Fe-S biogenesis by SMS and SUF pathways: A focus on the assembly step.

FeS clusters are prosthetic groups present in all organisms. Proteins with FeS centers are involved in most cellular processes. ISC and SUF are machineries necessary for the formation and insertion of FeS in proteins. Recently, a phylogenetic analysis on more than 10,000 genomes of prokaryotes have uncovered two new systems, MIS and SMS, which were proposed to be ancestral to ISC and SUF. SMS is composed of SmsBC, two homologs of SufBC(D), the scaffolding complex of SUF. In this review, we will specifically focus on the current knowledge of the SUF system and on the new perspectives given by the recent discovery of its ancestor, the SMS system.

When iron and sulfur met on an anoxic planet and eventually made clusters essential for life.

[FeS] clusters are co-factors that are essential for life and are synthesized by dedicated multiprotein cellular machineries. In this review, we present the current scenario for the emergence and the diversification of the [FeS] cluster biosynthesis machineries. In addition to well-known NIF, ISC and SUF machineries, two alternative minimal systems, SMS, and MIS, were recently identified. Taxonomic distribution and phylogeny analyses indicate that SMS and MIS were present in the Last Universal Common Ancestor (LUCA), well before the increase of oxygen on Earth. ISC, SUF and NIF systems emerged later in the history of life. The possible reasons for the emergence and diversification of these machineries are discussed.

Multimodal Spectroscopic Analysis of the Fe-S Clusters of the as-Isolated Escherichia coli SufBC2D Complex.

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are essential inorganic cofactors dedicated to a wide range of biological functions, including electron transfer and catalysis. Specialized multiprotein machineries present in all types of organisms support their biosynthesis. These machineries encompass a scaffold protein, on which Fe-S clusters are assembled before being transferred to cellular targets. Here, we describe the first characterization of the native Fe-S cluster of the anaerobically purified SufBC2D scaffold from Escherichia coli by XAS and Mössbauer, UV-visible absorption, and EPR spectroscopies. Interestingly, we propose that SufBC2D harbors two iron-sulfur-containing species, a [2Fe-2S] cluster and an as-yet unidentified species. Mutagenesis and biochemistry were used to propose amino acid ligands for the [2Fe-2S] cluster, supporting the hypothesis that both SufB and SufD are involved in the Fe-S cluster ligation. The [2Fe-2S] cluster can be transferred to ferredoxin in agreement with the SufBC2D scaffold function. These results are discussed in the context of Fe-S cluster biogenesis.

An organic O donor for biological hydroxylation reactions.

All biological hydroxylation reactions are thought to derive the oxygen atom from one of three inorganic oxygen donors, O2, H2O2, or H2O. Here, we have identified the organic compound prephenate as the oxygen donor for the three hydroxylation steps of the O2-independent biosynthetic pathway of ubiquinone, a widely distributed lipid coenzyme. Prephenate is an intermediate in the aromatic amino acid pathway and genetic experiments showed that it is essential for ubiquinone biosynthesis in Escherichia coli under anaerobic conditions. Metabolic labeling experiments with 18O-shikimate, a precursor of prephenate, demonstrated the incorporation of 18O atoms into ubiquinone. The role of specific iron-sulfur enzymes belonging to the widespread U32 protein family is discussed. Prephenate-dependent hydroxylation reactions represent a unique biochemical strategy for adaptation to anaerobic environments.

Matching the ß-oxidation gene repertoire with the wide diversity of fatty acids.

Bacteria can use fatty acids (FAs) from their environment as carbon and energy source. This catabolism is performed by the enzymes of the well-known ß-oxidation machinery, producing reducing power and releasing acetyl-CoA that can feed the tricarboxylic acid cycle. FAs are extremely diverse: they can be saturated or (poly)unsaturated and are found in different sizes. The need to degrade such a wide variety of compounds may explain why so many seemingly homologous enzymes are found for each step of the ß-oxidation cycle. In addition, the degradation of unsaturated fatty acids requires specific auxiliary enzymes for isomerase and reductase reactions. Furthermore, the ß-oxidation cycle can be blocked by dead-end products, which are taken care of by acyl-CoA thioesterases. Yet, the functional characterization of the enzymes required for the degradation of the full diversity of FAs remains to be documented in most bacteria.

