Comparison of Short-term Outcomes of Hand-assisted Laparoscopic,Laparoscopic-assisted and Open Colorectal Cancer Surgery / 中国医科大学学报

ABSTRACT

Objective To compare the short-term clinical outcomes of hand-assisted laparoscopic surgery(HALS),laparoscopic-assisted surgery (LAS)and open surgery(OS)for colorectal cancer treatment. Methods The clinical data of 74 patients underwent HALS,LAS and OS for colorectal cancer treatment between October 2011 and December 2015 were assessed retrospectively. All the surgeries were performed by the same surgical team. The intraoperative details,postoperative recovery,postoperative complications,oncologic results and cost were compared among the three groups. Results A total of 24 patients in HALS group,25 patients in LAS group and 25 patients in OS group were finally included. The gen-eral data and oncologic baseline were comparable among the three groups. The comparative results showed that the operative time increase d and in-cision length shortened gradually in OS group,HALS group and LAS group(P0.05). In terms of post-operative recovery,postoperative complications and oncologic results,there was no statistical difference between the three groups(P>0.05). As for cost,the total cost and operative cost of OS group were lower than HALS group and LAS group(P0.05). The material cost increase gradually in OS group ,HALS group and LAS group(P0.05). Conclusion HALS,LAS and OS are compen-satory with each other,and clinicians can choose the reasonable procedure according to personal proficiency and situation of patients.