Quality of Reporting Using Good Reporting of A Mixed Methods Study Criteria in Chiropractic Mixed Methods Research: A Methodological Review.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this review was to examine the reporting in chiropractic mixed methods research using Good Reporting of A Mixed Methods Study (GRAMMS) criteria. METHODS: In this methodological review, we searched MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, and the Index to Chiropractic Literature from the inception of each database to December 31, 2020, for chiropractic studies reporting the use of both qualitative and quantitative methods or mixed qualitative methods. Pairs of reviewers independently screened titles, abstracts, and full-text studies, extracted data, and appraised reporting using the GRAMMS criteria and risk of bias with the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT). Generalized estimating equations were used to explore factors associated with reporting using GRAMMS criteria. RESULTS: Of 1040 citations, 55 studies were eligible for review. Thirty-seven of these 55 articles employed either a multistage or convergent mixed methods design, and, on average, 3 of 6 GRAMMS items were reported among included studies. We found a strong positive correlation in scores between the GRAMMS and MMAT instruments (r = 0.78; 95% CI, 0.66-0.87). In our adjusted analysis, publications in journals indexed in Web of Science (adjusted odds ratio = 2.71; 95% CI, 1.48-4.95) were associated with higher reporting using GRAMMS criteria. Three of the 55 studies fully adhered to all 6 GRAMMS criteria, 4 studies adhered to 5 criteria, 10 studies adhered to 4 criteria, and the remaining 38 adhered to 3 criteria or fewer. CONCLUSION: Our findings suggest that reporting in chiropractic mixed methods research using GRAMMS criteria was poor, particularly among studies with a higher risk of bias.

Risk of bias in chiropractic mixed methods research: a secondary analysis of a meta-epidemiological review.

Objective: To examine the risk of bias in chiropractic mixed methods research. Methods: We performed a secondary analysis of a meta-epidemiological review of chiropractic mixed methods studies. We assessed risk of bias with the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT) and used generalized estimating equations to explore factors associated with risk of bias. Results: Among 55 eligible studies, a mean of 62% (6.8 [2.3]/11) of MMAT items were fulfilled. In our adjusted analysis, studies published since 2010 versus pre-2010 (adjusted odds ratio [aOR] = 2.26; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.39 to 3.68) and those published in journals with an impact factor versus no impact factor (aOR = 2.21; 95% CI, 1.33 to 3.68) were associated with lower risk of bias. Conclusion: Our findings suggest opportunities for improvement in the quality of conduct among published chiropractic mixed methods studies. Author compliance with the MMAT criteria may reduce methodological bias in future mixed methods research.

Objectif: examiner le risque de biais dans la recherche sur les méthodes mixtes chiropratiques. Méthodologie: nous avons effectué une analyse secondaire d'un examen méta-épidémiologique d'études de méthodes mixtes chiropratiques. Nous avons examiné le risque de biais avec The Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool, MMAT (l'outil d'évaluation des méthodes mixtes), et utilisé des équations d'estimation généralisées pour explorer les facteurs associés au risque de biais. Résultats: parmi 55 études admissibles, une moyenne de 62 % (6,8 [2,3]/11) des items du MMAT ont été remplis. Dans notre analyse ajustée, les études publiées depuis 2010 versus celles d'avant 2010 (rapport de cotes [aOR] ajusté = 2,26; intervalle de confiance [IC] à 95 %, 1,39 à 3,68), et celles publiées dans des revues avec un indice de citations versus aucun indice de citations (aOR = 2,21; IC à 95 %, 1,33 à 3,68) étaient associées à un risque de biais plus faible. Conclusion: nos résultats suggèrent des opportunités d'amélioration de la qualité de la conduite parmi les études publiées sur les méthodes mixtes chiropratiques. La conformité des auteurs aux critères MMAT peut réduire les biais méthodologiques dans les futures recherches sur les méthodes mixtes.

Quality of reporting in chiropractic mixed methods research: a methodological review protocol.

