Intrahepatic Cholangiocarcinoma in Hepatolithiasis

ABSTRACT

BACKGROUND: Hepatolithiasis is rarely associated with a cholangiocarcinoma and the etiologic relationship between them has not been proved. Hepatolithiasis is a risk factor for cholangiocarcinoma. Accurate preoperative diagnosis remains low, and the survival outcome is still dismal, despite improvements in imaging studies. METHODS: Eighteen cases of intrahepatic cholangiocarcinomas among the 522 cases undergoing treatments from Jan. 1984 to May 1998 for hepatolithiasis at the Department of Surgery, Kyung Hee University Hospital were reviewed. RESULTS: The patients had a significantly long duration of symptoms, a high incidence of previous biliary surgery, and a lower rate of preoperative diagnosis. The eighteen cases accounted for 3.4% of the hepatolithiasis cases and 8.5% of the cholangiocarcinomas. There were 17 women and 1 man, and the most prevalent age group was in the 5th and the 6th decades. HBsAg was positive in one case who had chronic hepatitis, 3 patients had clonorchiasis, and 2 patients had liver cirrhosis. CEA and CA19-9 were elevated in 42.9% (3/7) and 27.3% (3/11) of the patients. Various imaging studies, including ultrasonography, CT, choangiography, angiography, and ERCP were performed for diagnosis. The malignant lesions could not be detected preoperatively in 9 patients, and the presence of a coexisting malignant tumor was confirmed by frozen section or by permanent tissue pathology. The operative methods were as follows; a lobectomy in 4 patients, a segmentectomy in 4 patients, and a CBD resection for palliation or explo-laparotomy only in 4 patients because of multiple hepatic metastases. During the operation, the exact location of the stones and the gross pathology of the tumor were recorded in each case. The left side was more prevalent than the right. The mean survival was 15 months for resection group and 9 months for non resection group. CONCLUSIONS: The lower survival rates may be attributed to delayed diagnosis, lower diagnostic accuracy, and relatively fewer curative resections in the patients with stone-containing cholangiocarcinomas. Hepatolithiasis is one of the risk factors of a cholangiocarcinoma. During the diagnostic and operative procedures, we should not overlook a cholangiocarcinoma which can coexist with hepatolithiasis, and we should examine tumor markers, the results of imaging studies and tissue examinations, and the operative findings.