Relationship between crown form of upper central incisors and papilla filling in Chinese Han-nationality youth / 北京大学学报(医学版)

ABSTRACT

Objective:To explore a crown form classification method for upper central incisor which is more objective and scientific than traditional classification method based on the standardized photography technique.To analyze the relationship between crown form of upper central incisors and papilla filling in periodontally healthy Chinese Han-nationality youth.Methods:In the study,180 periodontally healthy Chinese youth (75 males,and 105 females )aged 20 -30 (24.3 ±4.5)years were included.With the standardized upper central incisor photography technique,pictures of 360 upper central incisors were ob-tained.Each tooth was classified as triangular,ovoid or square by 13 experienced specialist majors in prothodontics independently and the final classification result was decided by most evaluators in order to ensure objectivity.The standardized digital photo was also used to evaluate the gingival papilla filling situation.The papilla filling result was recorded as present or absent according to naked eye observation. The papilla filling rates of different crown forms were analyzed.Statistical analyses were performed with SPSS 19.0.Results:The proportions of triangle,ovoid and square forms of upper central incisor in Chinese Han-nationality youth were 31.4% (113 /360),37.2% (134 /360)and 31.4% (113 /360 ), respectively ,and no statistical difference was found between the males and females.Average κvalue be-tween each two evaluators was 0.381.Average κvalue was raised up to 0.563 when compared with the final classification result.In the study,24 upper central incisors without contact were excluded,and the papilla filling rates of triangle,ovoid and square crown were 56.4% (62 /110),69.6% (87 /125 ), 76.2% (77 /101)separately.The papilla filling rate of square form was higher (P =0.007 ).Conclu-sion:The proportion of clinical crown form of upper central incisor in Chinese Han-nationality youth is obtained.Compared with triangle form,square form is found to favor a gingival papilla that fills the inter-proximal embrasure space.The consistency of the present classification method for upper central incisor is not satisfying,which indicates that a new classification method,more scientific and objective than the present one,is to be found.