Components of iron-Sulfur cluster assembly machineries are robust phylogenetic markers to trace the origin of mitochondria and plastids.

Establishing the origin of mitochondria and plastids is key to understand 2 founding events in the origin and early evolution of eukaryotes. Recent advances in the exploration of microbial diversity and in phylogenomics approaches have indicated a deep origin of mitochondria and plastids during the diversification of Alphaproteobacteria and Cyanobacteria, respectively. Here, we strongly support these placements by analyzing the machineries for assembly of iron-sulfur ([Fe-S]) clusters, an essential function in eukaryotic cells that is carried out in mitochondria by the ISC machinery and in plastids by the SUF machinery. We assessed the taxonomic distribution of ISC and SUF in representatives of major eukaryotic supergroups and analyzed the phylogenetic relationships with their prokaryotic homologues. Concatenation datasets of core ISC proteins show an early branching of mitochondria within Alphaproteobacteria, right after the emergence of Magnetococcales. Similar analyses with the SUF machinery place primary plastids as sister to Gloeomargarita within Cyanobacteria. Our results add to the growing evidence of an early emergence of primary organelles and show that the analysis of essential machineries of endosymbiotic origin provide a robust signal to resolve ancient and fundamental steps in eukaryotic evolution.

Role of the Escherichia coli ubiquinone-synthesizing UbiUVT pathway in adaptation to changing respiratory conditions.

Isoprenoid quinones are essential for cellular physiology. They act as electron and proton shuttles in respiratory chains and various biological processes. Escherichia coli and many α-, ß-, and γ-proteobacteria possess two types of isoprenoid quinones: ubiquinone (UQ) is mainly used under aerobiosis, while demethylmenaquinones (DMK) are mostly used under anaerobiosis. Yet, we recently established the existence of an anaerobic O2-independent UQ biosynthesis pathway controlled by ubiT, ubiU, and ubiV genes. Here, we characterize the regulation of ubiTUV genes in E. coli. We show that the three genes are transcribed as two divergent operons that are both under the control of the O2-sensing Fnr transcriptional regulator. Phenotypic analyses using a menA mutant devoid of DMK revealed that UbiUV-dependent UQ synthesis is essential for nitrate respiration and uracil biosynthesis under anaerobiosis, while it contributes, though modestly, to bacterial multiplication in the mouse gut. Moreover, we showed by genetic study and 18O2 labeling that UbiUV contributes to the hydroxylation of ubiquinone precursors through a unique O2-independent process. Last, we report the crucial role of ubiT in allowing E. coli to shift efficiently from anaerobic to aerobic conditions. Overall, this study uncovers a new facet of the strategy used by E. coli to adjust its metabolism on changing O2 levels and respiratory conditions. This work links respiratory mechanisms to phenotypic adaptation, a major driver in the capacity of E. coli to multiply in gut microbiota and of facultative anaerobic pathogens to multiply in their host. IMPORTANCE Enterobacteria multiplication in the gastrointestinal tract is linked to microaerobic respiration and associated with various inflammatory bowel diseases. Our study focuses on the biosynthesis of ubiquinone, a key player in respiratory chains, under anaerobiosis. The importance of this study stems from the fact that UQ usage was for long considered to be restricted to aerobic conditions. Here we investigated the molecular mechanism allowing UQ synthesis in the absence of O2 and searched for the anaerobic processes that UQ is fueling in such conditions. We found that UQ biosynthesis involves anaerobic hydroxylases, that is, enzymes able to insert an O atom in the absence of O2. We also found that anaerobically synthesized UQ can be used for respiration on nitrate and the synthesis of pyrimidine. Our findings are likely to be applicable to most facultative anaerobes, which count many pathogens (Salmonella, Shigella, and Vibrio) and will help in unraveling microbiota dynamics.

Analysis of a logical regulatory network reveals how Fe-S cluster biogenesis is controlled in the face of stress.

