Costimulatory Blockade and Solid Organ Transplantation: The Past, Present, and Future.

Belatacept is the first costimulatory blockade agent clinically approved for transplant immunosuppression. Although more than 10 years of study have demonstrated that belatacept offers superior long-term renal allograft and patient survival compared to conventional calcineurin inhibitor (CNI)-based immunosuppression regimens, the clinical adoption of belatacept has continued to lag because of concerns of an early risk of acute cellular rejection (ACR) and various logistical barriers to its administration. In this review, the history of the clinical development of belatacept is examined, along with the findings of the seminal BENEFIT and BENEFIT-EXT trials culminating in the clinical approval of belatacept. Recent efforts to incorporate belatacept into novel CNI-free immunosuppression regimens are reviewed, as well as the experience of the Emory Transplant Center in using a tapered course of low-dose tacrolimus in belatacept-treated renal allograft patients to garner the long-term outcome benefits of belatacept without the short-term increased risks of ACR. Potential avenues to increase the clinical adoption of belatacept in the future are explored, including surmounting the logistical barriers of belatacept administration through subcutaneous administration or more infrequent belatacept dosing. In addition, belatacept conversion strategies and potential expanded clinical indications of belatacept are discussed for pediatric transplant recipients, extrarenal transplant recipients, treatment of antibody-mediated rejection (AMR), and in patients with failed renal allografts. Finally, we discuss the novel immunosuppressive drugs currently in the development pipeline that may aid in the expansion of costimulation blockade utilization.

Implementation of an Online Intraoperative Assessment of Technical Performance for Surgical Trainees.

INTRODUCTION: Assessment of surgical resident technical performance is an integral component of any surgical training program. Timely assessment delivered in a structured format is a critical step to enhance technical skills, but residents often report that the quality and quantity of timely feedback received is lacking. Moreover, the absence of written feedback with specificity can allow residents to seemingly progress in their operative milestones as a junior resident, but struggle as they progress into their postgraduate year 3 and above. We therefore designed and implemented a web-based intraoperative assessment tool and corresponding summary "dashboard" to facilitate real-time assessment and documentation of technical performance. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A web form was designed leveraging a cloud computing platform and implementing a modified Ottawa Surgical Competency Operating Room Evaluation instrument; this included additional, procedure-specific criteria for select operations. A link to this was provided to residents via email and to all surgical faculty as a Quick Response code. Residents open and complete a portion of the form on a smartphone, then relinquish the device to an attending surgeon who then completes and submits the assessment. The data are then transferred to a secure web-based reporting interface; each resident (together with a faculty advisor) can then access and review all completed assessments. RESULTS: The Assessment form was activated in June 2021 and formally introduced to all residents in July 2021, with residents required to complete at least one assessment per month. Residents with less predictable access to operative procedures (night float or Intensive Care Unit) were exempted from the requirement on those months. To date a total of 559 assessments have been completed for operations performed by 56 trainees, supervised by 122 surgical faculty and senior trainees. The mean number of procedures assessed per resident was 10.0 and the mean number per assessor was 4.6. Resident initiation of Intraoperative Assessments has increased since the tool was introduced and scores for technical and nontechnical performance reliably differentiate residents by seniority. CONCLUSIONS: This novel system demonstrates that an online, resident-initiated technical assessment tool is feasible to implement and scale. This model's requirement that the attending enter performance ratings into the trainee's electronic device ensures that feedback is delivered directly to the trainee. Whether this aspect of our assessment ensures more direct and specific (and therefore potentially actionable) feedback is a focus for future study. Our use of commercial cloud computing services should permit cost-effective adoption of similar systems at other training programs.

Memory T follicular helper cells drive donor-specific antibodies independent of memory B cells and primary germinal center and alloantibody formation.

Human leukocyte antigen antibodies are important immunologic mediators of renal allograft loss and are difficult to control. The inability to permanently eliminate donor-specific antibodies (DSA) is partly due to an incomplete understanding of the cellular mechanisms driving alloantibody formation, recurrence, and maintenance. Memory T follicular helper (mTfh) cells rapidly interact with memory B cells upon antigen re-exposure for anamnestic humoral responses, but little is known about Tfh memory in transplantation. We hypothesized that alloreactive mTfh cells form after transplantation and play a critical role in DSA formation following alloantigen re-encounter. To test this hypothesis, we utilized murine skin allograft models to identify and characterize Tfh memory and interrogate its ability to mediate alloantibody responses. We identified alloreactive Tfh memory as a mediator of accelerated humoral alloresponses independent of memory B cells and primary germinal center, or DSA, formation. Furthermore, we demonstrate that mTfh-driven alloantibody formation is susceptible to CD28 costimulation blockade. These findings provide novel insight into a pathologic role for memory Tfh in alloantibody responses and strongly support shifting therapeutic focus from the singular targeting of B cell lineage cells and alloantibodies themselves to multimodal strategies that include inhibition of mTfh cells to treat DSA.

