Effect of compositional variation of dental MTA cements on setting time / 대한치과재료학회지

ABSTRACT

The long setting time of dental MTA (Mineral Trioxide Aggregate) cement is a major disadvantage in clinical use. In this study, the setting time (ST) of nine commercial MTA cements was tested according to the ISO 6876:2012 standard (n = 5).Materials evaluated were ProRoot MTA (PR), Ortho MTA (Ortho), Retro MTA (Retro), Endocem MTA (Endocem), Endoseal MTA (Endoseal), One-Fil (OF), MTA Cem (MC), EZ-Seal (EZ), and Biodentine (BD). XRD and XRF analysis were performed to evaluate the effect of composition on ST. Kruskal-Wallis test as a non-parametric ANOVA followed by Duncan’s post hoc test was used for statistical analysis. The ST was PR > EZ > OF > Ortho > Retro > MC > Endoseal > BD > Endocem in decreasing order (p < 0.001). PR showed the longest (369.4 min) and Endocem showed the shortest (2.4 min) ST. Endocem (2.4 min), BD (16.0 min) and Endoseal (47.0 min) contained calcium carbonate. MC (48.8 min), Retro (43.6 min), Ortho (65.0), and OF (165.4 min), which had the next short setting time, contained dicalcium aluminate. In EZ (182.4 min), dicalcium silicate was the main crystalline phase rather than tricalcium silicate, which contributes to the early strength, and it contained calcium sulfate. Endocem, which showed the shortest setting time, showed the smallest d90 particle size of 6.12 µm. The information obtained from this study would be helpful in developing a composition for controlling the setting time of MTA cement and selecting a product with a setting time suitable for each clinical case.