Effect of Motor State on Postactivation Depression of the Soleus H-Reflex in Parkinson's Disease During Deep Brain Stimulation and Dopaminergic Medication Treatment: A Pilot Study.

PURPOSE: Postactivation depression of the Hoffmann reflex is reduced in Parkinson's disease (PD), but how the recovery is influenced by the state of the muscle is unknown. The present pilot study examined postactivation depression in PD at rest and during a voluntary contraction while patients were off treatment and while receiving medications and/or deep brain stimulation. METHODS: The authors recruited nine patients with PD treated with implanted deep brain stimulation and examined postactivation depression under four treatment conditions. Paired pulses were delivered 25 to 300 ms apart, and soleus Hoffmann reflex recovery was tested at rest and during voluntary plantar flexion. Trials were matched for background muscle activity and compared with 10 age-matched controls. RESULTS: Patients with Parkinson disease who were OFF medications (OFF meds) and OFF stimulation (OFF stim) at rest showed less postactivation depression at the 300 ms interpulse interval (86.1% ± 21.0%) relative to control subjects (36.4% ± 6.1%; P < 0.05). Postactivation depression was restored when dopaminergic medication and/or deep brain stimulation was applied. Comparisons between resting and active motor states revealed that the recovery curves were similar OFF meds/OFF stim owing to faster recovery in PD seen at rest. In contrast, the effect of the motor state was different ON meds/OFF stim and ON meds/ON stim (both P < 0.05), with a nonsignificant trend OFF meds/ON stim ( P > 0.08). During a contraction, recovery curves were similar between all treatment conditions in PD and control. CONCLUSIONS: Disrupted Hoffmann reflex recovery is restored to control levels in PD patients at rest when receiving medications and/or deep brain stimulation or when engaged in voluntary contraction.

Effects of Deep Brain Stimulation and Dopaminergic Medication on Excitatory and Inhibitory Spinal Pathways in Parkinson Disease.

PURPOSE: Abnormal activity within the corticospinal system is believed to contribute to the motor dysfunction associated with Parkinson disease. However, the effect of treatment for parkinsonian motor symptoms on dysfunctional descending input to the motor neuron pool remains unclear. METHODS: We recruited nine patients with PD treated with deep brain stimulation and examined the time course of interaction between a conditioning pulse from transcranial magnetic stimulation and the soleus H-reflex. Patients with Parkinson disease were examined under four treatment conditions and compared with 10 age-matched control subjects. RESULTS: In healthy controls, transcranial magnetic stimulation conditioning led to early inhibition of the H-reflex (76.2% ± 6.3%) at a condition-test interval of -2 ms. This early inhibition was absent when patients were OFF medication/OFF stimulation (132.5% ± 20.4%; P > 0.05) but was maximally restored toward control levels ON medication/ON stimulation (80.3% ± 7.0%). Of note, early inhibition ON medication/ON stimulation tended to be stronger than when medication (85.4% ± 5.9%) or deep brain stimulation (95.7% ± 9.4%) were applied separately. Late facilitation was observed in controls at condition-test intervals ≥5 ms but was significantly reduced (by 50% to 80% of controls) in Parkinson disease OFF stimulation at condition-test intervals ≥15 ms. The late facilitation was akin to control subjects when patients were ON stimulation. CONCLUSIONS: The present pilot study demonstrates that the recruitment of early inhibition and late facilitation is disrupted in untreated Parkinson disease and that medication and deep brain stimulation may act together to normalize supraspinal drive to the motor neuron pool.

Intraoperative changes in the H-reflex pathway during deep brain stimulation surgery for Parkinson's disease: A potential biomarker for optimal electrode placement.