Three-year Outcomes After Conversion From Monthly to Every 2-month Belatacept Maintenance Therapy in Kidney Transplant Recipients: Results From a Randomized Controlled Trial.

Maintenance immunosuppression with belatacept following kidney transplantation results in improved long-term graft function as compared with calcineurin inhibitors. However, broad application of belatacept has been limited, in part related to logistical barriers surrounding a monthly (q1m) infusion requirement. Methods: To determine whether every 2-mo (q2m) belatacept is noninferior to standard q1m maintenance, we conducted a prospective, single-center randomized trial in low-immunologic-risk, stable renal transplant recipients. Here, post hoc analysis of 3-y outcomes, including renal function and adverse events, are reported. Results: One hundred sixty-three patients received treatment in the q1m control group (n = 82) or q2m study group (n = 81). Renal allograft function as measured by baseline-adjusted estimated glomerular filtration rate was not significantly different between groups (time-averaged mean difference of 0.2 mL/min/1.73 m2; 95% confidence interval: -2.5, 2.9). There were no statistically significant differences in time to death or graft loss, freedom from rejection, or freedom from donor-specific antibodies (DSAs). During the extended 12- to 36-mo follow-up, 3 deaths, 1 graft loss occurred in the q1m group, compared with 2 deaths, and 2 graft losses in the q2m group. In the q1m group, 1 patient developed DSAs and acute rejection. In the q2m group, 3 patients developed DSAs and 2 associated with acute rejection. Conclusions: Based on the similar renal function and survival at 36 mo compared with q1m, q2m belatacept is a potentially viable maintenance immunosuppressive strategy in low immunologic risk kidney transplant recipients that may facilitate increased clinical utilization of costimulation blockade-based immunosuppression.

CXCL13 Is an Indicator of Germinal Center Activity and Alloantibody Formation Following Transplantation.

Donor-specific antibodies (DSA) are a recognized cause of allograft injury, yet biomarkers that indicate their development posttransplant or guide management are not available. CXCL13 (chemokine [C-X-C motif] ligand 1) is a chemoattractant produced within secondary lymphoid organs necessary for germinal center (GC) and alloantibody formation. Perturbations in serum CXCL13 levels have been associated with humoral immune activity. Therefore, CXCL13 may correlate with the formation of HLA antibodies following transplantation. METHODS: A murine skin graft model was utilized to define the production and kinetics of CXCL13 in response to alloantigen. Human Tfh:B-cell in vitro cocultures were performed to evaluate CXCL13 production by human lymphocytes, and serum from healthy controls and human transplant recipients with and without de novo DSA was tested for CXCL13. RESULTS: CXCL13 was detectable in the blood of allografted mice and correlated with Tfh and GC B-cell responses. Greater CXCL13 expression was observed in the draining lymph nodes of allografted mice as compared with naïve or syngeneic graft recipients, and serum levels preceded the detection of DSA posttransplant. Similarly, productive human Tfh:B-cell interactions that led to plasmablast differentiation and IgG formation also exhibited CXCL13 expression. CXCL13 levels in human transplant recipients with de novo DSA were greater than in healthy controls and stable transplant patients and also correlated with the development of alloantibodies in a small cohort of serially monitored recipients. CONCLUSIONS: CXCL13 indicates GC alloreactivity and alloantibody formation and correlated with DSA formation in kidney transplant recipients, thereby introducing CXCL13 as a potential biomarker for HLA antibodies.

Belatacept and CD28 Costimulation Blockade: Preventing and Reducing Alloantibodies over the Long Term.

Purpose of Review: Highlight developments in T and B cell biology that are helping elucidate the mechanisms underlying CD28 pathway blockade-mediated inhibition of alloantibodies in transplantation, and discuss recent clinical observations on the impact of belatacept on de novo and established HLA antibodies. Recent Findings: The identification of T follicular helper cells as the CD4+ T cell subset required for optimal humoral immunity, along with newly identified roles for CD28 and the B7 molecules on B cell lineage cells has begun to pave the way for improved understanding and discovery of the mechanisms of CD28 costimulation blockade-mediated antibody inhibition. There has been resurgent clinical interest in the ability of belatacept to attenuate alloantibody responses. New reports have continued to document its ability to prevent de novo antibody responses, and more recent studies have surfaced exploring its potential to control nascent or pre-existing HLA antibodies. Summary: A growing understanding of the mechanisms of anti-CD28-mediated alloantibody inhibition and continued clinical successes will guide the clinical optimization of belatacept and next generation CD28 blockers to prevent and reduce alloantibodies over the long-term.

