Immunosuppression Doubles the Risk of Covid-19 Infection in a Large Vaccinated Cohort of 898 Patients with Rheumatic Diseases: Implications for Future Practice

ABSTRACT

Background/Aims It is recognised that immunosuppressive medications, often relied upon in the management of autoimmune rheumatic disease, inhibit vaccine-induced immunity against the SARS-CoV-2 virus. A key challenge for rheumatologists is maximising immunity provided by the vaccine in their patients. Recent data has implicated methotrexate (MXT), a commonly used disease modifying anti-rheumatic drug (DMARD), in reducing patients' vaccine-induced immunity against the virus and studies have demonstrated the effectiveness of pausing MXT medication for 2-weeks after receiving the vaccine in boosting patients' immunity. There is a lack of data exploring the impact of concurrent biologic-DMARD (b-DMARD) use with MXT on COVID-19 infection rates in vaccinated individuals. This analysis forms part of a larger programme of research (clinicaltrials.gov NCT04542031) exploring COVID-19 in patients with rheumatic disease. Here we provide a comparative analysis of COVID-19 infection rates between patients taking MXT either with or without b-DMARD therapy and those on no immunosuppression. Methods We distributed two web-based questionnaires via SMS-messaging in April 2020 and December 2021 and two interim monitoring questionnaires in December 2020 and June 2021. All rheumatology patients with a valid mobile telephone number under follow up at the Royal Wolverhampton Trust were invited to participate in the study;those that consented received follow up questionnaires. We collected information on demographics, rheumatology diagnosis and treatment, vaccination status, and COVID-19 infection rates. Data were collected 7-days following questionnaire distribution. Results Initial questionnaires were sent to 7911 active follow up patients, 1636/ 7911 (21%) responded and consented to further follow up;906/1636 (55.4%) provided a complete response to the final survey which was subsequently linked to survey one enabling analysis. Responders were female (622/906, 68.7%), white (865, 95.5%), 60 years or above (519, 57.3%), and vaccinated (898/906;99.1%). Of those vaccinated significantly more patients that were on any immunosuppressive therapy compared to those on no immunosuppression (92/530 (17.4%) vs. 26/368 (7.1%);p<0.001), and more in the MXT monotherapy group compared to no immunosuppression (33/222 (14.9%) vs. 26/368 (7.1%);p=0.001) contracted COVID-19. Similar numbers in the MTX and b-DMARD and b-DMARD without MXT groups (23/140 (16.4%) vs. 36/168 (21.4%);p=0.23) contracted COVID-19. Conclusion Recent trial data from the VROOM study has demonstrated that omitting a patients MXT therapy for a 2-week period following administration of the COVID-19 vaccine doubles their antibody response. This data highlights that the risk of COVID-19 infection in vaccinated rheumatology patients is doubled in patients on any immunosuppressive medication compared to those on no immunosuppression, while there is no significant difference in infection rates between patients on MXT and a b-DMARD and b-DMARD therapy without MXT. Further work exploring the impact of different types of immunosuppression on COVID-19 vaccine-induced immunity and simple interventions to maximise this immunity in immunosuppressed individuals is required.