Obstetrics care in Indonesia: Determinants of maternal mortality and stillbirth rates.

PROBLEM: The Indonesian Healthcare Program starting in 2014 enabled access to healthcare delivery for large population groups. Guidance of usage, infrastructure and healthcare process development were the most challenging tasks during the implementation period. Due to the high social impact obstetric care and related quality assurance require evidence-based developmental strategies. This study aims for analysis of outcome and maternal health care utilization, as well as differences related to demographic and economic subgroups. METHODS: For univariate group comparison ANOVA method was applied and combined with Scheffé procedure and Bonferoni correction for post-hoc tests. Meanwhile, multivariate approaches through regression analysis based on insurance reimbursement data antenatal, perinatal and postnatal care were performed at the province level. Maternal mortality (MMR) and stillbirth rates were used for outcome. Demographic characteristics, availability of obstetricians (SPOG), midwifes and healthcare infrastructure were included for their determinants. RESULTS: Specialized hospital facilities (type A/B) for advanced care covered a large part of uncomplicated cases (~35%). Differences between insurance membership groups (poor, non-poor) were not seen. Availability of human resources (SPOG, midwifes) (R2 = 0.728; p<0.001) and rural setting (R2 = 0.288; p = 0.001) are correlated with reduced insufficient referral. Their presence within provinces was related to lower occurrence of complicated cases (R2 = 0.294; p = 0.001). However, higher SPOG rates within provinces were also related to high C-section rates (p<0.001). MMR and stillbirth rates can be predicted by availability of human resources and C-section rates explaining 49.0% of variance. CONCLUSIONS: Improvement of perinatal outcome should focus on sufficient referral processes, availability of SPOG in provinces dominated by rural/remote demography and avoidance of overtreatment by high C-section rates. It is very important to regulate the education of obstetricians and gynecologists in Indonesia as well as distribution arrangements regarding to solve the problems with pregnancy complications in remote and rural areas.

Population-based study on coverage and healthcare processes for cancer during implementation of national healthcare insurance in Indonesia.

Background: A national healthcare insurance has been implemented in Indonesia since 2014. Although cancer care currently represents a smaller part of the healthcare support, the demographic development will lead to a rapid growth of the population within age groups at cancer risk. This requires strategic and developmental planning of cancer care resources. Based on data of the national healthcare insurance, current cancer care processes and their determinants were evaluated. Methods: Nationwide reimbursement data as well as demographic, economic and healthcare infrastructure data were used for the study. Poor and underserved population was stratified according to the national classification system. Availability of healthcare resources was evaluated at provincial level. Cancer care usage was analysed applying descriptive and multivariate statistical approaches (regression, cluster analysis, tree classification). Findings: Cancer care was provided in primary care (PHC) for 2.6/1000 and advanced care (AHC) for 4.8/1000 participants within the family-based membership structure. Regression analysis revealed human resource availability in rural/remote areas a determinant for cancer PHC. Cancer care in AHC was determined by PHC provided by general practitioners (GP), availability of AHC infrastructure (Class A & B hospital beds) and treatment migration between provinces. Tree classification confirmed predominant roles of GP, AHC infrastructure and referral between cancer care provider levels. Interpretation: Cancer care will gain much higher importance for the Indonesian healthcare system within the next decade. Infrastructure, human resources, and process development should avoid rising overload of cancer care delivery by targeting reduction of treatment migration (availability of GPs in rural/remote provinces), improvement of referral systems (effective clinical selection processes and back-referral) and AHC cancer care structures (regional distribution of Class A & B hospitals). Funding: This project was supported by grants from Centre for Research, Publication, and Community Development Muhammadiyah University of Yogyakarta (SW, ID), and data provision by BPJS Indonesia.

Availability and Accessibility of Primary Care for the Remote, Rural, and Poor Population of Indonesia.

Background: Adopting Universal Health Coverage for implementation of a national health insurance system [Jaminan Kesehatan Nasional (JKN)/Badan Penyelenggara Jaminan Sosial or the Indonesian National Social Health Insurance Scheme (BPJS)] targets the 255 million population of Indonesia. The availability, accessibility, and acceptance of healthcare services are the most important challenges during implementation. Referral behavior and the utilization of primary care structures for underserved (rural/remote regions) populations are key guiding elements. In this study, we provided the first assessment of BPJS implementation and its resulting implications for healthcare delivery based on the entire insurance dataset for the initial period of implementation, specifically focusing on poor and remote populations. Methods: Demographic, economic, and healthcare infrastructure information was obtained from public resources. Data about the JKN membership structure, performance information, and reimbursement were provided by the BPJS national head office. For analysis, an ANOVA was used to compare reimbursement indexes for primary healthcare (PHC) and advanced healthcare (AHC). The usage of primary care resources was analyzed by comparing clustered provinces and utilization indices differentiating poor [Penerima Bantuan Iur (PBI) membership] and non-poor populations (non-PBI). Factorial and canonical discrimination analyses were applied to identify the determinants of PHC structures. Results: Remote regions cover 27.8% of districts/municipalities. The distribution of the poor population and PBI members were highly correlated (r2 > 0.8; p < 0.001). Three clusters of provinces [remote high-poor (N = 13), remote low-poor (N = 15), non-remote (N = 5)] were identified. A discrimination analysis enabled the >82% correct cluster classification of infrastructure and human resources of health (HRH)-related factors. Standardized HRH (nurses and general practitioners [GP]) availability showed significant differences between clusters (p < 0.01), whereas the availability of hospital beds was weakly correlated. The usage of PHC was ~2-fold of AHC, while non-PBI members utilized AHC 4- to 5-fold more frequently than PBI members. Referral indices (r2 = 0.94; p < 0.001) for PBI, non-PBI, and AHC utilization rates (r2 = 0.53; p < 0.001) were highly correlated. Conclusion: Human resources of health availability were intensively related to the extent of the remote population but not the numbers of the poor population. The access points of PHC were mainly used by the poor population and in remote regions, whereas other population groups (non-PBI and non-Remote) preferred direct access to AHC. Guiding referral and the utilization of primary care will be key success factors for the effective and efficient usage of available healthcare infrastructures and the achievement of universal health coverage in Indonesia. The short-term development of JKN was recommended, with a focus on guiding referral behavior, especially in remote regions and for non-PBI members.