Comment on "Percolation transitions are not always sharpened by making networks interdependent".

A Comment on the Letter by S. W. Son, P. Grassberger, and M. Paczuski, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 195702 (2011). The authors of the Letter offer a Reply.

Ribosome crystallography: catalysis and evolution of peptide-bond formation, nascent chain elongation and its co-translational folding.

A ribosome is a ribozyme polymerizing amino acids, exploiting positional- and substrate-mediated chemical catalysis. We showed that peptide-bond formation is facilitated by the ribosomal architectural frame, provided by a sizable symmetry-related region in and around the peptidyl transferase centre, suggesting that the ribosomal active site was evolved by gene fusion. Mobility in tunnel components is exploited for elongation arrest as well as for trafficking nascent proteins into the folding space bordered by the bacterial chaperone, namely the trigger factor.

High resolution structure of the large ribosomal subunit from a mesophilic eubacterium.

We describe the high resolution structure of the large ribosomal subunit from Deinococcus radiodurans (D50S), a gram-positive mesophile suitable for binding of antibiotics and functionally relevant ligands. The over-all structure of D50S is similar to that from the archae bacterium Haloarcula marismortui (H50S); however, a detailed comparison revealed significant differences, for example, in the orientation of nucleotides in peptidyl transferase center and in the structures of many ribosomal proteins. Analysis of ribosomal features involved in dynamic aspects of protein biosynthesis that are partially or fully disordered in H50S revealed the conformations of intersubunit bridges in unbound subunits, suggesting how they may change upon subunit association and how movements of the L1-stalk may facilitate the exit of tRNA.

Structural basis for the interaction of antibiotics with the peptidyl transferase centre in eubacteria.

Ribosomes, the site of protein synthesis, are a major target for natural and synthetic antibiotics. Detailed knowledge of antibiotic binding sites is central to understanding the mechanisms of drug action. Conversely, drugs are excellent tools for studying the ribosome function. To elucidate the structural basis of ribosome-antibiotic interactions, we determined the high-resolution X-ray structures of the 50S ribosomal subunit of the eubacterium Deinococcus radiodurans, complexed with the clinically relevant antibiotics chloramphenicol, clindamycin and the three macrolides erythromycin, clarithromycin and roxithromycin. We found that antibiotic binding sites are composed exclusively of segments of 23S ribosomal RNA at the peptidyl transferase cavity and do not involve any interaction of the drugs with ribosomal proteins. Here we report the details of antibiotic interactions with the components of their binding sites. Our results also show the importance of putative Mg+2 ions for the binding of some drugs. This structural analysis should facilitate rational drug design.

Crystal structures of complexes of the small ribosomal subunit with tetracycline, edeine and IF3.

The small ribosomal subunit is responsible for the decoding of genetic information and plays a key role in the initiation of protein synthesis. We analyzed by X-ray crystallography the structures of three different complexes of the small ribosomal subunit of Thermus thermophilus with the A-site inhibitor tetracycline, the universal initiation inhibitor edeine and the C-terminal domain of the translation initiation factor IF3. The crystal structure analysis of the complex with tetracycline revealed the functionally important site responsible for the blockage of the A-site. Five additional tetracycline sites resolve most of the controversial biochemical data on the location of tetracycline. The interaction of edeine with the small subunit indicates its role in inhibiting initiation and shows its involvement with P-site tRNA. The location of the C-terminal domain of IF3, at the solvent side of the platform, sheds light on the formation of the initiation complex, and implies that the anti-association activity of IF3 is due to its influence on the conformational dynamics of the small ribosomal subunit.

Ribosomal crystallography: from poorly diffracting microcrystals to high-resolution structures.

The cellular organelles translating the genetic code into proteins, the ribosomes, are large, asymmetric, flexible, and unstable ribonucleoprotein assemblies, hence they are difficult to crystallize. Despite two decades of intensive effort and thorough searches for suitable sources, so far only three crystal types have yielded high-resolution structures: two large subunits (from an archaean and from a mesophilic eubacterium) and one thermophilic small subunit. These structures have added to our understanding of decoding, have revealed dynamic aspects of the biosynthetic process, and have indicated the strategies adopted by ribosomes for interacting between themselves as well as with inhibitors, factors and substrates.

Targeting exposed RNA regions in crystals of the small ribosomal subunits at medium resolution.

Within the framework of ribosomal crystallography, the small subunits are being analyzed, using crystals diffracting to 3 A resolution. The medium resolution electron density map of this subunit, obtained by multiple isomorphous replacement, show recognizable morphologies, strikingly similar to the functional active conformer of the small ribosomal subunit. It contains elongated dense features, traceable as RNA chains as well as globular regions into which the structures determined for isolated ribosomal proteins, or other known structural motifs were fitted. To facilitate unbiased map interpretation, metal clusters are being covalently attached either to the surface of the subunits or to DNA oligomers complementary to exposed ribosomal RNA. Two surface cysteines and the 3' end of the 16S ribosomal RNA have been localized. Targeting several additional RNA regions shed light on their relative exposure and confirmed previous studies concerning their functional relevance.

