Sensitivity of tele-ophthalmic diagnosis of diabetic retinopathy when performed by resident physicians

ABSTRACT

Purpose: During the Covid-19 era, understanding the benefits and limitations of tele-ophthalmology has become increasingly important. In this study, we aim to assess the accuracy of tele-ophthalmic diagnosis of diabetic retinopathy (DR) and diabetic macular edema (DME) when performed by resident physicians. Methods: Retrospective study on 16 patients (32 eyes;28 DR and 4 controls) who presented to a retina clinic at an academic medical center. Automated OCT-B images with 3D topographic maps and fundus photographs of the posterior pole using a Topcon Maestro 3D OCT-1 unit were taken. Images were transmitted remotely to a resident physician who assessed the severity of the DR and DME on the basis of the fundus photographs and OCT. The same images were transmitted to a retina specialist for grading. Primary outcomes included DR and DME grade as defined by the International Clinical Diabetic Retinopathy classification scale. We then tested the concordance between diagnoses rendered via tele-OCT by the resident compared to the retina attending's remote diagnosis and the gold standard retina specialist's clinical examination using Cohen's Kappa statistic (κ). Results: Agreement between ophthalmology residents and attendings on tele-OCT diagnosis of DR was substantial (78% concordance on presence and 75% on severity), while agreement on identifying and grading edema was moderate (60% concordance on DME presence and 52% concordance on overall DME severity). Detection of DR by residents via tele-retinal imaging is highly sensitive (100% sensitivity), while detection of DME is highly specific (79-95% specificity). Discordance between residents and attendings on DME grading may owe to differences in opinion regarding what constitutes mild edema versus no edema;however, both concordance and predictive accuracy increase when identifying patients with moderate to severe DME. Conclusions: This study provides proof of principle for the sensitivity and specificity for remote diagnosis of DR via tele-OCT fundus and OCT-B images. This technology may be useful in identifying patients at risk of severe vision loss and enable early detection of patients who need referral for prompt treatment. These findings may be particularly relevant to training programs looking to implement tele-retinal diabetic screening or using tele-OCT where prompt access to a retina specialist may not be possible.