Clinical effects of the open versus closed high tibial osteotomy on knee osteoarthritis / 中华老年医学杂志

ABSTRACT

Objective:To compare clinical effects of the open versus closed high tibial osteotomy on knee osteoarthritis.Methods:A total of 100 patients with knee osteoarthritis admitted to our hospital from May 2018 to May 2019 were included.They were randomly divided into groups A and B(n=50, each group)according to the principle of random and double blind.Patients in group A received the medial opening high tibial osteotomy, and group B were treated with lateral closed high tibial osteotomy.The changes in the Lysholm knee score, hospital for special surgery(HSS)knee score and complications were compared between the two groups before and 1 year after surgery.The correction angle, the change of patella height before and after operation, and the change of posterior slope of tibial plateau were compared between the two groups.Results:Before and after treatment, Lysholm scores were(63.51±5.47)and(90.98±5.84)( t=24.275, P=0.000), and HSS scores were(51.85±4.68)and(88.64±5.87)( t=34.652, P=0.000). Lysholm scores were(62.98±6.14)and(91.52±6.54 9)( t=22.497, P=0.000), and HSS scores were(52.05±5.16)and(89.54±5.15)( t=36.362, P=0.000)in group A and B, .After treatment, all index were significantly improved in the two groups, but there was no statistical difference between the two groups( P>0.05). In group A, the posterior slope of tibial plateau were(8.75±1.48)° and(10.25±1.65)°( t=4.785, P=0.000)and the patellar height was(0.890±0.031)and(0.898±0.032)( t=1.270, P=0.207)before and after treatment.Before and after treatment in group B, the posterior slope of tibial plateau were(8.69±1.53)° and(5.26±1.21)°( t=12.434, P=0.000)and the patellar height were(0.889±0.047)and(0.821±0.039)( t=7.873, P=0.000). The correction angle, posterior slope of tibial plateau and patella height were significantly improved after treatment in the two groups.While, the decreases of posterior slope of tibial plateau and patella height were better in the group B than in the group A( P<0.05). There was no significant difference in the incidence of complications between the two groups( P>0.05). Conclusions:For treatment of knee osteoarthritis patients, the medial opening high tibial osteotomy and lateral closed high tibial osteotomy have the same exact effect and high safety, but the two methods have their own advantages and disadvantages in clinical treatment.And the appropriate surgical treatment can be selected according to the characteristics of patients.