Consensus on the criteria needed for creating a rare-disease patient registry. A Delphi study.

BACKGROUND: Patient registries (PRs) are important tools for public-health surveillance and rare-disease research. The purpose of this study is to identify the most important criteria for the creation of a rare-disease PR that could be used by public-health authorities to develop health policies. METHODS: A consensus-development Delphi study was used, with participants selected for their expertize in rare diseases and registries. Participants were asked to complete a questionnaire on the most important criteria for creating PRs. Three rounds were performed. RESULTS: Agreement was reached on half the questions in the first round and on 89% of questions in the final round, with a total expert participation rate of around 60% by the final stage. This study made it possible to reach a broader consensus starting from experts' initial assessment of the features that should be considered for the creation of a rare-disease PR. CONCLUSION: The consensus method used made it possible to define the characteristics of a PR based on expert opinion within a rare-disease framework. This study may serve as a guide for helping other researchers plan and build a rare-disease PR.

Comparative cost-effectiveness analysis of oral triptan therapy for migraine in four European countries.

AIM: To assess the differences in the cost-effectiveness of oral triptan therapy for migraines among European countries. METHODS: A cost-effectiveness analysis of triptan therapy for migraine was conducted from a health-care payer perspective in four European countries (France, Italy, Spain and the UK). The study included those orally administered triptans available in all of these countries (almotriptan, brand-name sumatriptan, generic sumatriptan, zolmitriptan), and it was performed using a decision-tree model that incorporated costs of the drugs and probabilities associated with the possible events and outcomes. Average cost-effectiveness ratios were calculated in two different scenarios. RESULTS: The average cost-effectiveness ratio showed wide variations across the different countries, these differences being up to 131 % (almotriptan), 77 % (brand-name sumatriptan), 153 % (generic sumatriptan) and 77 % (zolmitriptan). Generic sumatriptan was the most cost-effective drug analysed in the studied countries. CONCLUSIONS: Caution must be taken when trying to transfer conclusions of pharmacoeconomics studies on migraines even in neighbouring countries. This cross-country variability is a concern for decision-makers and also for the elaboration of international recommendations and clinical practice guidelines.

Epidemiology of hereditary ataxias in Spain: hospital discharge registry and population-based mortality study.

BACKGROUND: Hereditary ataxias (HA) comprise a group of genetically heterogeneous rare diseases. As important public health problems to be monitored, this study analyses the morbimortality of HA in Spain. METHODS: Data were extracted from the national death index (1981-2008), using the International Classification of Diseases (ICD) 9th revision code 334 until 1998, and 10th revision code G11 from 1999 onwards. ICD-9 codes were then selected from the national discharge dataset (1998-2007). Age-adjusted morbidity and mortality rates were obtained by gender and 5-year period. RESULTS: Of the 610 HA deaths from 1981 to 2008, 277 corresponded to Friedreich's ataxia (45.4%) and 333 (54.6%) to other and unspecified ataxias (non-Friedreich group). Both groups showed an increase in mortality trend, which was more pronounced in males from 1985-1989 to 1990-1994. Geographical distribution of mortality revealed higher risk for males, mainly in the north of Spain. A total of 5,341 HA hospitalisations were identified from 1998 to 2007. The average annual age-adjusted hospitalisation rate was 1.19 per 100,000 population, with a rising trend. CONCLUSION: This increase in morbidity and mortality, coupled with the slight interprovincial differences, indicate that more attention should be paid to these rare diseases by public authorities and society alike.

Cost-effectiveness analysis of burning mouth syndrome therapy.

OBJECTIVE: To study the cost-effectiveness of four alternative treatments for burning mouth syndrome (BMS). METHODS: A cost-effectiveness analysis was conducted from a healthcare payer perspective of four therapy strategies (amisulpride, paroxetine, sertraline and topical clonazepam), using a decision-tree model that incorporated direct healthcare costs and probabilities associated with the possible events and outcomes. Average cost-effectiveness and incremental cost-effectiveness ratios were calculated. Sensitivity analyses included the costs of brand name and generic drugs in five European countries (France, Italy, the Netherlands, Spain and UK), as well as two scenarios with different treatment length. RESULTS: Of the drugs analysed, topical clonazepam proved to be the most cost-effective therapy. Although generic proved more efficient than brand name drugs, they displayed no advantage over brand name topical clonazepam. The Netherlands was the country with the highest overall drug efficiency. Sensitivity analyses highlighted the robustness of the model, because topical clonazepam proved to be the most efficient therapy under all the different scenarios. CONCLUSIONS: Topical clonazepam, which previous analyses of clinical evidence have shown to be the drug of choice for BMS, also proved to be the most cost-effective of the drugs analysed for this condition.

Increase in motor neuron disease mortality in Spain: temporal and geographical analysis (1990-2005).

The aim of this study was to assess the trend of motor neuron disease mortality in Spain from 1990 to 2005, and to ascertain the existence of geographical differences in mortality rates. MND deaths are registered by the National Statistics Institute of Spain ­ International Classification of Diseases (ICD) codes ICD9 335.2 (1990-1998) and ICD10 G12.2 (1999-2005). Annual sex- and age-specific rates, as well as rates adjusted for the standard European population were obtained. Provincial standardized mortality ratios (SMRs) were calculated for the study period. Respective provincial SMRs were smoothed with data from adjacent provinces using a Poisson model. Results showed that MND mortality increased in Spain from 1990 to 2005. Geographical differences between provinces were evident throughout the study period. In general, risk of death due to MND was higher in regions lying to the north of Spain. In conclusion, the temporal and geographical variability observed might be explained by genetic factors, differences in environmental exposures and the possible influence of the type of medical care and treatment received. Mortality depends also on health service quality and diagnostic validity. All these factors may play a very important role in analysis of MND mortality in Spain, and the contribution of each of these will have to be examined in depth by ad hoc studies.

The Spanish toxic oil syndrome 20 years after its onset: a multidisciplinary review of scientific knowledge.

In 1981, in Spain, the ingestion of an oil fraudulently sold as olive oil caused an outbreak of a previously unrecorded condition, later known as toxic oil syndrome (TOS), clinically characterized by intense incapacitating myalgias, marked peripheral eosinophilia, and pulmonary infiltrates. Of the 20,000 persons affected, approximately 300 died shortly after the onset of the disease and a larger number developed chronic disease. For more than 15 years, a scientific committee supported by the World Health Organization's Regional Office for Europe and by the Institute of Health Carlos III in Madrid has guided investigation intended to identify the causal agent(s), to assess toxicity and mode of action, to establish the pathogenesis of the disease, and to detect late consequences. This report summarizes advances in research on this front. No late mortality excess has been detected. Among survivors, the prevalence of some chronic conditions (e.g., sclerodermia, neurologic changes) is high. Attempts to reproduce the condition in laboratory animals have been unsuccessful, and no condition similar to TOS has been reported in the scientific literature. Laboratory findings suggest an autoimmune mechanism for TOS, such as high levels of seric soluble interleukin-2 receptor. Epidemiologic studies integrated with chemical analyses of case-related oils have shown that the disease is strongly associated with the consumption of oils containing fatty acid esters of 3-(N-phenylamino)-1,2-propanediol (PAP). These chemicals have also been found in oils synthesized under conditions simulating those hypothesized to have occurred when the toxic oil was produced in 1981. Whether PAP esters are simply markers of toxicity of oils or have the capability to induce the disease remains to be elucidated.