Comparison of the effect of ERCP/S +LC and LCBDE in the treatment of cholecystolithiasis patients with concurrent choledocholith / 中国基层医药

ABSTRACT

Objective To compare the effect of endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography sphincterot-omy plus laparoscopic cholecystectomy(ERCP/S +LC)and laparoscopic common bile duct exploration(LCBDE)in the treatment of cholecystolithiasis patients with concurrent choledocholith.Methods Retrospective analysis was made of information of 280 cholecystolithiasis patients with concurrent choledocholith,who were randomly divided into group A (n =60)and group B (n =220).group A was arranged with LCBDE and group B was treated ERCP/S +LC. The operation time,hospital stay after operation,hospitalization fee,size of common bile duct calculi,stone clearance rate and the incidence of postoperative complications were compared.Results The operation time,hospital stay after operation,hospitalization fee,size of the common bile duct calculi,stone clearance rate and the incidence of postopera-tive complications of group A &B were (95.58 ±22.66)m vs.(87.46 ±40.25)m,(15.18 ±5.46)d vs.(14.32 ± 4.21)d,(2.45 ±0.32)ten thousand yuan vs.(2.89 ±0.64)ten thousand yuan,(1.12 ±0.34)cm vs.(1.39 ± 0.38)cm,96.6% vs.91% and 1.6% vs.3.2%.There was no significant difference in calculus clearance rate between the two treatments(χ2 =1.44,P >0.05 ).Patients in LCBDE group spent slightly less on hospitalization expenses than patients in ERCP/S +LC group,but there was no significant difference shown(t =0.923,P >0.05). Patients in ERCP/S +LC group had suffered a relatively high incidence of complications than patients in LCBDE group,and significant difference was found(χ2 =4.17,P <0.05).Conclusion Both LCBDE and ERCP/S +LC are effective minimally invasive therapies for concurrent cholecystolithiasis and choledocholith,and should be clinically applied in accordance with their specific characteristics.