Structure of functionally activated small ribosomal subunit at 3.3 angstroms resolution.

The small ribosomal subunit performs the decoding of genetic information during translation. The structure of that from Thermus thermophilus shows that the decoding center, which positions mRNA and three tRNAs, is constructed entirely of RNA. The entrance to the mRNA channel will encircle the message when a latch-like contact closes and contributes to processivity and fidelity. Extended RNA helical elements that run longitudinally through the body transmit structural changes, correlating events at the particle's far end with the cycle of mRNA translocation at the decoding region. 96% of the nucleotides were traced and the main fold of all proteins was determined. The latter are either peripheral or appear to serve as linkers. Some may assist the directionality of translocation.

The small ribosomal subunit from Thermus thermophilus at 4.5 A resolution: pattern fittings and the identification of a functional site.

The electron density map of the small ribosomal subunit from Thermus thermophilus, constructed at 4.5 A resolution, shows the recognizable morphology of this particle, as well as structural features that were interpreted as ribosomal RNA and proteins. Unbiased assignments, carried out by quantitative covalent binding of heavy atom compounds at predetermined sites, led to the localization of the surface of the ribosomal protein S13 at a position compatible with previous assignments, whereas the surface of S11 was localized at a distance of about twice its diameter from the site suggested for its center by neutron scattering. Proteins S5 and S7, whose structures have been determined crystallographically, were visually placed in the map with no alterations in their conformations. Regions suitable to host the fold of protein S15 were detected in several positions, all at a significant distance from the location of this protein in the neutron scattering map. Targeting the 16S RNA region, where mRNA docks to allow the formation of the initiation complex by a mercurated mRNA analog, led to the characterization of its vicinity.

Metal compounds as tools for the construction and the interpretation of medium-resolution maps of ribosomal particles.

Procedures were developed exploiting organometallic clusters and coordination compounds in combination with heavy metal salts for derivatization of ribosomal crystals. These enabled the construction of multiple isomorphous replacement (MIR) and multiple isomorphous replacement combined with anomalous scattering medium-resolution electron density maps for the ribosomal particles that yield the crystals diffracting to the highest resolution, 3 A, of the large subunit from Haloarcula marismortui and the small subunit from Thermus thermophilus. The first steps in the interpretation of the 7. 3-A MIR map of the small subunit were made with the aid of a tetrairidium cluster that was covalently attached to exposed sulfhydryls on the particle's surface prior to crystallization. The positions of these sulfhydryls were localized in difference Fourier maps that were constructed with the MIR phases.

Elucidating the medium-resolution structure of ribosomal particles: an interplay between electron cryo-microscopy and X-ray crystallograhy.

BACKGROUND: Ribosomes are the universal cellular organelles that accomplish the translation of the genetic code into proteins. Electron cryo-microscopy (cryo-EM) has yielded fairly detailed three-dimensional reconstructions of ribosomes. These were used to assist in the determination of higher resolution structures by X-ray crystallography. RESULTS: Molecular replacement studies using cryo-EM reconstructions provided feasible packing schemes for crystals of ribosomes and their two subunits from Thermus thermophilus, and of the large subunits from Haloarcula marismortui. For the large subunits, these studies also confirmed the major heavy-atom sites obtained by single isomorphous replacement combined with anomalous diffraction (SIRAS) and by multiple isomorphous replacement combined with anomalous diffraction (MIRAS) at approximately 10 A. Although adequate starting phases could not be obtained for the small subunits, the crystals of which diffract to 3.0 A, cryo-EM reconstructions were indispensable for analyzing their 7.2 A multiple isomorphous replacement (MIR) map. This work indicated that the conformation of the crystallized small subunits resembles that seen within the 70S ribosomes. Subsequently, crystals of particles trapped in their functionally active state were grown. CONCLUSIONS: Single-particle cryo-EM can contribute to the progress of crystallography of non-symmetrical, large and flexible macromolecular assemblies. Besides confirming heavy-atom sites, obtained from flat or overcrowded difference Patterson maps, the cryo-EM reconstructions assisted in elucidating packing arrangements. They also provided tools for the identification of the conformation within the crystals and for the estimation of the level of inherent non-isomorphism.

Crystallographic studies on the ribosome, a large macromolecular assembly exhibiting severe nonisomorphism, extreme beam sensitivity and no internal symmetry.

