Comparison of percutaneous resection and laparoscopic deroofing of renal cysts / 中华泌尿外科杂志

ABSTRACT

Objective To compare the short term clinical efficacy of percutaneous resection and laparoscopic deroofing of renal cysts.Methods From October 2013 to June 2016,the data from 39 cases with renal cysts were followed for approximately 22 months (ranging 5-36 months).Patients were randomized into two groups.In the resectoscopic group(17 pts),the mean age of those patients was 57 years (ranging 34-81 years).The mean size of these cysts was 6.4cm (ranging 5.4-8.2 cm).The mean preoperative creatinine was 66.5μmol/L (ranging 38.1-108.8μ mol/L).The mean preoperative sodium was 141.4μ mol/L(ranging 135.6-145.1μmol/L).The mean preoperative potassium was 4.0μmol/L (ranging 3.4-4.7 μmol/L).In the latter laparoscope (22pts),the mean age of these patients was 60 years (ranging 46-73 years).The mean size of these cysts was 6.8cm (ranging 4.3-8.9cm).The mean preoperative creatinine was 74.8μmol/L (ranging 48.6-141.9μmol/L).The mean preoperative sodium was 141.5μmol/L(ranging 135.0-146.1 μmol/L).The mean preoperative potassium was 4.0μmol/L (ranging 3.1-4.8μmol/L).The operative time,blood loss,days of drainage,hospital stay and complications were compared with the two groups.Results All of the 39 cases were accepted the procedure successfully without open conversion.Compared the resectoscopic group with Laparoscopic,the mean operative time was 29.7 min (ranging 15-50 min) and 63.0min (ranging 20-1 00 min),mean blood loss was 36.6ml(ranging 10-80 ml) and 60.4ml(ranging 10-200 ml),days of drainage was 2.3 days and 3.1 days,hospital stay was 3.7 days and 5.1 days,the mean postoperative creatinine was 67.4 μmol/L(ranging 43.8-95.5 μmol/L) and 68.9μmol/L(ranging 46.5-157.6 μmol/L),the mean postoperative sodium was 141.2μmol/L(ranging 136.0-147.2 μmol/L) and 141.6 μmol/L(ranging 136.0-147.2 μmol/L),the mean postoperative potassium was 3.8 μmol/L (ranging 3.2-4.3 μmol/L) and 3.8μmol/L (ranging 3.3-4.3 μmol/L).The overall postoperative pathology was renal cysts.All cases were followed for approximately 19 months (ranging 6-35 months) and 22 months (ranging 5-36 months) in reseetoscopic and laparoscopic group respectively.No cysts recurrence was found by ultrasound.Conclusions Compared with laparoscopic deroofing,use of resectoscopic technology significantly enhances the possibility of achieving better intraoperative results in all patients with renal cysts.Percutaneous resection of simple renal cysts is safe and feasible.