Meta analysis of the bacteria culture results after conjunctiva sac irrigation by two common disinfectant / 中华检验医学杂志

ABSTRACT

Objective To provide strong evidence for sterilization standardization by comparing the results of bacteria culture after conjunctiva sac irrigation by gentamicin and povidone-iodine (PVI) and analyzing the sterilization effect of these two common disinfectant.Methods Six randomized control trials comparing the sterilization effect between gentamicin and PVI in conjunctiva sac irrigation were retrieved through the following databasesPubmed,Embase,Cochrane Library,WANFANG DATA,CNKI and VIP database.Relative Risk (RR) was set as the effect indexes to evaluating the conjunctiva sac bacterial-culture results before and after irritation.The data of these articles were processed with Meta analysis by random model.The side effects of both dilutions were also compared using the descriptive analysis.Results Before irrigation,bacteria in the sac were mostly gram-positive coccus,among which Staphylococcus epidermidis and Staphylococcus aureus were most common.The detection rate of these two bacteria were 30.5％ (226/740) and 2.4％ (18/740),and the constituent ratio were 65.5％ and 5.2％ respectively.After irrigation,the number of the bacteria was decreased dramatically,but could not be totally eliminated.There was no significant difference in sterilization effect between gentamicin and PVI after conjunctiva sac irrigation.The weighted average value of RR was 0.51 with 95％ confidence interval (CI) in (0.25,1.06),P =0.07.Comparing to gentamicin,PVI was less comfortable after conjunctiva sac irrigation,but when the concentration was regulated,it would be acceptable by patients and didn't affect surgeries.Conclusions There was no significant difference in sterilization effect between gentamicin and PVI in conjunctiva sac irrigation.The side effect of PVI was minor in low concentration.PVI is more specific to the bacteria species than gentamicin.Using PVI was recommended in preoperation sterilization.