Comparison of conventional X-ray fluoroscopy and ISO-C3D navigation for placement of sacroiliac screws in treatment of posterior pelvic ring fractures / 中华创伤杂志

ABSTRACT

Objective To compare the effect of ISO-C3D navigation and conventional C-arm fluoroscopy in iliosacral screws insertion for treatment of posterior pelvic ring injuries.Methods Sixty-five patients with posterior pelvic ring injuries managed by minimally invasive percutaneous iliosacral screws from June 2006 to January 2012 were reviewed.There were 37 males and 28 females,at age range of 18-63 years (mean 35.9 years).Pelvic fracture classification based on Tile system was type B1 in 10 cases,type B2 in 15,type B3 in nine,type C1 in 18 and type C2 in 13.Patients were divided into ISO-C3D navigation group (Group A,n =35) and C-arm fluoroscopy group (Group B,n =30) according to the difference in intraoperative fluoroscopy methods.Intraoperative fluoroscopy time,time cost in inserting a screw,patient satisfaction rate for bone reduction,bone union time and excellent-good rate of postoperative function were recorded.Results Eighty cannulated screws were inserted for the 65 patients.Average fluoroscopy time and time cost in inserting a screw were shorter in Group A than in Group B (P ＜0.01),but there was no statistical difference between the two gronps in patient satisfaction rate for bone reduction.No patient presented with infection,vascular nerve injury or other complications.Follow-up was 6-24 months (mean 12.7 months) for all the patients.Functional recovery showed no statistical difference between the two groups at postoperative 6 months.All fractures were healed and no delayed union or nonunion happened.Conclusion As compared with conventional C-arm fluoroscopy,computer-navigated surgery can reduce fluoroscopy time and improve screw insertion accuracy.