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are important cofactors conserved in all domains of life, yet their synthesis and stability are compromised in stressful conditions such as iron deprivation or oxidative stress. Two conserved machineries, Isc and Suf, assemble and transfer Fe-S clusters to client proteins. The model bacterium Escherichia coli possesses both Isc and Suf, and in this bacterium utilization of these machineries is under the control of a complex regulatory network. To better understand the dynamics behind Fe-S cluster biogenesis in E. coli, we here built a logical model describing its regulatory network. This model comprises three biological processes: 1) Fe-S cluster biogenesis, containing Isc and Suf, the carriers NfuA and ErpA, and the transcription factor IscR, the main regulator of Fe-S clusters homeostasis; 2) iron homeostasis, containing the free intracellular iron regulated by the iron sensing regulator Fur and the non-coding regulatory RNA RyhB involved in iron sparing; 3) oxidative stress, representing intracellular H2O2 accumulation, which activates OxyR, the regulator of catalases and peroxidases that decompose H2O2 and limit the rate of the Fenton reaction. Analysis of this comprehensive model reveals a modular structure that displays five different types of system behaviors depending on environmental conditions, and provides a better understanding on how oxidative stress and iron homeostasis combine and control Fe-S cluster biogenesis. Using the model, we were able to predict that an iscR mutant would present growth defects in iron starvation due to partial inability to build Fe-S clusters, and we validated this prediction experimentally.

The thiolation of uridine 34 in tRNA, which controls protein translation, depends on a [4Fe-4S] cluster in the archaeum Methanococcus maripaludis.

Thiolation of uridine 34 in the anticodon loop of several tRNAs is conserved in the three domains of life and guarantees fidelity of protein translation. U34-tRNA thiolation is catalyzed by a complex of two proteins in the eukaryotic cytosol (named Ctu1/Ctu2 in humans), but by a single NcsA enzyme in archaea. We report here spectroscopic and biochemical experiments showing that NcsA from Methanococcus maripaludis (MmNcsA) is a dimer that binds a [4Fe-4S] cluster, which is required for catalysis. Moreover, the crystal structure of MmNcsA at 2.8 Å resolution shows that the [4Fe-4S] cluster is coordinated by three conserved cysteines only, in each monomer. Extra electron density on the fourth nonprotein-bonded iron most likely locates the binding site for a hydrogenosulfide ligand, in agreement with the [4Fe-4S] cluster being used to bind and activate the sulfur atom of the sulfur donor. Comparison of the crystal structure of MmNcsA with the AlphaFold model of the human Ctu1/Ctu2 complex shows a very close superposition of the catalytic site residues, including the cysteines that coordinate the [4Fe-4S] cluster in MmNcsA. We thus propose that the same mechanism for U34-tRNA thiolation, mediated by a [4Fe-4S]-dependent enzyme, operates in archaea and eukaryotes.

Bioenergetic State of Escherichia coli Controls Aminoglycoside Susceptibility.

Aminoglycosides (AG) have been used against Gram-negative bacteria for decades. Yet, how bacterial metabolism and environmental conditions modify AG toxicity is poorly understood. Here, we show that the level of AG susceptibility varies depending on the nature of the respiratory chain that Escherichia coli uses for growth, i.e., oxygen, nitrate, or fumarate. We show that all components of the fumarate respiratory chain, namely, hydrogenases 2 and 3, the formate hydrogenlyase complex, menaquinone, and fumarate reductase are required for AG-mediated killing under fumarate respiratory conditions. In addition, we show that the AAA+ ATPase RavA and its Von Wildebrand domain-containing partner, ViaA, are essential for AG to act under fumarate respiratory conditions. This effect was true for all AG that were tested but not for antibiotics from other classes. In addition, we show that the sensitizing effect of RavA-ViaA is due to increased gentamicin uptake in a proton motive force-dependent manner. Interestingly, the sensitizing effect of RavA-ViaA was prominent in poor energy conservation conditions, i.e., with fumarate, but dispensable under high energy conservation conditions, i.e., in the presence of nitrate or oxygen. We propose that RavA-ViaA can facilitate uptake of AG across the membrane in low-energy cellular states. IMPORTANCE Antibiotic resistance is a major public health, social, and economic problem. Aminoglycosides (AG) are known to be highly effective against Gram-negative bacteria, but their use is limited to life-threatening infections because of their nephrotoxicity and ototoxicity at therapeutic dose. Elucidation of AG-sensitization mechanisms in bacteria would allow reduced effective doses of AG. Here, we have identified the molecular components involved in anaerobic fumarate respiration that are required for AG to kill. In addition to oxidoreductases and menaquinone, this includes new molecular players, RavA, an AAA+ ATPase, and ViaA, its partner that has the VWA motif. Remarkably, the influence of RavA-ViaA on AG susceptibility varies according to the type of bioenergetic metabolism used by E. coli. This is a significant advance because anaerobiosis is well known to reduce the antibacterial activity of AG. This study highlights the critical importance of the relationship between culture conditions, metabolism, and antibiotic susceptibility.

