Anti-sliding plating for Letenneur type Ⅰ Hoffa fractures / 中华创伤骨科杂志

ABSTRACT

Objective To explore the anti-sliding plating for Hoffa fractures by comparing the me-chanical properties of anti-sliding plates and cancellous bone screws. Methods Twenty cases of the same type of Hoffa fracture in the model femur were randomly divided into 4 even groups. Group A used 2 antegrade cancellous bone screws; Group B used 2 retrograde cancellous bone screws forwards; Group C used anti-sliding plate and locking screw fixation; Group D used anti-sliding plate and cancellous bone screw fixation. All the samples were subjected to the cycle fatigue and the maximum failure load tests. Results The fatigue test revealed no significant difference in the mean maximum displacements at the 10, 100, 1000, 10 000 cycles between the 4 groups. In the maximum failure load test, there were significant differences between Group A [(1224±72) N] and Groups C and D [(2183±227) N and (2124±235) N], as well as between Groups B [(1405±235) N] and Groups C and D; there was no significant difference between Group A and Group B, neither between Group C and Group D, Conclusions In the initial period after secure fixation for Hoffa fractures, anti-sliding plates and cancellous bone screws can all provide satisfactory mechanical stability and strength. But anti-sliding plating is recommended for cases of long healing expected, patients with great body mass index, and patients with poor compliance.