Effect comparison of nonoperative and operative treatment of fracture of scapular neck / 中国医师进修杂志

ABSTRACT

Objective To explore the effective method for treatment of fracture of scapular neck.Methods A retrospective analysis of 40 patients with fractures of scapular neck was done.The patients were treated by operation or non-operation from August 1995 to August 2005.According to the degree of displacement,40 cases included 22 mild displaced fractures(≤10 mm,≤40°),and 18 severe displaced fractures (＞10 mm,＞40°),26 cases were non-operation and 14 cases by operation.Herscovici score was adopted.Results Forty patients were followed up for 1-3 years.Among 26 patients treated by non-operation,Herscovici score showed that 16 cases achieved the excellent result,2 cases good,3 cases fair and 5 cases poor.of 14 patients treated by operation,Herscovici score showed that 12 cases achieved the excellent result,2 cases good. Conclusion Fractures of scapular neck with mild displacement can be treated by non-operation while fractures of scapular with severe displacement or associated with ipsilateral clavical fractures should be treated by operation to reconstruct the stabihty of shoulder and minimize the complications.