Comparison of different operative approach on benign ovarian removal and the characters of Yin way of operation / 中国综合临床

ABSTRACT

Objective To investigate the clinical effect of abdominal operation,laparoscopic operation and vaginal operation on treating ovarian cysts in order to summarize the characteristics of Yin type way operation. Methods Two hundreds and twenty-six patients with benign ovarian cysts were selected as our subjects and they were hospitalized from Jan. 2006 to Dec. 2012 in the First People's Hospital of Shangqiu. Of 226 patients,there were 77 cases with laparoscopic operation( laparoscopic group),75 cases with vaginal operation(transvaginal group),and 74 cases with traditional open operation(abdominal group). The information of operation periods,intraoperative blood loss volum,postoperative analgesia,postoperative exhaust time and hospitalization days,and the rate of postoperative complication were collected. All the patients were followed-up at 1 or 3 months after surgery. Results Operation periods and bleeding volume in vaginal group was(41. 71 ± 16. 92)min and(33. 11 ± 20. 19)ml,less than that in laparoscopic((50. 73 ± 18. 71)min,(38. 21 ± 18. 73)ml)and abdominal group((61. 81 ± 19. 75)min.(107. 29 ± 41. 27)ml)and the difference was significant. Meanwhile,gastrointestinal function recovery in vaginal group was(12. 19 ± 4. 17)h,less than that other two groups(15. 43 ± 4. 31)h and(30. 00 ± 6. 21)h). In addition,shorter hospitalization period was also less than that of other two groups((4. 38 ± 1. 30)d vs.(5. 60 ± 0. 50)d vs.(8. 50 ± 2. 00)d;P 0. 05 ). Conclusion The approaches of transvaginal operation and laparoscopy operation treating the ovarian cyst have their advantages and disadvantages. It is better to accurately understand the operation indications and then achieve the best therapeutic effect with minimal trauma.