ABSTRACT
PURPOSE: Carbapenem inactivation method (CIM) and modified carbapenem inactivation method (mCIM) were recently developed for rapid detection of carbapenemase producing Gram negative bacilli (CP-GNB). In this study we compared the ability of modified Hodge test (MHT), CIM and mCIM to identify CP-GNB in Oman and India. METHODS: Fifty fully characterized and genotyped CP-GNB (26 OXA-48-like, 2 NDM-1 from Oman and 22 NDM-1 from India) and 8 AmpC as controls in India were subjected to MHT, CIM, mCIM and mCIM with in-house modifications. Wilcoxon paired test and receiver operating characteristics (ROC) were utilised for statistical analysis. RESULTS: Isolates were predominantly OXA-48-like genes producing Klebsiella pneumoniae from Oman and NDM-1 producing Escherichia coli from India. MHT was positive in all except one OXA-48-like producers and in 70.8 â% of the NDM-1 isolates. The sensitivity of CIM in detecting 0XA-48 like and NDM-1 carbapenemases were 39.2% and 87.5% respectively. mCIM at 4 âh detected 92.3 â% and 79.1% of 0XA-48 and NDM-1 respectively. Using receiver operative characteristics (ROC), highest sensitivity and specificity for detection of OXA-48-like was obtained by mCIM at 4 âh at cut off 17 âmm while for NDM-1 CIM was the test of choice at 16 âmm. CONCLUSION: CIM and mCIM are simple, cheap and easy tests to perform. CIM gave excellent results with NDM1 strains while it was quite poor in predicting OXA-48-like. We recommend CIM and eCIM for rapid identification of NDM-1 producers and mCIM at 4 âh and MHT for detection of OXA-48-like. No one method can correctly detect both genotypes. As determined by ROC curves a zone of inhibition of 17 âmm was considered adequate for detection of OXA-48-like and 16 âmm of NDM-1 by mCIM at 4 âh and CIM respectively.