Crystals, diffracting best to around 3 A, have been grown from intact large and small ribosomal subunits. The bright synchrotron radiation necessary for the collection of the higher-resolution X-ray diffraction data introduces significant decay even at cryo temperatures. Nevertheless, owing to the reasonable isomorphism of the recently improved crystals of the small ribosomal subunits, reliable phases have been extracted at medium resolution (5-6 A) and an interpretable five-derivative MIR map has been constructed. For the crystals of the large subunits, however, the situation is more complicated because at higher resolution (2.7-7 A) they suffer from substantial radiation sensitivity, a low level of isomorphism, instability of the longest unit-cell axis and nonisotropic mosaicity. The 8 A MIR map, constructed to gain insight into this unusual system, may provide feasible reasoning for the odd combination of the properties of these crystals as well as hints for future improvement. Parallel efforts, in which electron-microscopy-reconstructed images are being exploited for molecular-replacement studies, are also discussed.

A milestone in ribosomal crystallography: the construction of preliminary electron density maps at intermediate resolution.

Preliminary electron density maps of the large and the small ribosomal particles from halophilic and thermophilic sources, phased by the isomorphous replacement method, have been constructed at intermediate resolution. These maps contain features comparable in size with what is expected for the corresponding particles, and their packing arrangements are in accord with the schemes obtained by ab-initio procedures as well as with the motifs observed in thin sections of the crystals by electron microscopy. To phase higher resolution data, procedures are being developed for derivatization by specific labeling of the ribosomal particles at selected locations with rather small and dense clusters. Potential binding sites are being inserted either by site directed mutagenesis or by chemical modifications to facilitate cluster binding on the surface of the halophilic large and the thermophilic small ribosomal particles, which yield the crystals diffracting to highest resolution (2.9 and 7.3 A (1 A = 0.1 nm), respectively). For this purpose, the surface of these ribosomal particles is being characterized and procedures are being developed for quantitative detachment of selected ribosomal proteins and for their incorporation into core particles. The genes of these proteins are being cloned, sequenced, mutated to introduce reactive side groups, mainly cysteines, and overexpressed. In parallel, two in situ small and stable complexes were isolated from the halophilic ribosome. Procedures for their crystal production in large quantities are currently being developed. Models, reconstructed at low resolution from crystalline arrays of ribosomes and their large subunits, are being used for initial low-resolution phasing of the X-ray amplitudes. The interpretation of these models stimulated the design and the crystallization of complexes mimicking defined functional states of a higher quality than those obtained for isolated ribosomes. These models also inspired modelling experiments according to results of functional studies, performed elsewhere, focusing on the progression of nascent proteins.

Characterization and preliminary attempts for derivatization of crystals of large ribosomal subunits from Haloarcula marismortui diffracting to 3 A resolution.

An improved form of crystals of large (50 S) ribosomal subunits from Haloarcula marismortui, formally named Halobacterium marismortui, diffracting to 3 A resolution, has been obtained by the addition of 1 mM-Cd2+ to the crystallization medium, which contained more than 1.9 M of other salts. The improved crystals, grown from functionally active particles to an average size of 0.3 mm x 0.3 mm x 0.08 mm, are isomorphous with the previously reported ones, which diffracted to 4.5 A. They are of space group C222(1), cell dimensions a = 210 A, b = 300 A, c = 581 A, and contain one particle in the asymmetric unit. Their superior internal order is reflected not only in their high resolution, but also in their reasonable mosaicity (less than 0.3 degrees). In contrast to the previously grown crystals, the new ones are of adequate mechanical strength and survive well the shock-cooling treatment. Due to their weak diffracting power, all crystallographic studies have been performed with synchrotron radiation. At cryotemperature, these crystals showed no measurable decay for a few days of irradiation and a complete diffraction data set could be collected from a single crystal. Efforts for initial phasing by specific and quantitative derivatization with super-dense heavy-atom clusters are in progress.

Characterization and preliminary crystallographic studies on large ribosomal subunits from Thermus thermophilus.

Diffracting crystals, suitable for X-ray crystallographic analysis, have been obtained from large (50 S) ribosomal subunits from Thermus thermophilus. These crystals, with P4(1)2(1)2 symmetry and a unit cell of 495 A x 495 A x 196 A, reach typically a size of 0.15 mm x 0.25 mm x 0.35 mm. Using synchrotron radiation at cryo-temperature, these crystals diffract X-rays to better than 9 A resolution, and do not show any measurable decay after a few days of irradiation. They complete a series of crystals, grown by us, from ribosomal particles of the same source, including a 30 S subunits, 70 S ribosomes and complexes of the latter with: (1) an oligomer of 35 uridine residues and (2) the same oligonucleotide together with approximately two Phe-tRNA(Phe) molecules. Crystallographic analysis of the various members of this series should provide information for investigating the conformational changes that take place upon the association of ribosomes from their subunits as well as upon binding of non-ribosomal components that participate in protein biosynthesis.