Postoperative Comfort Score after Septoplasty among Patients Undergoing Nasal Packing versus Suturing of the Septal Flap by Modified Technique without Packing : A Randomized Controlled Trial

ABSTRACT

Background: Septal surgery is one of the most common surgical procedures performed by an Otorhinolaryngeal surgeon since ancient times. Various modifications in the approach, changing concept of conserving septal cartilage, use of an endoscope and good antibiotics to control postoperative infection have played a key role in controlling the complication rates but still, one thing which is mostly practiced worldwide is nasal packing in the postoperative period which is a nightmare for many patients, as the pain threshold varies from patient to patient. It also causes dryness of mouth, throat irritation, facial heaviness, headache, excessive watering from eyes, aural fullness. There is a lack of proper evidence to prove whether nasal packing really decreases postoperative hemorrhage as the incision is properly approximated and sutured. The main reason for nasal packing was an approximation of nasal septal flap thereby reducing the chances of septal Haematoma and stabilization of septal flap in the midline. The present study has been taken to study and compare postoperative nasal packing and modified quilting suture of the septal flap without the nasal pack. Material and Methods: This one-year prospective comparative study was conducted on 149 patients who underwent septoplasty with 3 months follow-up. One group had Postoperative nasal packing and the other had only modified septal flap suturing without the nasal pack. Results: Out of the total of 149 patients, 88 underwent nasal packing in the postoperative period and 61 patients had undergone suture of the nasal septal flap without nasal packing. A statistically significant value of VAS score was found in the non-packing group of 61 patients, where the average postoperative VAS score was 1.46 against 3.7 among the packing group of 88 patients. An unpaired t-test was applied and a value of 15.431 was obtained with a pvalue less than 0.001. No cases presented with septal perforation in the postoperative period in patients without a nasal pack and there were 2 cases (2.2%) of septal perforation in the nasal packing group. There was no significant bleeding in the postoperative period in both groups of patients. Conclusion: Stabilization of the nasal septal flap by modified quilting technique is better option after septoplasty with good comfort score.