An early origin of iron-sulfur cluster biosynthesis machineries before Earth oxygenation.

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are ubiquitous cofactors essential for life. It is largely thought that the emergence of oxygenic photosynthesis and progressive oxygenation of the atmosphere led to the origin of multiprotein machineries (ISC, NIF and SUF) assisting Fe-S cluster synthesis in the presence of oxidative stress and shortage of bioavailable iron. However, previous analyses have left unclear the origin and evolution of these systems. Here, we combine exhaustive homology searches with genomic context analysis and phylogeny to precisely identify Fe-S cluster biogenesis systems in over 10,000 archaeal and bacterial genomes. We highlight the existence of two additional and clearly distinct 'minimal' Fe-S cluster assembly machineries, MIS (minimal iron-sulfur) and SMS (SUF-like minimal system), which we infer in the last universal common ancestor (LUCA) and we experimentally validate SMS as a bona fide Fe-S cluster biogenesis system. These ancestral systems were kept in archaea whereas they went through stepwise complexification in bacteria to incorporate additional functions for higher Fe-S cluster synthesis efficiency leading to SUF, ISC and NIF. Horizontal gene transfers and losses then shaped the current distribution of these systems, driving ecological adaptations such as the emergence of aerobic lifestyles in archaea. Our results show that dedicated machineries were in place early in evolution to assist Fe-S cluster biogenesis and that their origin is not directly linked to Earth oxygenation.

The AAA+ ATPase RavA and its binding partner ViaA modulate E. coli aminoglycoside sensitivity through interaction with the inner membrane.

Enteric bacteria have to adapt to environmental stresses in the human gastrointestinal tract such as acid and nutrient stress, oxygen limitation and exposure to antibiotics. Membrane lipid composition has recently emerged as a key factor for stress adaptation. The E. coli ravA-viaA operon is essential for aminoglycoside bactericidal activity under anaerobiosis but its mechanism of action is unclear. Here we characterise the VWA domain-protein ViaA and its interaction with the AAA+ ATPase RavA, and find that both proteins localise at the inner cell membrane. We demonstrate that RavA and ViaA target specific phospholipids and subsequently identify their lipid-binding sites. We further show that mutations abolishing interaction with lipids restore induced changes in cell membrane morphology and lipid composition. Finally we reveal that these mutations render E. coli gentamicin-resistant under fumarate respiration conditions. Our work thus uncovers a ravA-viaA-based pathway which is mobilised in response to aminoglycosides under anaerobiosis and engaged in cell membrane regulation.

Degradation of Exogenous Fatty Acids in Escherichia coli.

