Comparison of the efficiency of the pelvic packing and the angioembolization for controlling pelvic fracture hemorrhoea / 中华骨科杂志

ABSTRACT

Objective To compare the efficiency of the pelvic packing and the angioembolization for controlling pelvic fracture hemorrhoea.Methods Data of 43 consecutive patients with pelvic fracture hemorrhoea who were enrolled in our hospital from April 2004 to April 2012 were retrospectively analyzed.There were 26 patients who had undergone pelvic packing,including 15 men and 11 women with an average age of 41.6 years (packing group).The causes of the fractures included road accident injury (12 cases),falling injury (8 cases) and the bruise injury caused by heavy object (6 cases).According to the Tile classification,there were 16 cases of type B and 10 cases of type C.There were 4 cases with open pelvic fractures and 5 associated with the abdomen trauma.There were 17 patients who had undergone angioembolization,including 10 men and 7 women,with an average age of 39.2 years (angio group).The causes included road accident injury (9 cases),falling injury (5 cases) and the bruise injury caused by heavy object (3 cases).There were 2 cases of type A,11 cases of type B and 4 cases of type C.The ISS,operation time,blood transfusion and the complication were all recorded respectively.Results For the packing group,the average ISS was 52.4± 15.3,and the operation time was 42.0±2.1 min.The blood transfusion was 15.0±4.7 U before the surgery and 6.0±1.6 U in the first 24 h after the surgery.The mean ICU stay was (8.0±3.6)d.And for the angio group,the average ISS was 40.6±12.4,and the operation time was 86.0±3.6 min.The blood transfusion before the surgery was 13.0±5.4 U vs.10.0±2.1 U in the first 24 h after the surgery,and the ICU stay was 11.0± 1.8 d.2 cases in the packing group underwent repacking and 6 cases in the angio group had received second angioembolization.Five cases died in the packing group but no one died of the hemorrhoea while 4 cases died in the angio group with one died of the hemorrhoea.There were 3 cases in the packing group suffering the deep infection while 1 suffered the superficial infection in the angio group.Conclusion The efficiency of the pelvic packing is higher than the angioembolization because of its shorter operation time and ICU stay,more effective blood control,less blood transfusion after surgery,and lower postoperative mortality.It is very suitable for the application at the local hospital and the national conditions nowadays.