A strategic development model for the role of the biomedical physicist in the education of healthcare professionals in Europe.

This is the third of a series of articles targeted at biomedical physicists providing educational services to other healthcare professions, whether in a university faculty of medicine/health sciences or otherwise (e.g., faculty of science, hospital-based medical physics department). The first paper identified the past and present role of the biomedical physicist in the education of the healthcare professions and highlighted issues of concern. The second paper reported the results of a comprehensive SWOT (strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, threats) audit of that role. In this paper we present a strategy for the development of the role based on the outcomes of the SWOT audit. The research methods adopted focus on the importance of strategic planning at all levels in the provision of educational services. The analytical process used in the study was a pragmatic blend of the various theoretical frameworks described in the literature on strategic planning research as adapted for use in academic role development. Important results included identification of the core competences of the biomedical physicist in this context; specification of benchmarking schemes based on experiences of other biomedical disciplines; formulation of detailed mission and vision statements; gap analysis for the role. The paper concludes with a set of strategies and specific actions for gap reduction.

A comprehensive SWOT audit of the role of the biomedical physicist in the education of healthcare professionals in Europe.

Although biomedical physicists provide educational services to the healthcare professions in the majority of universities in Europe, their precise role with respect to the education of the healthcare professions has not been studied systematically. To address this issue we are conducting a research project to produce a strategic development model for the role using the well-established SWOT (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats) methodology. SWOT based strategic planning is a two-step process: one first carries out a SWOT position audit and then uses the identified SWOT themes to construct the strategic development model. This paper reports the results of a SWOT audit for the role of the biomedical physicist in the education of the healthcare professions in Europe. Internal Strengths and Weaknesses of the role were identified through a qualitative survey of biomedical physics departments and biomedical physics curricula delivered to healthcare professionals across Europe. External environmental Opportunities and Threats were identified through a systematic survey of the healthcare, healthcare professional education and higher education literature and categorized under standard PEST (Political, Economic, Social-Psychological, Technological-Scientific) categories. The paper includes an appendix of terminology. Defined terms are marked with an asterisk in the text.

The role of the biomedical physicist in the education of the healthcare professions: an EFOMP project.

The role of the biomedical physicist in the education of the healthcare professions has not yet been studied in a systematic manner. This article presents the first results of an EFOMP project aimed at researching and developing this important component of the role of the biomedical physicist. A background to the study expands on the reasons that led to the need for the project. This is followed by an extensive review of the published literature regarding the role. This focuses mainly on the teaching contributions within programmes for physicians, diagnostic radiographers, radiation therapists, and the postgraduate medical specializations of radiology, radiotherapy, interventional radiology and cardiology. Finally a summary list of the specific research objectives that need to be immediately addressed is presented. These are the carrying out of a Europe-wide position audit for the role, the construction of a strategic role development model and the design of a curriculum development model suitable for modern healthcare professional education.

The causes of cancer in France.

BACKGROUND: While external factors are responsible for many human cancers, precise estimates of the contribution of known carcinogens to the cancer burden in a given population have been scarce. METHODS: We estimated the proportion of cancer deaths which occurred in France in 2000 attributable to known risk factors, based on data on frequency of exposure around 1985. RESULTS: In 2000, tobacco smoking was responsible for 23.9% of cancer deaths (33.4% in men and 9.6% in women), alcohol drinking for 6.9% (9.4% in men and 3.0% in women) and chronic infections for 3.7%. Occupation is responsible for 3.7% of cancer deaths in men; lack of physical activity, overweight/obesity and use of exogenous hormones are responsible for 2%-3% of cancer deaths in women. Other risk factors, including pollutants, are responsible for <1% of cancer deaths. Thus, known risk factors explain 35.0% of cancer deaths, and 15.0% among never smokers. CONCLUSIONS: While cancer mortality is decreasing in France, known risk factors of cancer explain only a minority of cancers, with a predominant role of tobacco smoking.

The debate on the use of linear no threshold for assessing the effects of low doses.

