Superior versus anterior reconstruction plate internal fixation for middle clavicular fractures in old patients: a comparative study / 中华创伤杂志

ABSTRACT

Objective To compare the effect of anterior and superior reconstruction plate internal fixation in treatment of middle clavicular fractures in the old patients.Methods Thirty-nine old patients with middle clavicular fractures received anterior and superior reconstruction plate internal fixation treatment,respectively.There were 19 males and 20 females at average age of 66.7 years.The operation time,intraoperative blood loss and healing time were observed and compared in two groups.According to the Constant scoring system,shoulder functional evaluation was made at half a year after operation and the latest follow-up.Results All the patients were followed up for 10-32 months (average 18.7 months).Of the two groups,there was no statistical significance in aspects of healing time and Constant score at half a year after operation and the latest follow-up ( P ＞0.05 ).The complication of superior reconstruction plate internal fixation group was significant higher than that of anterior reconstruction plate internal fixation group,while the anterior reconstruction plate internal fixation group had shorter operation time and less intraoperative blood loss in comparison with the superior reconstruction plate internal fixation group ( P ＜ 0.05).Conclusion As for the middle clavicular fractures in the old patients,both anterior and superior reconstruction plate internal fixation can obtain satisfactory curative effect.With shorter operation time,less intraoperative bleeding and less complications,anterior reconstruction plate internal fixation is a much reliable treatment for middle clavicle fractures in the old patients and deserves wider application.