Systematic Review on Safety of Chinese Medicines Combined with Tripterygium wilfordii Preparations in Treatment of Rheumatoid Arthritis and Exploration on Underlying Network Regulatory Mechanisms of Enhancing Efficacy and Reducing Toxicity / 中国实验方剂学杂志

ABSTRACT

ObjectiveTo systematically evaluate the safety of Chinese medicines combined with Tripterygium wilfordii polyglycoside tablets/Tripterygium wilfordii tablets （TWPT/TWT） in the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis （RA）， and to explore the network regulatory mechanisms of enhancing efficacy and reducing toxicity of commonly used combination regimes. MethodThe literature involving the adverse reactions of TWPT/TWT in treating RA was searched and collected from three Chinese databases （CNKI， Wanfang Data， VIP） and three English databases （PubMed， Cochrane Library， Embase） from the inception of the databases to July 2021. All studies were assessed by the Cochrane risk of bias tool， and the data were extracted and analyzed by Stata 15.0. Furthermore， Integrative Pharmacology-based Research Platform of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2.0 （TCMIP v2.0，http：//www.tcmip.cn/） was used to construct a "drug target-symptom gene of efficacy and toxicity" interaction network， to explore the underlying network regulatory mechanisms of enhancing efficacy and reducing toxicity of common T. wilfordii preparation combinations. ResultA total of 2 132 articles on Chinese medicines combined with TWPT/TWT in the treatment of RA were retrieved， and 18 of them were finally included. The systematic review showed that the adverse reactions of TWPT/TWT against RA mainly occurred in the digestive system， blood system， and reproductive system， of which digestive system had the highest incidence of damages. However， the combination with Chinese medicines effectively alleviated the adverse reactions caused by TWPT/TWT ［RR （95% CI）=0.45 （0.30， 0.66）， P<0.01］. In addition， the subgroup analysis indicated that the age of RA patients， course of disease， combination regimen， medication dosage and duration of treatment all affected the occurrence of adverse reactions of TWPT/TWT. It was found in clinical studies that total glucosides of paeony （TGP） and TWPT/TWT was most widely combined， and the effect of TGP in reducing TWPT/TWT-induced hepatotoxicity was also more significant than that of other Chinese medicines. Moreover， taking this combination regime as an example， this paper explored the "efficacy-toxicity" association mechanisms of TGP-TWPT/TWT against RA. The "drug target-symptom gene of efficacy and toxicity" interaction network revealed that the core network targets of TGP-TWPT/TWT enhanced efficacy and reduced toxicity mainly through regulating immunity-inflammation-related pathways， metabolic pathways and cell signal transduction. Especially， interleukin-4 （IL-4） and interleukin-13 （IL-13）， which were involved in the "immunity-inflammation" module， were the common targets of TGP-TWPT/TWT to enhance efficacy and reduce toxicity. The endogenous sterols， bile acids and bile salts， insulin secretion and other metabolic pathways in the "body metabolism" module were closely associated with the mechanisms of TWPT/TWT inducing hepatotoxicity and TGP reducing hepatotoxicity. While cell function regulation pathways， such as stem cell factor （SCF）/tyrosine kinase receptor （KIT） signaling pathway and phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase （PI3K）/protein kinase B （Akt）signaling pathway were involved in both anti-RA effects and hepatotoxicity of TWPT/TWT. ConclusionClinical application of suitable Chinese medicines combined with TWPT/TWT in the treatment of RA can effectively improve the rheumatism and reduce the adverse reactions of TWPT/TWT， and TGP-TWPT/TWT has the most significant toxicity-reducing effect. Further biological network-based investigation indicates that the toxicity-reducing mechanism of TGP-TWPT/TWT may be related to the regulation of interleukin signaling pathway and bile acid metabolism pathway， and the synergistic efficacy-enhancing effect of the combination may be achieved by acting on interleukin signaling pathway and cell function regulation pathway.