STRAIN-SPECIFIC SEROLOGICAL RESPONSE FOLLOWING SARS-CoV-2 VOC INFECTION

ABSTRACT

Background: The emergence of new SARS-CoV-2 variants raises concerns whether preexisting artificial (vaccine-induced) and natural immunity from prior COVID-19 prevents re-infections. Here, we investigated the differences in primary humoral immune response following SARS-CoV-2 variants of concern (VOCs) infection and aimed to identify the key mutations involved in these differences. Methods: Patients with primary PCR-proven SARS-CoV-2 infection with no history of previous COVID-19 vaccination were included between October 2020 and May 2021 at Amsterdam UMC and via the Dutch SARS-CoV-2 sequence surveillance program. Serum was collected 4-8 weeks after symptom onset and tested for IgG binding and pseudovirus neutralization of the wild-type (WT, Wuhan/D614G), Alpha, Beta and Delta variants. Results: We included 51 COVID-19 patients, who were infected with the WT (n=20), Alpha (n=10), Beta (n=9) or Delta variant (n=12). Generally, the highest neutralization titers were against the autologous virus. After stratifying for hospitalization status, non-hospitalized patients infected with the WT (ID50 817) or Alpha (ID50 2524) variant showed the strongest geometric mean autologous neutralization, followed by the Delta variant (ID50 704) infected participants. By contrast, only one participant infected with the Beta variant showed strong autologous neutralization (median ID50 171). The VOCs also differed in their ability to induce cross-neutralizing responses, with WT-infected patients showing the broadest immune response, followed by Alpha, Delta and Beta infected participants. Additionally, participants infected with the WT, Alpha or Delta variant showed the lowest cross-neutralization against the Beta variant, with a median 5.0-fold (2 to 16-fold), 7.7-fold (2 to 32-fold), and 5.3-fold (1 to 19-fold) reduction compared to the autologous neutralization, respectively. We identified the E484K mutation as the key mutation responsible for this low cross-neutralization. Conclusion: We demonstrated that even small differences in the S protein influences the polyclonal antibody response following infection. The low level of (cross-)neutralization induced by the Beta variant may implicate a higher re-infection risk, but further research of the memory B cell compartment and clinical studies are needed. The broadest cross-neutralizing response observed for WT-infected patients suggests that artificial immunity induced by the current approved COVID-19 vaccines already protects against many re-infections.