From December 2004 to July 2005, three reports on the effects of low doses of ionising radiation were released: ICRP (2004), the joint report of the French Academies of Science and Medicine (Tubiana et al 2005), and a report from the American Academy of Sciences (BEIR VII 2005). These reports quote the same recent articles on the biological effects of low doses, yet their conclusions diverge. The French report concludes that recent biological data show that the efficacy of defense mechanisms is modulated by dose and dose rate and that linear no threshold (LNT) is no longer plausible. The ICRP and the BEIR VII reports recognise that there are biologic arguments against LNT but feel that there are not sufficient biological proofs against it to change risk assessment methodology and subsequent regulatory policy based on LNT. They point out the remaining uncertainties and the lack of mechanistic explanations of phenomena such as low dose hyperlethality or the adaptive response. In this context, a critical analysis of the available data is necessary. The epidemiological data and the experimental data challenge the validity of the LNT hypothesis for assessing the carcinogenic effect of low doses, but do not allow its exclusion. Therefore, the main criteria for selecting the most reliable dose-effect relationship from a scientific point of view should be based on biological data. Their analysis should help one to understand the current controversy.

Recent reports on the effect of low doses of ionizing radiation and its dose-effect relationship.

Recently, the risk associated with low doses of ionizing radiation has gained new interest. Here, we analyze and discuss the major differences between two reports recently published on this issue; the report of the French Academy of Sciences and of the French Academy of Medicine published in March 2005, and the BEIR VII-Phase 2 Report of the American National Academy of Sciences published as a preliminary version in July 2005. The conclusion of the French Report is that the linear no-threshold relationship (LNT) may greatly overestimate the carcinogenic effect of low doses (<100 mSv) and even more that of very low doses (<10 mSv), such as those delivered during X-ray examinations. Conversely, the conclusion of the BEIR VII report is that LNT should be used for assessing the detrimental effects of these low and very low doses. The causes of these diverging conclusions should be carefully examined. They seem to be mostly associated with the interpretation of recent biological data. The point of view of the French Report is that these recent data are incompatible with the postulate on which LNT is implicitly based, namely the constancy of the carcinogenic effect per unit dose, irrespective of dose and dose rate.

Usefulness of fine needle aspiration cytology in the diagnosis of loco-regional recurrence of differentiated thyroid carcinoma.

AIM: The aim of our study was to define the usefulness of fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) in the assessment of loco-regional recurrence of differentiated thyroid carcinoma (DTC). METHODS: Among 1182 consecutive patients treated and followed for DTC from 1992 to 2001, we retrospectively analysed 65 FNAC results of patients presenting a suspicion of loco-regional recurrence. Recurrences were proved at histology in 35 cases and by cervical radioiodine uptake on post-therapeutic WBS (whole body scan) in nine cases. RESULTS: Among the 44 recurrences, FNAC results were malignant, benign and unsatisfactory in 33, two and nine cases, respectively. For the diagnosis of malignancy, FNAC sensitivity was 94%, specificity 100%, positive predictive value 100% and negative predictive value 87%. In the 35 cases where divergent results between diagnostic WBS (37-111MBq (131)I) and Tg level were observed, FNAC assessed the final status in 22 cases (malignant and benign in 17 and five cases, respectively). Of the 12 non-functioning and non-secreting lesions, FNAC diagnosed malignancy in four of the five malignant cases and ruled out malignancy in all seven benign lesions. CONCLUSION: These results outline the interest of FNAC in the assessment of loco-regional recurrences of DTC, especially when classical follow-up tools such as WBS and/or Tg level are unable to detect the recurrences.

[Analytical aspects of the semiquantitative determination of urinary iodine using ferroin: value of rapid screening for iodine deficiency or excess]. / Aspects méthodologiques de la détermination semi-quantitative de l'iodurie par la ferroïne: intérêt dans le dépistage rapide de carence ou surcharge en iode.

