Your browser doesn't support javascript.
Performance Evaluation of Serial SARS-CoV-2 Rapid Antigen Testing During a Nursing Home Outbreak.
McKay, Susannah L; Tobolowsky, Farrell A; Moritz, Erin D; Hatfield, Kelly M; Bhatnagar, Amelia; LaVoie, Stephen P; Jackson, David A; Lecy, K Danielle; Bryant-Genevier, Jonathan; Campbell, Davina; Freeman, Brandi; Gilbert, Sarah E; Folster, Jennifer M; Medrzycki, Magdalena; Shewmaker, Patricia L; Bankamp, Bettina; Radford, Kay W; Anderson, Raydel; Bowen, Michael D; Negley, Jeanne; Reddy, Sujan C; Jernigan, John A; Brown, Allison C; McDonald, L Clifford; Kutty, Preeta K.
  • McKay SL; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Tobolowsky FA; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Moritz ED; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Hatfield KM; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Bhatnagar A; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • LaVoie SP; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Jackson DA; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Lecy KD; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Anchorage, Alaska (K.D.L.).
  • Bryant-Genevier J; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Campbell D; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Freeman B; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Gilbert SE; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Folster JM; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Medrzycki M; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Shewmaker PL; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Bankamp B; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Radford KW; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Anderson R; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Bowen MD; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Negley J; Georgia Department of Public Health, Atlanta, Georgia (J.N.).
  • Reddy SC; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Jernigan JA; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Brown AC; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • McDonald LC; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
  • Kutty PK; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia (S.L.M., F.A.T., E.D.M., K.M.H., A.B., S.P.L., D.A.J., J.B., D.C., B.F., S.E.G., J.M.F., M.M., P.L.S., B.B., K.W.R., R.A., M.D.B., S.C.R., J.A.J., A.C.B., L.C.M., P.K.K.).
Ann Intern Med ; 174(7): 945-951, 2021 07.
Article in English | MEDLINE | ID: covidwho-1318465
ABSTRACT

BACKGROUND:

To address high COVID-19 burden in U.S. nursing homes, rapid SARS-CoV-2 antigen tests have been widely distributed in those facilities. However, performance data are lacking, especially in asymptomatic people.

OBJECTIVE:

To evaluate the performance of SARS-CoV-2 antigen testing when used for facility-wide testing during a nursing home outbreak.

DESIGN:

A prospective evaluation involving 3 facility-wide rounds of testing where paired respiratory specimens were collected to evaluate the performance of the BinaxNOW antigen test compared with virus culture and real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). Early and late infection were defined using changes in RT-PCR cycle threshold values and prior test results.

SETTING:

A nursing home with an ongoing SARS-CoV-2 outbreak.

PARTICIPANTS:

532 paired specimens collected from 234 available residents and staff. MEASUREMENTS Percentage of positive agreement (PPA) and percentage of negative agreement (PNA) for BinaxNOW compared with RT-PCR and virus culture.

RESULTS:

BinaxNOW PPA with virus culture, used for detection of replication-competent virus, was 95%. However, the overall PPA of antigen testing with RT-PCR was 69%, and PNA was 98%. When only the first positive test result was analyzed for each participant, PPA of antigen testing with RT-PCR was 82% among 45 symptomatic people and 52% among 343 asymptomatic people. Compared with RT-PCR and virus culture, the BinaxNOW test performed well in early infection (86% and 95%, respectively) and poorly in late infection (51% and no recovered virus, respectively).

LIMITATION:

Accurate symptom ascertainment was challenging in nursing home residents; test performance may not be representative of testing done by nonlaboratory staff.

CONCLUSION:

Despite lower positive agreement compared with RT-PCR, antigen test positivity had higher agreement with shedding of replication-competent virus. These results suggest that antigen testing could be a useful tool to rapidly identify contagious people at risk for transmitting SARS-CoV-2 during nascent outbreaks and help reduce COVID-19 burden in nursing homes. PRIMARY FUNDING SOURCE None.
Subject(s)
Fulltext
Print
XML
PubMed Links
Search on Google

Full text: Available Collection: International databases Database: MEDLINE Main subject: Pandemics / COVID-19 Serological Testing / SARS-CoV-2 / COVID-19 / Antigens, Viral / Nursing Homes Type of study: Cohort study / Diagnostic study / Experimental Studies / Observational study / Prognostic study Topics: Long Covid Limits: Humans Country/Region as subject: North America Language: English Journal: Ann Intern Med Year: 2021 Document Type: Article

Similar

MEDLINE
LILACS
LIS
Fulltext
Print
XML
PubMed Links
Search on Google

Full text: Available Collection: International databases Database: MEDLINE Main subject: Pandemics / COVID-19 Serological Testing / SARS-CoV-2 / COVID-19 / Antigens, Viral / Nursing Homes Type of study: Cohort study / Diagnostic study / Experimental Studies / Observational study / Prognostic study Topics: Long Covid Limits: Humans Country/Region as subject: North America Language: English Journal: Ann Intern Med Year: 2021 Document Type: Article