BACKGROUND: Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) targeting the subthalamic nucleus (STN) and globus pallidus interna (GPi) is an effective treatment for cardinal motor symptoms and motor complications in Parkinson's Disease (PD). However, malpositioned DBS electrodes can result in suboptimal therapeutic response. OBJECTIVE: We explored whether recovery of the H-reflex-an easily measured electrophysiological analogue of the stretch reflex, known to be altered in PD-could serve as an adjunct biomarker of suboptimal versus optimal electrode position during STN- or GPi-DBS implantation. METHODS: Changes in soleus H-reflex recovery were investigated intraoperatively throughout awake DBS target refinement across 26 nuclei (14 STN). H-reflex recovery was evaluated during microelectrode recording (MER) and macrostimulation at multiple locations within and outside target nuclei, at varying stimulus intensities. RESULTS: Following MER, H-reflex recovery normalized (i.e., became less Parkinsonian) in 21/26 nuclei, and correlated with on-table motor improvement consistent with an insertional effect. During macrostimulation, H-reflex recovery was maximally normalized in 23/26 nuclei when current was applied at the location within the nucleus producing optimal motor benefit. At these optimal sites, H-reflex normalization was greatest at stimulation intensities generating maximum motor benefit free of stimulation-induced side effects, with subthreshold or suprathreshold intensities generating less dramatic normalization. CONCLUSION: H-reflex recovery is modulated by stimulation of the STN or GPi in patients with PD and varies depending on the location and intensity of stimulation within the target nucleus. H-reflex recovery shows potential as an easily-measured, objective, patient-specific, adjunct biomarker of suboptimal versus optimal electrode position during DBS surgery for PD.

Characterizing the effect of low intensity transcranial magnetic stimulation on the soleus H-reflex at rest.

Modulation of a Hoffmann (H)-reflex following transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) has been used to assess the nature of signals transmitted from cortical centers to lower motor neurons. Further characterizing the recruitment and time-course of the TMS-induced effect onto the soleus H-reflex adds to the discussion of these pathways and may improve its utility in clinical studies. In 10 healthy controls, TMS was used to condition the soleus H-reflex using TMS intensities from 65 to 110% of the resting motor threshold (RMT). Early facilitation [- 5 to - 3 ms condition-test (C-T) interval] was evident when TMS was 110% of RMT (P < 0.05). By comparison, late facilitation (+ 10 to + 20 ms C-T interval) was several times larger and observed over a wider range of TMS intensities, including 65-110% of RMT. The early inhibition (- 3 to - 1 ms C-T interval) had a low TMS threshold and was elicited over a wide range of intensity from 65% to 95% of RMT (all P < 0.05). A second inhibitory phase was seen ~ 4 ms later (+ 1 to + 4 ms C-T intervals) and was only observed for a TMS intensity of 95% of RMT (P < 0.05). The present findings reaffirm that subthreshold TMS strongly modulates soleus motor neurons and demonstrates that distinct pathways can be selectively probed at discrete C-T intervals when using specific TMS intensities.

Intraoperative spinal cord monitoring using low intensity transcranial stimulation to remove post-activation depression of the H-reflex.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate whether low intensity transcranial electrical stimulation (TES) can be used to condition post-activation depression of the H-reflex and simultaneously monitor the integrity of spinal motor pathways during spinal deformity correction surgery. METHODS: In 20 pediatric patients undergoing corrective surgery for spinal deformity, post-activation depression of the medial gastrocnemius H-reflex was initiated by delivering two pulses 50-125ms apart, and the second H-reflex was conditioned by TES. RESULTS: Low intensity TES caused no visible shoulder or trunk movements during 19/20 procedures and the stimulation reduced post-activation depression of the H-reflex. The interaction was present in 20/20 patients and did not diminish throughout the surgical period. In one case, the conditioning effect was lost within minutes of the disappearance of the lower extremity motor evoked potentials. CONCLUSION: Post-activation depression was used to detect the arrival of a subthreshold motor evoked potential at the lower motor neuron. The interaction produced minimal movement within the surgical field and remained stable throughout the surgical period. SIGNIFICANCE: This is the first use of post-activation depression during intraoperative neurophysiological monitoring to directly assess the integrity of descending spinal motor pathways.

Reduced postactivation depression of soleus H reflex and root evoked potential after transcranial magnetic stimulation.

Postactivation depression of the Hoffmann (H) reflex is associated with a transient period of suppression following activation of the reflex pathway. In soleus, the depression lasts for 100-200 ms during voluntary contraction and up to 10 s at rest. A reflex root evoked potential (REP), elicited after a single pulse of transcutaneous stimulation to the thoracolumbar spine, has been shown to exhibit similar suppression. The present study systematically characterized the effect of transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) on postactivation depression using double-pulse H reflexes and REPs. A TMS pulse reduced the period of depression to 10-15 ms for both reflexes. TMS could even produce postactivation facilitation of the H reflex, as the second reflex response was increased to 243 ± 51% of control values at the 75-ms interval. The time course was qualitatively similar for the REP, yet the overall increase was less. While recovery of the H reflex was slower in the relaxed muscle, the profile exhibited a distinct bimodal shape characterized by an early peak at the 25-ms interval, reaching 72 ± 23% of control values, followed by a trough at 50 ms, and then a gradual recovery at intervals > 50 ms. The rapid recovery of two successively depressed H reflexes, ∼ 25 ms apart, was also possible with double-pulse TMS. The effect of the TMS-induced corticospinal excitation on postactivation depression may be explained by a combination of pre- and postsynaptic mechanisms, although further investigation is required to distinguish between them.