BACKGROUND: Mixed methods designs are increasingly used in health care research to enrich findings. However, little is known about the frequency of use of this methodology in chiropractic research, or the quality of reporting among chiropractic studies using mixed methods. OBJECTIVE: To quantify the use and quality of mixed methods in chiropractic research, and explore the association of study characteristics (e.g., authorship, expertise, journal impact factor, country and year of publication) with reporting quality. METHODS: We will conduct a systematic search of MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, and the Index to Chiropractic Literature to identify all chiropractic mixed methods studies published from inception of each database to December 31, 2020. Articles reporting the use of both qualitative and quantitative methods, or mixed qualitative methods, will be included. Pairs of reviewers will perform article screening, data extraction, risk of bias with the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT), and appraisal of reporting quality using the Good Reporting of A Mixed Methods Study (GRAMMS) guideline. We will explore the correlation between GRAMMS and MMAT scores, and construct generalized estimating equations to explore factors associated with reporting quality. DISCUSSION: This will be the first methodological review to examine the reporting quality of published mixed methods studies involving chiropractic research. The results of our review will inform opportunities to improve reporting in chiropractic mixed methods studies. Our results will be disseminated in a peer-reviewed publication and presented publicly at conferences and as part of a doctoral thesis.

A Primary Care Provider's Guide to Diet and Nutrition After Spinal Cord Injury.

Physiological changes that occur after spinal cord injury (SCI) are profound and affect almost every organ system in the human body. Energy balance is significantly altered due to motor paralysis, spasticity or flaccidity, neurogenic sarcopenia, neurogenic osteopenia, sympathetic nervous system disruption, and blunted anabolism. Energy expenditure is markedly reduced, whereas hypothalamic control of appetite and satiety is diminished, resulting in discordant energy intake. Ultimately, neurogenic obesity ensues as the result of a positive energy balance. Even though nutritional guidelines for persons with SCI have been available since 2009, the necessity for body composition assessment and total daily energy expenditure was insufficiently addressed such that most individuals with SCI continued in positive energy balance despite "adherence" to the guidelines. Macronutrients must be carefully assessed to optimize caloric intake, while micronutrient consumption may need to be supplemented in order to meet recommended daily allowances. Such a diet would emphasize foods with low caloric yet high nutrient density. This article reviews current literature regarding nutritional requirements for SCI and provides a straightforward plan for implementing more rigorous dietary interventions meant to address the obesity crisis in this especially vulnerable population.

The Value in Mental Health Screening for Individuals With Spinal Cord Injury: What Patients Tell Us.

OBJECTIVE: To gather consumer perspectives of a mental health screening protocol and to identify the incidence of previously unrecognized mental health concerns (case finding). DESIGN: Pilot study using mixed methods: quantitative (survey) and qualitative (interviews). SETTING: Primary care health team in Kitchener, Ontario, Canada. PARTICIPANTS: Patients (N=15) with spinal cord injury living in the community. Participants ranged in age from 21 to 81 years of age (mean=46); 12 were men, 8 had tetraplegia and 5 paraplegia. The number of years since injury ranged from 1 to 32 (mean=13). INTERVENTION: Implementation of a mental health screening protocol consisting of standardized screening tools for depression, anxiety, substance abuse, social isolation, somatoform disorder, functional status, chronic pain, and cognitive impairment. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Positive results on screening tool, acceptability of the screening process, perceptions of the value of screening, and intentions to follow resulting treatment recommendations. RESULTS: Screening identified 11 of 15 individuals with a chronic pain condition; 1 individual screened positive for depression, 1 for anxiety, 3 for potential substance abuse, and 1 for social isolation. Most of the participants (12/13) rated the screening protocol as very acceptable. All but 1 individual intended to follow resulting treatment recommendations. Interview analyses generated themes related to disclosure of experiences that were incomplete that concealed important information and perceptions that the screening protocol failed to assess resiliency. Although perceived as valuable, participants felt screening tools alone did not capture information important to them. CONCLUSIONS: Screening tools alone may not identify mental health issues. Interviews in addition to screening tools are needed to accurately identify mental health issues in this population. Identification of mental health issues is critical to ensuring access to effective interventions and improving health outcomes and quality of life for individuals with SCI.