Microencapsulated adult porcine islets transplanted intraperitoneally in streptozotocin-diabetic non-human primates.

BACKGROUND: Xenogeneic donors would provide an unlimited source of islets for the treatment of type 1 diabetes (T1D). The goal of this study was to assess the function of microencapsulated adult porcine islets (APIs) transplanted ip in streptozotocin (STZ)-diabetic non-human primates (NHPs) given targeted immunosuppression. METHODS: APIs were encapsulated in: (a) single barium-gelled alginate capsules or (b) double alginate capsules with an inner, islet-containing compartment and a durable, biocompatible outer alginate layer. Immunosuppressed, streptozotocin-diabetic NHPs were transplanted ip with encapsulated APIs, and graft function was monitored by measuring blood glucose, %HbA1c, and porcine C-peptide. At graft failure, explanted capsules were assessed for biocompatibility and durability plus islet viability and functionality. Host immune responses were evaluated by phenotyping peritoneal cell populations, quantitation of peritoneal cytokines and chemokines, and measurement of anti-porcine IgG and IgM plus anti-Gal IgG. RESULTS: NHP recipients had reduced hyperglycemia, decreased exogenous insulin requirements, and lower percent hemoglobin A1c (%HbA1c) levels. Porcine C-peptide was detected in plasma of all recipients, but these levels diminished with time. However, relatively high levels of porcine C-peptide were detected locally in the peritoneal graft site of some recipients at sacrifice. IV glucose tolerance tests demonstrated metabolic function, but the grafts eventually failed in all diabetic NHPs regardless of the type of encapsulation or the host immunosuppression regimen. Explanted microcapsules were intact, "clean," and free-floating without evidence of fibrosis at graft failure, and some reversed diabetes when re-implanted ip in diabetic immunoincompetent mice. Histology of explanted capsules showed scant evidence of a host cellular response, and viable islets could be found. Flow cytometric analyses of peritoneal cells and peripheral blood showed similarly minimal evidence of a host immune response. Preformed anti-porcine IgG and IgM antibodies were present in recipient plasma, but these levels did not rise post-transplant. Peritoneal graft site cytokine or chemokine levels were equivalent to normal controls, with the exception of minimal elevation observed for IL-6 or IL-1ß, GRO-α, I-309, IP-10, and MCP-1. However, we found central necrosis in many of the encapsulated islets after graft failure, and explanted islets expressed endogenous markers of hypoxia (HIF-1α, osteopontin, and GLUT-1), suggesting a role for non-immunologic factors, likely hypoxia, in graft failure. CONCLUSIONS: With donor xenoislet microencapsulation and host immunosuppression, APIs corrected hyperglycemia after ip transplantation in STZ-diabetic NHPs in the short term. The islet xenografts lost efficacy gradually, but at graft failure, some viable islets remained, substantial porcine C-peptide was detected in the peritoneal graft site, and there was very little evidence of a host immune response. We postulate that chronic effects of non-immunologic factors, such as in vivo hypoxic and hyperglycemic conditions, damaged the encapsulated islet xenografts. To achieve long-term function, new approaches must be developed to prevent this damage, for example, by increasing the oxygen supply to microencapsulated islets in the ip space.

Selective CD28 blockade attenuates CTLA-4-dependent CD8+ memory T cell effector function and prolongs graft survival.

Memory T cells pose a significant problem to successful therapeutic control of unwanted immune responses during autoimmunity and transplantation, as they are differentially controlled by cosignaling receptors such as CD28 and CTLA-4. Treatment with abatacept and belatacept impede CD28 signaling by binding to CD80 and CD86, but they also have the unintended consequence of blocking the ligands for CTLA-4, a process that may inadvertently boost effector responses. Here, we show that a potentially novel anti-CD28 domain antibody (dAb) that selectively blocks CD28 but preserves CTLA-4 coinhibition confers improved allograft survival in sensitized recipients as compared with CTLA-4 Ig. However, both CTLA-4 Ig and anti-CD28 dAb similarly and significantly reduced the accumulation of donor-reactive CD8+ memory T cells, demonstrating that regulation of the expansion of CD8+ memory T cell populations is controlled in part by CD28 signals and is not significantly impacted by CTLA-4. In contrast, selective CD28 blockade was superior to CTLA-4 Ig in inhibiting IFN-γ, TNF, and IL-2 production by CD8+ memory T cells, which in turn resulted in reduced recruitment of innate CD11b+ monocytes into allografts. Importantly, this superiority was CTLA-4 dependent, demonstrating that effector function of CD8+ memory T cells is regulated by the balance of CD28 and CTLA-4 signaling.

T follicular helper cells in the generation of alloantibody and graft rejection.

