Case-control Study on Small Splint and Plaster External Fixation after Closed Manipulative Reduction in the Treatment of Elderly Type C Colles Fractures / 中国中医药信息杂志

ABSTRACT

Objective To compare the clinical effects of small splint fixation after closed manipulative reduction with plaster external fixation in the treatment of elderly type C Colles fractures.Methods Totally 96 elderly patients with type C Colles fractures were randomly divided into two groups, 48 patients in each group. Both groups were treated with closed manipulative reduction. The fractures were externally fixed with splint in the treatment group, and those were externally fixed with pipe plaster in the control group. The figure of radius length, palmar tilt and ulnar deviation were detected respectively in pre-reduction, the same day with reduction, and the day when external fixation was removed (6th week), in order to evaluated the drop of anatomical position. The therapeutic effects were evaluated according to Gartland-Werley wrist score when external fixation was taken off after 6 months.Results In both groups, figures of radius length, palmar tilt and ulnar deviation evidently increased in the day after reduction and the day of external fixation removal, compared with pre-reduction (P<0.05). Compared with the day after reduction, the radius length, palmar tilt and ulnar deviation of the day of external fixation removal all dropped in both groups (P<0.05). But the drop degree in control group was significantly higher than treatment group (P<0.05). For the joint function, 9 cases for excellent, 26 for good, 6 for fair, and 4 for bad in the therapy group. The excellent and good rate was 77.8% (35/45). In the control group, 4 cases for excellent, 22 for good, 10 for fair and 9 for bad. The excellent and good rate was 57.8% (26/45). The curative effect of treatment group was remarkably superior to control group (P<0.05).Conclusion Closed manipulative reduction combined with splint external fixation is more effective than pipe plaster in treatment of elderly type C Colles fractures.