An approach to interprofessional management of complex patients: a case report.

INTRODUCTION: Complex patients are frequently high-users of health care resources. Case management has been demonstrated to be an effective and efficient approach for this demographic. CASE PRESENTATION: A 36-year old, medically complex male patient was referred to an interprofessional primary care team to optimize health status. Team involvement included a case manager, nurse practitioner, pharmacist, social worker, team assistant and chiropractor. Interventions involved medication management, smoking cessation, mindfulness skills and musculoskeletal treatment. SUMMARY: Complex patients are increasingly managed by teams. To continue, these teams will have to demonstrate positive outcomes and cost-effectiveness. Chiropractors have skills that can enhance team-based patient care.

INTRODUCTION: Les patients ayant des besoins complexes sont souvent ceux qui utilisent le plus les ressources en soins de santé. La gestion de cas s'est avérée être une approche efficace et efficiente pour ce groupe de personnes. PRÉSENTATION DE CAS: Un patient de 36 ans présentant des problèmes de santé complexes a été dirigé vers une équipe interprofessionnelle de soins primaires afin d'optimiser son état de santé. L'équipe comprenait un gestionnaire de cas, un infirmier praticien, un pharmacien, un travailleur social, un assistant d'équipe et un chiropraticien. Les interventions portaient sur la gestion des médicaments, l'abandon du tabac, les compétences liées à la pleine conscience et le traitement musculosquelettique. RÉSUMÉ: Les patients ayant des besoins complexes sont de plus en plus pris en charge par des équipes. Pour continuer à exercer, ces équipes devront démontrer des résultats positifs et un bon rapport coût-efficacité. Les chiropraticiens ont des compétences qui peuvent améliorer les soins aux patients dispensés en équipe.

Degenerative cervical myelopathy: Diagnosis and management in primary care.

OBJECTIVE: To raise awareness about degenerative cervical myelopathy (DCM) and to help family physicians identify, diagnose, and manage DCM more effectively. SOURCES OF INFORMATION: A PubMed search was conducted for articles published between 1970 and October 2017, using the terms cervical myelopathy and degenerative spinal cord injury with family medicine or primary care. MAIN MESSAGE: Owing to limited knowledge of DCM in primary care, along with the large variability of the disease, the diagnosis of DCM is often missed or delayed. The natural course of DCM presents as a stepwise decline, with symptoms ranging from muscle weakness to complete paralysis. All individuals with signs and symptoms should be referred to a spine surgeon for consideration of surgery; those with mild DCM might be offered conservative treatment but should receive a surgical evaluation and opinion nonetheless. Asymptomatic patients with evidence of cord compression on magnetic resonance imaging might need to be referred for assessment; however, surgery is not advised. It is critical to closely monitor asymptomatic individuals or those with mild DCM for neurologic deterioration. CONCLUSION: Degenerative cervical myelopathy is the most common cause of spinal cord dysfunction in adults. This review helps streamline its diagnosis in primary care, allowing for improved chances of early diagnosis and prevention of further neurologic decline among patients.

Myélopathie cervicale dégénérative: Diagnostic et prise en charge en première ligne.

