Surgical Treatment of Substernal Goiters

ABSTRACT

Substernal extension of a goiter into the thoracic inlet endows a generally benign neck mass with morbid potential. The reported incidence varies between 1% and 15% of all thyroidectomies performed. Whether all patients with a substernal goiter should undergo an operation or whether the operation should be performed selectively remains controversial. From May 1989 to March 1996, 10 patients underwent thyroidectomies for substernal goiters, and those cases of resected substernal goiters have been reviewed to access the symptoms and signs that brought patients to surgery the size and the position of goiter, the preoperative work-up, the risk associated with the operation, and the histopathologic state of the goiter. There were 3 male and 7 female patients, and their ages ranged from 40 to 68 years. The chief complaints were cervical mass (4), dyspnea (2), facial edema (1) and chest pain (1). No symtomatic cases (2) were also found. The average mass size was 8.4 cm (5-14 cm) and the average weight was 109 gm (41-350 gm). Although chest film was the most used, computed tomography was by far the most useful study. Thyroid scans often failed to show the substernal goiter. Fine-needle aspiration was not helpful because of inaccessibility. In the majority of the patients (7 cases), the substernal goiters were removed by a cervical incision. Three cases of goiters located deep to the carina level required a combined cervical and sternotomy approach or thoracotomy. In the cervical incision group, the complications were transient hypocalcemia (1) and unilateral recurrent laryngeal nerve injury (1). In the combined cervical and sternotomy approach or thoracotomy, unilateral recurrent laryngeal nerve injury (1) and bilateral recurrent laryngeal nerve injury (1) and mediastinitis (1) were the complications. An occult papillary carcinoma, which was not identified preoperatively, was found in one case. Removal was almost always accomplished via cervical incision and with low morbidity and no deaths. Also, the substernal goiters revealed unusual symptoms and signs, such as dyspnea, facial edema and chest pain, compared to usual thyoid goiters and were relatively bigger in size. In conclusion, most substernal goiter above the carinal level could be removed by cervical incision with a low rate of complication. The threat of compression, the substantial chance of malignancy, and the safety of resection mean that the presence of a substernal goiter is an indication for surgery.