Your browser doesn't support javascript.
142. The Reach, Implementation, and Effectiveness of Virtual Sex Education for Youth in Foster Care
Journal of Adolescent Health ; 72(3):S81, 2023.
Article in English | EMBASE | ID: covidwho-2239938
ABSTRACT

Purpose:

Youth in foster care have high rates of adverse sexual health outcomes and are important targets for evidence-based sex education. With the COVID-19 pandemic, sexual health programming was moved to a virtual format. However, few data existed to guide this transition. While it lowers expenses and can potentially broaden geographic reach, it is unclear if virtual programming meets the needs of youth in foster care or other vulnerable populations. We conducted a mixed-methods analysis comparing the reach, implementation, and effectiveness of virtual vs in-person sex education for youth in foster care before and during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Methods:

Indiana Proud and Connected Teens (IN-PACT) provides evidenced-based sex education programs to system-involved youth. The data used in this study focused exclusively on foster-care programming and includes attendance records, facilitator session reviews (n=64) from 2020-2021 virtual programs, and youth surveys from 2018-2020 in-person (n=965) and virtual (n=50) programs. Reach was measured using youth baseline survey demographics and sexual behaviors;implementation by free responses from facilitators on challenges and adaptation for virtual teaching;and effectiveness by attendance records and youth behavior intention on follow-up surveys.

Results:

Reach Youth demographic diversity was maintained for virtual programming in ethnicity, race, sex, and sexual orientation. However, youth in virtual programs had lower rates of self-reported risk behaviors including lower rates of involvement with juvenile justice (35.0% vs 59.4%, p<0.01) to have ever had sex (44.4% vs 78.8%, p<0.001) or contributed to a pregnancy (4.4% vs 23.4%, p<0.05). And though not statistically significant, virtual youth reported higher rates of condom use (44.4% vs 30.4%, p=0.371) and lower rates of substance use before sex in the past 3 months (15.6% vs 28.5%, p=0.114) as compared to in-person youth. Implementation Technical challenges included connection difficulties and learning curves to using Zoom. Virtual facilitators incorporated more technology than they did in-person by playing videos on complicated topics such as conception and STIs. In terms of curriculum, hands-on condom demonstrations were changed to facilitator-run experiments such as having youth use socks at home to simulate condoms on their arms. Breakout rooms were utilized to maintain small group work but were cumbersome. Relational challenges included awkward silences, disengagement, and a decrease in group trust due to cameras being turned off during sensitive topics and less connection between youth and facilitators. Effectiveness Attendance records show that fewer virtual youth completed 100% of programming, as compared to in-person youth (23% vs 54%). More virtual youth answered yes to the question "As a result of this program, will you abstain from sex for the next three months?” as compared to in-person youth (55% vs 45%, p=0.462). However, virtual youth were significantly less likely to have baseline sexual experience.

Conclusions:

In-person sexual health programming had a wider reach, experienced fewer implementation challenges, and was potentially more effective than virtual programming for youth in foster care. If virtual programming becomes necessary again, sex educators and researchers can use these data to redesign virtual programming that maximizes reach, implementation, and effectiveness. Sources of Support HHS 90AK0041-02-00 to Health Care Education and Training Inc.
Keywords

Full text: Available Collection: Databases of international organizations Database: EMBASE Type of study: Experimental Studies Language: English Journal: Journal of Adolescent Health Year: 2023 Document Type: Article

Similar

MEDLINE

...
LILACS

LIS


Full text: Available Collection: Databases of international organizations Database: EMBASE Type of study: Experimental Studies Language: English Journal: Journal of Adolescent Health Year: 2023 Document Type: Article