OBJECTIF: Sensibiliser les médecins de famille à la myélopathie cervicale dégénérative (MCD) afin de les aider à dépister, à diagnostiquer et à traiter la maladie de façon plus efficace. SOURCES DE L'INFORMATION: Une recherche d'articles publiés entre 1970 et octobre 2017 a été effectuée sur PubMed à l'aide des mots-clés anglais cervical myelopathy et degenerative spinal cord injury avec family medicine ou primary care. MESSAGE PRINCIPAL: Le diagnostic de MCD reste souvent omis ou retardé en première ligne en raison du peu de connaissances sur la maladie, de même que de la grande variabilité de ses manifestations. L'évolution naturelle de la MCD accuse un déclin par paliers, les symptômes allant d'une faiblesse musculaire à la paralysie complète. Toutes les personnes qui présentent des signes et des symptômes doivent être recommandées en chirurgie de la colonne vertébrale aux fins d'évaluation; les personnes dont le cas est léger peuvent recevoir un traitement prudent, mais doivent quand même recevoir une évaluation et une opinion chirurgicales. Les patients asymptomatiques qui présentent des signes de compression de la moelle épinière à l'imagerie par résonance magnétique devraient être recommandés aux fins d'évaluation; mais la chirurgie leur est déconseillée. Il est essentiel de surveiller de près les personnes asymptomatiques ou celles atteintes d'un cas léger de MCD afin de détecter toute détérioration neurologique. CONCLUSION: La myélopathie cervicale dégénérative est la cause la plus fréquente de dysfonctionnement de la moelle épinière chez les adultes. Cette révision aide à clarifier le diagnostic en première ligne, ce qui améliore les chances de poser un diagnostic précoce et de prévenir tout déclin neurologique supplémentaire chez les patients.

Melanoma in situ: a case report from the patient's perspective.

INTRODUCTION: Melanoma can be a fatal form of skin cancer. The prognosis rapidly deteriorates from the in situ stage (stage 0) to stage 4. As such, early detection and treatment are key. CASE PRESENTATION: A middle-aged patient, who was also a chiropractor, self-identified a small skin lesion using the Chiropractors Guide to Skin Cancer. The primary care physician made a dermatology referral, and biopsy identified melanoma. Surgery was subsequently booked and the lesion was excised with a 5 mm margin. The final pathology report confirmed a diagnosis of melanoma in situ. SUMMARY: As primary contact health care providers chiropractors can play a significant role in the potential identification and initiation of investigations into various possible dermatological disorders including skin cancer. Efforts should be made to diagnose melanoma at the in situ stage to ensure the best outcome.

INTRODUCTION: Le mélanome est un cancer de la peau pouvant être fatal. Le pronostic s'assombrit rapidement entre le stade 0 (mélanome in situ) et le stade 4. Un dépistage et un traitement précoces sont essentiels. PRÉSENTATION DU CAS: Un patient d'âge mûr, qui était aussi un chiropraticien, a décelé chez lui une petite lésion cutanée à l'aide du Chiropractors Guide to Skin Cancer (guide servant à aider le chiropraticien à dépister un cancer de la peau). Un médecin de premier recours l'a dirigé vers un dermatologue; l'examen de la biopsie a révélé un mélanome. Un rendez-vous en chirurgie a été pris. La lésion et une marge chirurgicale de 5 mm ont été excisées. Le rapport final du laboratoire de pathologie a confirmé le diagnostic d'un mélanome in situ. RÉSUMÉ: À titre de fournisseurs de soins de santé primaires, les chiropraticiens peuvent jouer un rôle important dans le dépistage de diverses affections cutanées dont le cancer de la peau et l'amorce des examens exploratoires. On devrait déployer des efforts pour que le mélanome soit diagnostiqué au stade 0 (mélanome in situ) pour assurer la meilleure issue possible.

Nonfunctioning pituitary macroadenoma: a case report from the patient perspective.

BACKGROUND: Nonfunctioning pituitary macroadenoma (NFPA) is a tumour of the endocrine system that is virtually always benign and can be difficult to detect. This case report is presented from the patient's perspective to highlight experiences that led to the eventual diagnosis of this condition. CASE PRESENTATION: A 48 year-old male experienced prolonged and unexplained reduced athletic performance worsening over five years. The patient reported decreased libido, which initiated a testosterone blood test. This confirmed reduced testosterone levels and resulted in an endocrinology referral. A subsequent dynamic contrast MRI of the pituitary region revealed a mass. The most frequent symptoms of NFPA are visual field defects, headaches and features of hypopituitarism (includes fatigue, dizziness, dry skin, irregular periods in women and sexual dysfunction in men). CONCLUSION: Clinicians should consider this differential diagnosis in middle-aged athletes with diminished athletic performance from an unknown cause, test visual fields and inquire if symptoms of headaches or hypopituitarism are present.