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: T follicular helper (Tfh) cells are an increasingly relevant CD4 T cell subset responsible for the provision of help to B cells for the generation of an effective humoral immune response. Here we review recent studies that have provided critical insights into the mechanisms of Tfh cell differentiation and function, and introduce newly identified roles for Tfh cells in human disease. RECENT FINDINGS: Novel molecular regulators of the Tfh cell differentiation program along with new found roles for the costimulatory and coinhibitory inducible T cell costimulator (ICOS), programmed death 1, and cytotoxic T lymphocyte antigen 4 pathways on Tfh cell function have been appreciated. Although circulating Tfh and Tfh-like subset signatures have been linked to numerous immune conditions, extrapolation of these findings to organ transplantation is just beginning. SUMMARY: The combination of recent progress with regard to Tfh cell biology at the basic science and clinical levels is guiding the elucidation of the role of Tfh cells in the alloimmune response. Application of this knowledge toward the development of novel therapeutic strategies for use in transplantation is imminent.

2B4 (CD244) induced by selective CD28 blockade functionally regulates allograft-specific CD8+ T cell responses.

Mounting evidence in models of both autoimmunity and chronic viral infection suggests that the outcome of T cell activation is critically impacted by the constellation of co-stimulatory and co-inhibitory receptors expressed on the cell surface. Here, we identified a critical role for the co-inhibitory SLAM family member 2B4 (CD244) in attenuating primary antigen-specific CD8(+) T cell responses in the presence of immune modulation with selective CD28 blockade. Our results reveal a specific up-regulation of 2B4 on antigen-specific CD8(+) T cells in animals in which CD28 signaling was blocked. However, 2B4 up-regulation was not observed in animals treated with CTLA-4 Ig (abatacept) or CD28 blockade in the presence of anti-CTLA-4 mAb. 2B4 up-regulation after CD28 blockade was functionally significant, as the inhibitory impact of CD28 blockade was diminished when antigen-specific CD8(+) T cells were deficient in 2B4. In contrast, 2B4 deficiency had no effect on CD8(+) T cell responses during unmodified rejection or in the presence of CTLA-4 Ig. We conclude that blockade of CD28 signals in the presence of preserved CTLA-4 signals results in the unique up-regulation of 2B4 on primary CD8(+) effectors, and that this 2B4 expression plays a critical functional role in controlling antigen-specific CD8(+) T cell responses.

NF-kappaB p50 and p52 regulate receptor activator of NF-kappaB ligand (RANKL) and tumor necrosis factor-induced osteoclast precursor differentiation by activating c-Fos and NFATc1.

Postmenopausal osteoporosis and rheumatoid joint destruction result from increased osteoclast formation and bone resorption induced by receptor activator of NF-kappaB ligand (RANKL) and tumor necrosis factor (TNF). Osteoclast formation induced by these cytokines requires NF-kappaB p50 and p52, c-Fos, and NFATc1 expression in osteoclast precursors. c-Fos induces NFATc1, but the relationship between NF-kappaB and these other transcription factors in osteoclastogenesis remains poorly understood. We report that RANKL and TNF can induce osteoclast formation directly from NF-kappaB p50/p52 double knockout (dKO) osteoclast precursors when either c-Fos or NFATc1 is expressed. RANKL- or TNF-induced c-Fos up-regulation and activation are abolished in dKO cells and in wild-type cells treated with an NF-kappaB inhibitor. c-Fos expression requires concomitant RANKL or TNF treatment to induce NFATc1 activation in the dKO cells. Furthermore, c-Fos expression increases the number and resorptive capacity of wild-type osteoclasts induced by TNF in vitro. We conclude that NF-kappaB controls early osteoclast differentiation from precursors induced directly by RANKL and TNF, leading to activation of c-Fos followed by NFATc1. Inhibition of NF-kappaB should prevent RANKL- and TNF-induced bone resorption.

TNF-alpha and pathologic bone resorption.

Chronic inflammatory bone diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis, periodontal disease and aseptic periprosthetic osteolysis, are characterized by bone loss around affected joints and teeth caused by increased osteoclastic bone resorption. This resorption is mediated largely by the increased local production of pro-inflammatory cytokines, such as tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNFa). These cytokines may induce resorption indirectly by affecting the production of the essential osteoclast differentiation factor, receptor activator of NF-kB ligand, and/or its soluble decoy receptor, osteoprotegerin, by osteoblast/stromal cells or directly by enhancing proliferation and/or activity of cells in the osteoclast lineage. The importance of TNFa in the pathogenesis of various forms of bone loss is supported by both experimental and clinical evidence. However, TNFa is not absolutely required for osteoclastogenesis, erosive arthritis, or osteolysis, as all these events could occur in the absence of TNFa and whether TNFa promotes osteoclast formation independently of RANK signaling is still a topic of debate. Here we review our current understanding of the mechanisms whereby TNFa increases osteoclastogenesis in vitro and in vivo.