Prognostic analysis of 130 patients with nasal and Waldeyer ring NK/T cell lymphoma treated by radiotherapy and/or chemotherapy / 中华放射肿瘤学杂志

ABSTRACT

Objective To observe the clinical effects of radiotherapy and/or chemotherapy in the treatment of nasal and Waldeyer ring natural killer (NK)/T cell lymphoma and to analyze the prognostic factors.Methods Between January 20,2000 and December 21,2010,109 patients with nasal NK/T cell lymphoma and 21 patients with Waldeyer ring NK/T cell lymphoma were admitted to our hospital; the diagnosis was confirmed by immunohistochemistry.According to the Ann Arbor staging system,116 patients were classified as stage Ⅰ E,and 14 as stage Ⅱ E.Thirty patients received radiotherapy alone;2 patients received chemotherapy alone; 98 patients received radiochemotherapy.Results The follow-up rate was 100％.Seventy-eight patients were followed up for at least 5 years.The complete remission (CR) rate was 89.2％ in all patients.The CR rates of stage Ⅰ E patients and stage Ⅱ E patients were 88.8％ and 92.9％,respectively (x2 =0.02,P =0.837).The CR rates of patients receiving radiotherapy alone and patients receiving radiochemotherapy were 86％ and 96％,respectively (x2 =1.44,P =0.230).The five-year overall survival (OS) rate and disease-free survival (DFS) rate of all patients were 58.0％ and 57.2％,respectively.The five-year OS rates of stage Ⅰ E patients and stage Ⅱ E patients were 60.6％ and 36.3％,respectively (x2 =0.25,P =0.615) ;the five-year DFS rates of stage Ⅰ E patients and stage Ⅱ E patients were 59.7％ and 36.3％,respectively (x2 =0.21,P =0.648).The five-year OS rates of patients receiving radiotherapy alone and patients receiving radiochemotherapy were 70.0％ and 48.4％,respectively (x2 =0.01,P =0.933) ; the five-year DFS rates of patients receiving radiotherapy alone and patients receiving radiochemotherapy were 65.6％ and 48.4％,respectively (x2 =0.09,P =0.764).The grade 3-4 toxicity rates of radiotherapy alone and radiochemotherapy were 6.7％ and 54.1％,respectively (x2 =41.38,P=0.002).The radiation dose to the primary lesion and Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group (ECOG) score were correlated with OS (x2 =3.1 8,P =0.005 ; x2 =2.97,P =0.008).Conclusions The clinical effect of radiochemotherapy is similar to that of radiotherapy alone in the patients with stage ⅠE and ⅡE nasal and Waldeyer ring NK/T cell lymphoma,but radiochemotherapy has higher toxicity than radiotherapy alone.The radiation dose to the primary lesion and ECOG score are the influential factors for OS.