Post-activation depression in the human soleus muscle using peripheral nerve and transcutaneous spinal stimulation.

Transcutaneous stimulation of the human lumbar spine can be used to elicit root-evoked potentials (REPs). These sensory-motor responses display notable similarities to the monosynaptic H-reflex. The purpose of this study was to compare post-activation depression of the soleus REP to that of the H-reflex, when conditioned by either an H-reflex or an REP. Paired pulses were delivered 25-200ms apart and the recovery was characterized using three levels of stimulation. In all conditions, post-activation depression was reduced during contraction as compared to rest (P<0.001). REP doublets, delivered using an inter-pulse interval of 150ms, recovered to 68±8% of control during plantarflexion and 20±6% of control at rest. During contraction, recovery of a second REP was 65% of the corresponding recovery for a second H-reflex. The recovery of an H-reflex was equivalent, when conditioned by either an H-reflex or an REP, even though the spinal stimulus activated and/or engaged more afferent and efferent fibers. Our results suggest that the additional elements activated by the spinal stimulus did not affect the recovery of the H-reflex. However, the transcutaneous spinal stimulus produced more inhibition when it was assessed using two low-intensity REPs (P<0.05) suggesting that the pathway mediating the spinally-evoked response was more susceptible to being inhibited.

Associations compete directly in memory.

Associations are confusable when they share an item. For example, double-function pairs (with the form AB, BC) are harder to remember than control pairs. Although ambiguous pairs are more difficult on average, it is not clear whether memories for associations compete directly with one another (associative competition hypothesis), as assumed by models that incorporate associative symmetry (bidirectional associations). Alternatively, associative interference results might be explained away by: (a) item suppression hypothesis: competition only between memory for the two target items (A and C are both targets of B); (b) candidate competition hypothesis: The cue (B) retrieves two potential targets, A and C, which compete to be output. These alternative hypotheses could explain previous results in the related, AB/AC learning procedure. Our procedure included a large amount of interference that had to be resolved within a single study set. Participants studied sets of control (single-function) and double-function pairs and were asked to produce one or two associates, respectively, to cue items. Recall of AB and BC were negatively correlated and could not be explained away by item suppression or competition between simultaneously retrieved candidate items. Thus, competition can occur at the level of representation of associations, regardless of which item is the cue, consistent with associative symmetry.

Blood ordering from the operating room: turnaround time as a quality indicator.

BACKGROUND: Quality indicators in transfusion medicine are necessary for patient safety and customer satisfaction. The turnaround time (TAT) of issuing red blood cells (RBCs) has emerged as a quality indicator but is not an established benchmark. We examined the TAT for issuing RBCs from the blood bank to the operating rooms (ORs) at Vanderbilt University Medical Center (VUMC) and Stanford University Medical Center (SUMC). STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: TAT was defined from time of request to when RBCs exited the blood bank. Cases eligible for analysis had completed type-and-screen results with requests for four or fewer RBC units. Patients with a positive antibody screen had serologically crossmatched units prepared and reserved for intraoperative use. We also e-mailed surveys to academic institutions to establish the current state of TAT monitoring and to anesthesiologists at VUMC to gauge the TAT expectations of the OR. RESULTS: The mean TATs at the two institutions were comparable (VUMC, 10 ± 3.8 min; SUMC, 14 ± 7.2 min) for orders of RBCs. The most common reasons for delayed TAT were overlapping orders, medical technologists occupied by phone calls, and oversaturation of pneumatic tube stations. Only 3 of 24 surveyed institutions actively monitored RBC TAT. Surveyed anesthesiologists (n = 7) reported an expectation for RBC TAT of 5 to 15 minutes for urgent cases. Established internal TAT policies were 15 and 20 minutes at VUMC and SUMC, respectively, for crossmatched RBC requests for patients with complete diagnostic testing. CONCLUSION: Many of the surveyed institutions do not monitor stat RBC issue TAT as a quality indicator. This study serves as a starting point for establishing a benchmark for TAT for issuing RBCs from the blood bank to ORs.