Many bacteria possess all the machineries required to grow on fatty acids (FA) as a unique source of carbon and energy. FA degradation proceeds through the ß-oxidation cycle that produces acetyl-CoA and reduced NADH and FADH cofactors. In addition to all the enzymes required for ß-oxidation, FA degradation also depends on sophisticated systems for its genetic regulation and for FA transport. The fact that these machineries are conserved in bacteria suggests a crucial role in environmental conditions, especially for enterobacteria. Bacteria also possess specific enzymes required for the degradation of FAs from their environment, again showing the importance of this metabolism for bacterial adaptation. In this review, we mainly describe FA degradation in the Escherichia coli model, and along the way, we highlight and discuss important aspects of this metabolism that are still unclear. We do not detail exhaustively the diversity of the machineries found in other bacteria, but we mention them if they bring additional information or enlightenment on specific aspects.

Cellular assays identify barriers impeding iron-sulfur enzyme activity in a non-native prokaryotic host.

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are ancient and ubiquitous protein cofactors and play irreplaceable roles in many metabolic and regulatory processes. Fe-S clusters are built and distributed to Fe-S enzymes by dedicated protein networks. The core components of these networks are widely conserved and highly versatile. However, Fe-S proteins and enzymes are often inactive outside their native host species. We sought to systematically investigate the compatibility of Fe-S networks with non-native Fe-S enzymes. By using collections of Fe-S enzyme orthologs representative of the entire range of prokaryotic diversity, we uncovered a striking correlation between phylogenetic distance and probability of functional expression. Moreover, coexpression of a heterologous Fe-S biogenesis pathway increases the phylogenetic range of orthologs that can be supported by the foreign host. We also find that Fe-S enzymes that require specific electron carrier proteins are rarely functionally expressed unless their taxon-specific reducing partners are identified and co-expressed. We demonstrate how these principles can be applied to improve the activity of a radical S-adenosyl methionine(rSAM) enzyme from a Streptomyces antibiotic biosynthesis pathway in Escherichia coli. Our results clarify how oxygen sensitivity and incompatibilities with foreign Fe-S and electron transfer networks each impede heterologous activity. In particular, identifying compatible electron transfer proteins and heterologous Fe-S biogenesis pathways may prove essential for engineering functional Fe-S enzyme-dependent pathways.

The Fe-S proteome of Escherichia coli: prediction, function, and fate.

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are inorganic ubiquitous and ancient cofactors. Fe-S-bound proteins contribute to most cellular processes, including DNA replication and integrity, genetic expression and regulation, metabolism, biosynthesis, and most bioenergetics systems. Also, Fe-S proteins hold a great biotechnological potential in metabolite and chemical production, including antibiotics. From classic biophysics and spectroscopy methodologies to recent development in bioinformatics, including structural modeling and chemoproteomics, our capacity to predict and identify Fe-S proteins has spectacularly increased over the recent years. Here, these developments are presented and collectively used to update the composition of Escherichia coli Fe-S proteome, for which we predict 181 occurrences, i.e. 40 more candidates than in our last catalog, and equivalent to 4% of its total proteome. Besides, Fe-S clusters can be targeted by redox active compounds or reactive oxygen and nitrosative species, and even be destabilized by contaminant metals. Accordingly, we discuss how cells handle damaged Fe-S proteins, i.e. degradation, recycling, or repair.

Bacterial Approaches for Assembling Iron-Sulfur Proteins.

Building iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters and assembling Fe-S proteins are essential actions for life on Earth. The three processes that sustain life, photosynthesis, nitrogen fixation, and respiration, require Fe-S proteins. Genes coding for Fe-S proteins can be found in nearly every sequenced genome. Fe-S proteins have a wide variety of functions, and therefore, defective assembly of Fe-S proteins results in cell death or global metabolic defects. Compared to alternative essential cellular processes, there is less known about Fe-S cluster synthesis and Fe-S protein maturation. Moreover, new factors involved in Fe-S protein assembly continue to be discovered. These facts highlight the growing need to develop a deeper biological understanding of Fe-S cluster synthesis, holo-protein maturation, and Fe-S cluster repair. Here, we outline bacterial strategies used to assemble Fe-S proteins and the genetic regulation of these processes. We focus on recent and relevant findings and discuss future directions, including the proposal of using Fe-S protein assembly as an antipathogen target.

The Biosynthetic Pathway of Ubiquinone Contributes to Pathogenicity of Francisella novicida.

