Clinical Application of Sentinel Node Biopsy in T1 or Less Breast Cancers. Is it Effective or Feasible?

ABSTRACT

BACKGROUND: Sentinel node biopsy has emerged recently as an alternative to routine axillary node dissection in predicting axillary nodal metastasis, and various studies have shown its effectiveness in patients with breast cancer. However, there have been some controversies in clinical application because of its high false negative rate. METHODS: One hundred forty patients with breast cancer underwent operative management in consideration of the results of sentinel node biopsies at the department of surgery, Samsung Medical Center, between Sep. 1995 and Jul. 1998. Sixty-three patients with tumor sizes of T1 or less were retrospectively evaluated. Intraoperative lymphatic mappings using vital blue dye and using a combination of vital dye and a 99mTc-antimony sulphide colloid were performed for 53 patients and 10 patients, respectively. RESULTS: Patient's ages were in the third decade for 2 patients (3.2%), in the fourth decade for 18 (28.6%), in the fifth decade for 18 (28.6%), in the sixth decade for 13 (20.6%) and in the seventh decade for 12 (19.0%). An infiltrating ductal carcinoma was observed in 51 patients (81.0%), an intraductal carcinoma in 8 (12.6%), a medullary carcinoma in 2 (3.2%), an infiltrating lobular carcinoma in 1 (1.6%) and a mucinous carcinoma in 1 (1.6%). Sentinel node was detected in 42 of the 53 patients (79.2%) evaluated with vital blue dye only and in 10 of the 10 patients (100%) evaluated with a combination of vital dye and a 99mTc-antimony sulphide colloid. Among the group of T1 or less, the sensitivity rates of vital dye and the combination were 81.8% and 100% and their accuracies of them were 95.2% and 100%, respectively. The false negative rates for all cases were 12.2% and 8.3%, respectively, but they were decreased to 6.1% and even 0% for the group of T1 or less. CONCLUSIONS: The detection rate and the accuracy of sentinel node biopsy were enhanced in patients with T1 or less breast cancer. If a combination of vital dye and a radioisotope is used, sentinel node biopsy may be applied clinically in limited patients such as those with T1 or less breast cancer.