A Comparison of Fusion Rates and Clinical Results Between Single-Level Cervical Corpectomy and Two-Level Discectomies and Fusion with Plating / 대한척추외과학회지

ABSTRACT

STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective study. OBJECTIVES: To compare the radiographic and clinical results of two-level discectomies and fusion with plating and a singlelevel corpectomy with plating. SUMMARY OF LITERATURE REVIEW Previous studies of multisegment fusion have shown decreased fusion rates correlating with the number of increasing levels, and the use of anterior plate in multilevel fusions may be warranted because of the increased pseudoarthrosis rates. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total 30 consecutive patients operated at our institutions between Oct. 1995 and Mar. 2000 were entered into this study. Twenty patients with cervical spondylosis had performed two-level discectomies with tricortical bone grafts and plating, and ten patients with cervical myelopathy had a single-level corpectomy with plating. Follow up averaged 2.4 years, radiographic and clinical follow up evaluation was performed. We assessed the radiologic value by postoperative and follow-up sagittal radiograms at monthly intervals until fusion was judged to be solid, and the clinical evaluation by Odom's criteria. RESULTS: Comparing the radiographic data between the two groups of patients, the values were not different. Of the thirty patients, no non-unions occurred in all patients. The average amount of graft collapse for patients with single-level corpectomy with plating or a two-level discectomy with plating was less than 1 mm for both groups. And, the average amount of kyphotic deformity was less than 1 degrees for both groups. The clinical results of the operations graded by Odom's criteria are no statistical significance between the two groups. (p < 0.9, chi test) CONCLUSION: There is no significant statistical differences for two-level discectomies with plating and a single-level corpectomy with plating in fusion rate and clinical results, and each methods can be used a viable alternative procedure by anatomical structure that were primarily causing the neural impingement with more reliable fusion rates.