Francisella tularensis is the causative agent of tularemia. Because of its extreme infectivity and high mortality rate, this pathogen was classified as a biothreat agent. Francisella spp. are strict aerobes, and ubiquinone (UQ) has been previously identified in these bacteria. While the UQ biosynthetic pathways were extensively studied in Escherichia coli, allowing the identification of 15 Ubi proteins to date, little is known about Francisella spp. In this study, and using Francisella novicida as a surrogate organism, we first identified ubiquinone 8 (UQ8) as the major quinone found in the membranes of this bacterium. Next, we characterized the UQ biosynthetic pathway in F. novicida using a combination of bioinformatics, genetics, and biochemical approaches. Our analysis disclosed the presence in Francisella of 10 putative Ubi proteins, and we confirmed 8 of them by heterologous complementation in E. coli. The UQ biosynthetic pathways from F. novicida and E. coli share similar patterns. However, differences were highlighted: the decarboxylase remains unidentified in Francisella spp., and homologs of the Ubi proteins involved in the O2-independent UQ pathway are not present. This is in agreement with the strictly aerobic niche of this bacterium. Next, via two approaches, i.e., the use of an inhibitor (3-amino-4-hydroxybenzoic acid) and a transposon mutant, both of which strongly impair the synthesis of UQ, we demonstrated that UQ is essential for the growth of F. novicida in respiratory medium and contributes to its pathogenicity in Galleria mellonella used as an alternative animal model. IMPORTANCE Francisella tularensis is the causative bacterium of tularemia and is classified as a biothreat agent. Using multidisciplinary approaches, we investigated the ubiquinone (UQ) biosynthetic pathway that operates in F. novicida used as a surrogate. We show that UQ8 is the major quinone identified in the membranes of Francisella novicida. We identified a new competitive inhibitor that strongly decreased the biosynthesis of UQ. Our demonstration of the crucial roles of UQ for the respiratory metabolism of F. novicida and for the involvement in its pathogenicity in the Galleria mellonella model should stimulate the search for selective inhibitors of bacterial UQ biosynthesis.

Iron-sulfur biology invades tRNA modification: the case of U34 sulfuration.

Sulfuration of uridine 34 in the anticodon of tRNAs is conserved in the three domains of life, guaranteeing fidelity of protein translation. In eubacteria, it is catalyzed by MnmA-type enzymes, which were previously concluded not to depend on an iron-sulfur [Fe-S] cluster. However, we report here spectroscopic and iron/sulfur analysis, as well as in vitro catalytic assays and site-directed mutagenesis studies unambiguously showing that MnmA from Escherichia coli can bind a [4Fe-4S] cluster, which is essential for sulfuration of U34-tRNA. We propose that the cluster serves to bind and activate hydrosulfide for nucleophilic attack on the adenylated nucleoside. Intriguingly, we found that E. coli cells retain s2U34 biosynthesis in the ΔiscUA ΔsufABCDSE strain, lacking functional ISC and SUF [Fe-S] cluster assembly machineries, thus suggesting an original and yet undescribed way of maturation of MnmA. Moreover, we report genetic analysis showing the importance of MnmA for sustaining oxidative stress.

Redox controls RecA protein activity via reversible oxidation of its methionine residues.

Reactive oxygen species (ROS) cause damage to DNA and proteins. Here, we report that the RecA recombinase is itself oxidized by ROS. Genetic and biochemical analyses revealed that oxidation of RecA altered its DNA repair and DNA recombination activities. Mass spectrometry analysis showed that exposure to ROS converted four out of nine Met residues of RecA to methionine sulfoxide. Mimicking oxidation of Met35 by changing it for Gln caused complete loss of function, whereas mimicking oxidation of Met164 resulted in constitutive SOS activation and loss of recombination activity. Yet, all ROS-induced alterations of RecA activity were suppressed by methionine sulfoxide reductases MsrA and MsrB. These findings indicate that under oxidative stress MsrA/B is needed for RecA homeostasis control. The implication is that, besides damaging DNA structure directly, ROS prevent repair of DNA damage by hampering RecA activity.