Iodine is an essential element for thyroid hormone synthesis. Iodine disorders induced biological and/to clinical expression of thyroid dysfunction. Inappropriate iodine intake (by default or by excess) is worrying in terms of public health in France regarding the iodine deficiency and the frequency of iatrogen iodine overloads. Urinary iodine determination which generally implicates the use of a cerimetric method, is an useful tool to evaluate iodine intakes. In this study, we described the analytical aspects of a semiquantitative method of urinary iodine using a redox indicator, ferroin. This method allows the screening of iodine excess or deficiency in a short time (< 3 hours) with a good specificity and sensitivity. Since this assay does not require specific apparatus, it could be easily developed in clinical chemistry laboratories for the detection of inappropriate iodine intakes, and could be useful for prevention programs of iodine deficiency.

Iodine kinetics and effectiveness of stable iodine prophylaxis after intake of radioactive iodine: a review.

Ingestion of potassium iodide (KI) offers effective protection against irradiation of the thyroid after accidental exposure to radioactive iodine. This prophylaxis aims at rapidly obtaining maximal thyroid protection without adverse effects. This article reviews studies on iodine kinetics in humans and on the efficacy of KI in protecting the thyroid. In adults with normal thyroid function, ingestion of 100 mg of iodide just before exposure to radioactive iodine blocks at least 95% of the thyroid dose. If exposure persists after iodide ingestion (100 mg), the percentage of averted dose may decrease significantly. Daily ingestion of a dose of 15 mg of KI would then maintain the thyroid blockade at a level above 90%. The efficacy of iodide and the occurrence of antithyroid effects also depend on external and individual factors such as dietary iodine intake, thyroid function, and age. The KI dosage regimen should be adjusted for age at exposure. For the fetus, the newborn, children, and adolescents, the risk of radiation-induced thyroid cancer in case of accidental exposure to radioactive iodine justifies KI prophylaxis, despite the risk of hypothyroidism, especially in newborns. For the elderly, the benefits of KI may be lower than the risk of iodine-induced hyperthyroidism.

Survival and therapeutic modalities in patients with bone metastases of differentiated thyroid carcinomas.

Data for patients with bone metastases (BMs) of differentiated thyroid carcinoma (DTC) were retrospectively studied to identify factors associated with survival. We especially studied the impact of therapies. Among the 1977 patients followed for DTC in our department from 1958 to 1999, 109 (77 females and 32 males; age range, 20--87 yr) presented BMS: All patients except 1 underwent total thyroidectomy, followed by radioiodine therapy (> or =3.7 gigabecquerels) in 95 cases. Survival rates at 5 and 10 yr were 41% and 15%, respectively. Univariate analyses indicated that a young age at BM discovery (P < 0.005) and the discovery of BM as a revealing symptom of DTC (P < 0.05) were features significantly associated with improved survival as well as radioiodine therapy (P < 10(-4)) and BM complete surgery (P < 0.02). Using multivariate analysis, the detection of BMs as a revealing symptom of thyroid carcinoma (P < 0.0005), the absence of metastasis appearance in other organs than bones during the follow-up (P < 0.03), the cumulative dose of radioiodine therapy (P < 0.0001), and complete BM surgery in young patients (P < 0.04) appeared as independent prognostic features associated with an improved survival.

Absolute activity quantitation in simultaneous 123I/99mTc brain SPECT.

