Four Patients with Calf Cramps who did not Respond to Shakuyakukanzoto but Responded well to Sokeikakketsuto / 日本東洋医学雑誌

ABSTRACT

We encountered 4 cases of calf cramps in which the herbal mixture shakuyakukanzoto was ineffective but another herbal mixture sokeikakketsuto was effective. In case 1, the patient was a 73-year-old man. He had a history of calf cramps, and started experiencing calf cramps more frequently about1month before he made his first visit to our department. Shakuyakukanzoto (7.5g/day) was initially prescribed, but the frequency of cramps did not change. Then, shakuyakukanzoto was replaced with sokeikakketsuto (7.5g/day), and this resulted in rapid alleviation of the symptom. In case 2, the patient was a 67-year-old woman undergoing outpatient care for shoulder stiffness, low back pain, etc. She started experiencing calf cramps at night and underwent shakuyakukanzoto (7.5g/day) treatment. The frequency of cramps did not change, and hence, shakuyakukanzoto was replaced with sokeikakketsuto (2.5g at bedtime). The symptom was alleviated in response to this therapy. In case 3, the patient was a 66-year-old woman undergoing treatment for low back pain at our department. She experienced calf cramps and was treated with shakuyakukanzobushito (3.0g/day). The response was poor, and the herbal mixture was replaced with sokeikakketsuto (7.5g/day), which resulted in the disappearance of her cramps. In case 4, the patient was a 75-year-old man undergoing treatment for a cold sensation in the left leg. He experienced calf cramps and was treated with shakuyakukanzobushito (1.5g/day). This therapy resulted in only temporary relief from the symptom. After the herbal mixture was replaced with sokeikakketsuto (2.5g/day), the cramps disappeared rapidly. Thus, sokeikakketsuto, which improves blood flow and is thought to manifest analgesic effects, may be used for treating patients with calf cramps who do not respond to shakuyakukanzoto.