Biomechanical study on clavicle intramedullary nail / 中国医师进修杂志

ABSTRACT

ObjectiveTo discuss the biomechanical properties of clavicle intramedullarynail in fixing middle fracture of clavicle and compare with the traditional plate and screw and single Kirschner wire,in order to provide scientific evidence for clinical application.MethodsFifteen adult cadaver were collected to make middle fracture of clavicle models.According to the clinical operation methods,the fracture models were divided into three groups with 5 specimens eachclavicle intramedullary nail group,plate and screwfixation group,and Kirschner wire internal fixation group.Biomechanical properties of three groups were tested and compared by experimental stress analysis method.ResultsIn the load 1000 N,the bending strength and bending stiffness of clavicle intramedullary nail group[ (57.41±4.72),( 2.28±0.17) N ] had no significant difference compared with those of plate and screw fixation group[(58.50 ±t4.14),(2.26 ±0.20) N ] (P ＞ 0.05),while had statistical significance compared with Kirschner wire internal fixation group [(51.14±4.32),(1.54±0.16) N] (P ＜ 0.05).The bending strength and bending stiffness had statistical significance between plate and screw fixation group and Kirschner wire internal fixation group (P＜ 0.05).In the torsional mechanical test,torque of clavicle intramedullary nail group had no significant difference compared with plate and screw fixation group (P ＞ 0.05 ),but had statistical significance compared with Kirschner wire internal fixation group (F =14.88,P ＜0.05).In compression test of the clavicle,the compression limit load of clavicle intramedullary nail grotup [ ( 1246±87) N ] had no statistical significance compared with plate and screw fixation group [ ( 1348±121 ) N ] ( P ＞ 0.05 ),and had significant difference compared with Kirschner wire internal fixation group [ ( 870±72 ) N ] (F =14.74,P ＜ 0.05 ).Conclusions Clavicle intramedullary nailing for treating middle fracture of clavicle can provide better biomechanical strength,stiffness and stability.Meanwhile as a minimally invasive operation,this operation method is feasible.Compared to other internal fixation methods,it has certain advantages.