UNLABELLED: Dual-isotope imaging can allow simultaneous assessment of brain perfusion using a 99mTc-labeled tracer and neurotransmission using an 123I-labeled tracer. However, the images are affected by scatter, cross talk, attenuation, distance-dependent collimator response (DCR), and partial-volume effect. We determined the accuracy and precision of activity quantitation in simulated normal and pathologic studies of simultaneous 123I/99mTc brain SPECT when compensating for all degrading phenomena. METHODS: Monte Carlo simulations were performed using the Zubal brain phantom. Contamination caused by high-energy 123I decay photons was incorporated. Twenty-four 99mTc and 123I activity distributions were simulated on the basis of normal and pathologic patient activity distributions. Cross talk and scatter were corrected using a new method based on a multilayer perceptron artificial neural network (ANN), as well as by the asymmetric window (AW) approach; for comparison, unscattered (U) photons of 99mTc and 123I were recorded. Nonuniform attenuation and DCR were modeled in an iterative ordered-subset expectation maximization (OSEM) algorithm. Mean percentage biases and SDs over the 12 normal and 12 pathologic simulated studies were computed for each structure with respect to the known activity distributions. RESULTS: For 123I, AW + OSEM yielded a bias of 7% in the cerebellum, 21% in the frontal cortex, and 36% in the corpus callosum in the simulated normal population. The bias was increased significantly in the striata of simulated pathologic studies (P < 0.05). The bias associated with ANN was significantly lower (<9% in these brain structures, P < 0.05). For 99mTc with AW + OSEM, the bias was 60% in the corpus callosum, 36% in the striata, and 18%-22% in the cortical lobes in the simulated normal population. This bias was <11% in all brain structures with ANN. In the simulated pathologic population, the bias associated with AW increased significantly in the cortical lobes to 55% (P < 0.05), although it did not change significantly with ANN. CONCLUSION: The accuracy and variability over simulated normal and pathologic studies of both 99mTc and 123I activity estimates were very close with ANN to those obtained with U + OSEM. ANN + OSEM is a promising approach for absolute activity quantitation in simultaneous 99mTc/123I SPECT.

Pulmonary blood flow distribution in stage 1 chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.

We investigated the hypothesis that lung blood flow distribution is modified in stage 1 chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). We compared patients with stage 1 COPD (n = 11) with restrictive patients with comparable blood gases (n = 7), to patients with low cardiac index with normal lungs (n = 11) and to control subjects (n = 11). Distribution of transit time (DTT) was computed by deconvolution from first pass radioactivity curves (albumin (99m)Tc) reconstructed from right and left ventricular regions of interest. Distribution descriptors, mean transit time (p < 0.05), standard deviation (p < 0.001), relative dispersion (p < 0.001), and kurtosis (p < 0.001) differed between groups (ANOVA). Cardiac index was the same in COPD and low CI groups but lower compared with normal subjects (p < 0.05). After normalization for cardiac output, the DTT of patients with COPD remained different from low CI and restrictive patients (p < 0.001). Therefore changes in DTT in patients with COPD compared with patients without COPD could not be explained on the basis of difference in cardiac output. Because P(O(2)), PC(O(2)), and pH were similar in COPD and restrictive groups, difference in distribution could not be explained either on the basis of blood gas data. We conclude that changes in DTT occurs in stage 1 COPD and cannot be explained by hypoxemia, hypercapnia, or acidosis alone but must relate to other structural or regulatory responses.

Fetal biometric parameters, twin type and birth weight difference. A longitudinal study.

OBJECTIVE: To examine the relationship between twin type, divided by zygosity, chorionicity, and birth weight difference [more or less than 15% intertwin weight difference at delivery] on fetal biometric measurements, including biparietal diameter, transverse abdominal diameter, head and abdominal circumferences (AC) and head and abdominal areas, femur length (FL), transverse cerebellar diameter, cerebellar circumference and cerebellar area at 18, 23, 28 and 32 weeks of gestational age. STUDY DESIGN: A prospective and longitudinal study was done on 75 twin pairs that did not present the twin-twin transfusion syndrome (150 fetuses) divided into birth weight difference group I (<15%) and group II (>/=15%). The twin pairs were divided into three groups: dizygotic, monochorionic, and dichorionic-monozygotic. In each group the differences in various ultrasound indices were evaluated in reference to discordant growth or concordant growth. RESULTS: In our sample, there were no monozygotic twin pairs with dichorionic placentation with a birth weight difference of more than 15%. Significant associations of group and gestational age were found in dizygotic and monochorionic twins. Intrapair differences were significantly higher in group II (>/=15%) than in group I (<15%) for all fetal parameters studied except for AC, abdominal area and all cerebellar parameters. The value of these discrepancies increased according to gestational age except for FL. Significant interactions between group and zygosity type indicated that intrapair FL differences were more associated with group in monochorionic twins, whereas intrapair transverse cerebellar diameter differences were more associated with group in dizygotic twins. CONCLUSION: Our data show that most fetal biometric parameters are associated with birth weight discordancy. Abdominal area could be a relevant marker for twins with obstetric complications. Note that this is the first research that has studied a twin sample divided by both twin type and birth weight group.

