Effect of the discrepancy of the dose calculation results of different algorithms on CyberKnife lung tumor treatment plan / 中华放射肿瘤学杂志

ABSTRACT

Objective To evaluate the effect of the discrepancy of the dose calculation results of different algorithms upon the CyberKnife lung tumor treatment plan,and assess the impact of tumor volume and location on the dose calculation results. Methods Thirty-two cases of lung tumors were treated with MultiPlan 5.2.1 planning system of CyberKnife VSI.Ray Tracing and Monte Carlo algorithms were adopted to calculate the dose distribution, and then the calculation results were statistically compared between two algorithms. Results For the enrolled cases,the calculation results of these two algorithms demonstrated that the deviation range of prescription dose coverage of planning target volume (PTV),conformal index,new conformal index and uniformity index were 0.93%~68. 80%, 0.87%~17. 21%,-212.38%~8. 27% and 0%~15. 17%, respectively. Conclusions In the CyberKnife treatment of lung tumors, the volume and location of tumors exert significant impact on the discrepancies of the dose calculation results of different algorithms. The smaller tumor volume and longer beam heterogeneity path are likely to generate a greater discrepancy. It is recommended to adopt or refer to the calculation results of Monte Carlo algorithm to deliver corresponding treatment.