Physician perspectives on care of individuals with severe mobility impairments in primary care in Southwestern Ontario, Canada.

Despite the high health risks associated with severe mobility impairments, individuals with physical disabilities are less likely to receive the same level of primary care as able-bodied persons. This study explores family physicians' perspectives on primary care for individuals with mobility impairments to identify and better understand the challenges that prevent equitable service delivery to this group of patients. Semi-structured interviews were conducted in the autumn of 2012 with a purposeful sample of 20 family physicians practising in Southwestern Ontario to gather their perspectives of the personal and professional barriers to healthcare delivery for individuals with mobility impairments, including perceptions of challenges, contributing reasons and possible improvements. A thematic analysis was conducted on the transcripts generated from the interviews to identify perceptions of existing barriers and gaps in care, needs and existing opportunities for improving primary care for this patient population. Eight themes emerged from the interviews that contributed to understanding the perceived challenges of providing care to patients with mobility impairments: transportation barriers, knowledge gaps and practice constraints resulting in episodic care rather than preventive care, incongruence between perceived and actual accessibility to care, emergency departments used as centres for primary care, inattention to mobility issues among specialist and community services, lack of easily accessible practice tools, low patient volumes impact decision-making regarding building decreased motivation to expand clinical capacity due to low patient volume, and lastly, remuneration issues. Despite this patient population presenting with high healthcare needs and significant barriers and care gaps in primary care, low prevalence rates negatively impact the acquisition of necessary equipment and knowledge required to optimally care for these patients in typical primary care settings. Novel approaches to address inequitable healthcare practices for this vulnerable group are needed.

Community-based falls prevention: lessons from an Interprofessional Mobility Clinic.

Falls are a common and serious risk with an aging population. Chiropractors commonly see firsthand the effects of falls and resulting injuries in their senior patients and they can reduce falls risk through active screening. Ongoing research has provided proven approaches for making falls less likely. Screening for falls should be done yearly for all patients 65 years and older or in those with a predisposing medical condition. Additional specific falls prevention professional education would enable the chiropractor to best assist these patients. Collaboration and communication with the patient's family physician offers an opportunity for improved interprofessional dialogue to enhance patient care related to falls risk. Frequently falls prevention strategies are implemented by an interprofessional team. Chiropractors increasingly contribute within multidisciplinary teams. Collaboration by the chiropractor requires both simple screening and knowledge of health care system navigation. Such awareness can permit optimal participation in the care of their patient and the best outcome.

Les chutes présentent un risque commun et grave chez une population vieillissante. Les chiropraticiens constatent habituellement directement les effets des chutes et les blessures conséquentes chez leurs patients âgés; et ils peuvent en réduire les risques grâce à un dépistage actif. Des recherches continues fournissent des méthodes vérifiées de réduction de la probabilité de chutes. Un dépistage des risques de chute doit être effectué chaque année pour tous les patients de 65 ans et plus, ou pour ceux dont l'état de santé les prédispose. Une formation professionnelle supplémentaire spécifique dans la prévention des chutes permettrait au chiropraticien de mieux aider ces patients. La collaboration et la communication avec le médecin de famille du patient offrent une occasion d'améliorer le dialogue interprofessionnel au profit de meilleurs soins prodigués au patient sur les risques de chute. Souvent les stratégies en matière de prévention des chutes sont mises en place par une équipe interprofessionnelle. Les chiropraticiens œuvrent de plus en plus au sein d'équipes multidisciplinaires. La collaboration des chiropraticiens nécessite des compétences pour de simples dépistages, ainsi que des connaissances pour s'orienter dans le système des soins de santé. De telles connaissances permettront au chiropraticien une participation optimale aux soins de son patient et l'obtention des meilleurs résultats.