[Thyroid cancer in patients with hyperthyroidism]. / Cancer de la thyroïde chez les hyperthyroïdiens.

OBJECTIVE: The prevalence of thyroid carcinoma in hyperthyroidism remains controversial. The aim of this retrospective study was to evaluate prevalence. PATIENTS AND METHODS: The prevalence of thyroid carcinoma was studied in 861 patients operated for clinical or infraclinical hyperthyroidism between 1992 and 1999. One hundred and fifty patients had a hot nodule, 13 of them with an associated goiter. Four hundred five patients had Graves' disease and 306 had a multinodular goiter. Multiple sections were made in all surgical specimens for pathology study. RESULTS: Prevalence in solitary nodules was 1.45%. For Graves' disease patients, it was 4.1%. Prevalence among patients with multinodular goiter was 4.9%. Among the cancers, 83% were microcarcinoma. Parathyroid morbidity after subtotal and total thyroidectomy was 0.56% and recurrent hyperthyroidism occurred in 1.6%. CONCLUSIONS: These findings are grossly identical to those observed in simple, nontoxic diffuse multinodular goiter. It would therefore be difficult to incriminate hyperthyroidism as playing a causal role in the development of thyroid cancer. These results do however provide an argument favoring total or near total thyroidectomy when surgery is performed in patients with hyperthyroidism.

Post-Chernobyl thyroid carcinoma in children.

The dramatic increase in childhood thyroid carcinoma observed in Belarus and Ukraine as early as 4 years after the Chernobyl nuclear accident, is well recognized as being a consequence of exposure to radioactive iodine fallout. Uncertainties persist concerning the contamination and the dosimetric data. Thyroid nodule, cervical lymph nodes or systematic ultrasound thyroid screening in exposed children led to the diagnosis. The carcinomas affected younger subjects, were less influenced by gender, and were more aggressive at clinical and histological presentation than in the case with naturally occurring carcinoma. Total thyroidectomy and radioiodine treatment remain the treatment of choice. The prognosis is good but further studies are needed to evaluate the prognosis of children presenting with pulmonary metastasis. The project of the Newly Independent States Chernobyl Tissue Bank will facilitate molecular genetic research into this important public health issue. Nevertheless, clinicians must keep in mind the simplicity and the effectiveness of iodine prophylaxis.

Secondary thyroidectomy in patients with prior thyroid surgery for benign disease: a study of 203 cases.

BACKGROUND: The goal of this study was to evaluate the complication rate of secondary thyroidectomy in patients with prior thyroid surgery for benign disease. METHODS: Over an 8-year period, 203 thyroid reoperations were performed on 202 patients. All information relating to operative procedures, pathology, and complications was recorded prospectively. RESULTS: There were 24 men and 178 women with a mean age of 52 years. Prior surgery was unilateral in 136 cases (67%) and bilateral in 67 cases (33%), and 14 patients (6.9%) had more than 1 previous thyroid operation. For euthyroid or pretoxic recurrent nodular goiter, 190 reoperations were performed and 13 reoperations were performed for recurrent thyrotoxicosis. Twenty-three cancers were found in a specimen (11.4%). Completion thyroidectomy was done in 143 patients. Postoperative complications occurred in 21 patients (10.4%): recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy (7 patients), hypocalcemia (8 patients), hematoma requiring surgical evacuation (5 patients), and wound infection (1 patient). Complications remained permanent in 4 patients (2%). CONCLUSIONS: The permanent complication rate is higher in thyroid reoperations than in primary thyroid operations. However, we believe that this 2% rate is low enough to allow reoperation whenever it is necessary, provided precise operative rules are respected.

[What is the contribution of imaging?]. / Que faut-il attendre de l'imagerie?

Thyroid imaging has an essentially diagnostic value, but is also plays a role in definition of indications and operative techniques. Ultrasound is the most useful examination. Scintigraphy has become less useful, but remains indicated in hyperthyroidism and in certain retrosternal goitres inaccessible to ultrasound. The other examinations only have a limited value.