Longitudinal Force Measurement and its Relationship to Technical Competence for Esophageal Anastomosis in a Thoracoscopic Esophageal Atresia/Tracheo-Esophageal Fistula Simulator.

PURPOSE: Thoracoscopic esophageal atresia with tracheo-esophageal fistula (EA/TEF) repair requires the gentle manipulation of delicate tissue. Force sensors were attached to the upper and lower esophagus of a 3D-printed EA/TEF simulator to explore force parameters as markers of performance. METHODS: Participants completed one intracorporeal suture between the anterior walls of upper and lower esophageal ends. Longitudinal force data were recorded at each end. A blinded pediatric surgeon marked attempt videos. Excessive force events, maximum tension, and force interquartile range (IQR) were measured. Data were reported as median (range) significance of p < 0.05. RESULTS: 17 participants of varying levels of experience performed the task. OSATS scores showed significant differences between experts and novices. Experts completed the task in a median time of 4 min. They used lower maximum tension, higher force IQR, and had fewer excess force events compared to the intermediate and novice groups. DISCUSSION: The application of force was dependent on expertise with more skilled participants having fewer excess force events. The higher expert force IQR likely reflects the consistent tension needed for task completion. Analysis of force data may be an indicator of competence, and trainees may benefit from a thoracoscopic simulator which provides force data feedback. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Not applicable.

Access to emergency paediatric surgery for testicular torsion or intestinal volvulus in New Zealand: A system perspective.

AIM: The risk of organ loss is increased in children with testicular torsion or intestinal volvulus if surgical management is not expedient. The current retrospective study aims to review the time-course from first symptom to 'knife to skin' in these conditions, to determine where delays occur and facilitate a systems approach to better manage these children. METHODS: One hundred consecutive paediatric cases of scrotal exploration for presumed testicular torsion, and 100 neonatal cases presenting with possible malrotation/volvulus were analysed to evaluate the exact time-course of events from admission to surgery. RESULTS: (i) Scrotal exploration: the median time from onset of symptoms to presentation was 12 h (interquartile range (IQR): 5-48 h). In children over 5 years of age, 36% (33/93) were transferred from an external district service area. (ii) Malrotation/volvulus: the median duration of symptoms prior to arrival/assessment was 12 h (IQR: 4-24 h). The median cumulative in-hospital time was over 6 h (368 min, IQR: 247-634 min). CONCLUSIONS: Time to presentation contributes significantly to testicular ischaemic time. This delay to timely surgical intervention is multi-factorial, and must be addressed at a public health level. Support and training in the management of testicular torsion should be provided to all adult surgeons/trainees that may care for these children. In general, this condition is best managed at the presenting hospital whenever appropriate expertise is available. Novel pathways that streamline care may improve efficiency at an institutional level. Addressing issues of access to specialised neonatal surgery is more vexed on account of the tyranny of distance, and the pre-requisite level of surgical expertise required.

How electronically available referral guidelines for primary medical practitioners can improve the timeliness of orchidopexy.

AIM: This study determined whether easily used guidelines and an electronic referral process could decrease the age of referral of suspected undescended testes (UDT). An online resource for primary medical practitioners was introduced for which the UDT guideline advises referral to paediatric surgery for testes not sitting spontaneously in the scrotum at three-months corrected age. METHOD: Data were collected prospectively for boys referred with UDT over a seven-year period (2012-2018), during which time agreed GP guidelines on the Community HealthPathways website for referral were introduced. Trends in the age at referral and age at orchidopexy were analysed. RESULTS: Complete data were obtained for 212 boys. Referral before age six months increased from 13% to 61%, and before 12 months from 48% to 78%. Orchidopexy by 12 months increased from 16% to 39%, and by 18 months from 48% to 74%, during the same period. Median age at orchidopexy for this 2012-2018 cohort was 21.6 months compared with 31.1 months from 1997-2007. DISCUSSION: These data demonstrate earlier referral of boys with UDT and earlier orchidopexy corresponded to the introduction of the GP Community HealthPathways website. A similar resource available in other regions or countries also might be expected to reduce the age of referral of suspected UDT from primary care providers.

Construct validation of a 3D printed neonatal thoracoscopic simulator: Can it measure expertise?

BACKGROUND: acquiring technical expertise for neonatal thoracoscopy is challenging. To address this, we designed a fully synthetic thoracoscopic simulator for which we established its construct validity. METHODS: three thoracoscopic tasks were assessed: ring transfer, needle pass and incision of a blind upper esophageal pouch (EA cut). Participants watched instructional videos with accompanying written instructions for each task before having their attempt video recorded. All tasks were marked by three blinded pediatric surgeons using a modified Objective Structured Assessment of Technical Skills (OSATS). Scores were assessed using appropriate statistical analysis and inter-rater reliability was analyzed by interclass correlation coefficient (ICC). RESULTS: 23 participants completed the ring transfer and needle pass and 21 the EA cut: 5 experts (consultant surgeons), 5 intermediate (registrars on a training program) and 13 novices (medical students, house surgeons or non-training registrars). All three tasks distinguished between novice and intermediate/expert (ring transfer p = 0.00001, needle pass p = 0.0004 and EA cut p = 0.0014, respectively). Interrater reliability was good for ring transfer and needle pass but poor for EA cut. CONCLUSION: the tasks distinguished between novice and intermediate/expert but not between expert and intermediate. In needle pass and EA cut, there was a trend for the experts to score higher than intermediate participants. Ring transfer and needle pass tasks achieved construct validity, had good interrater reliability and were found to be useful in assessing a novice surgeon's progression towards the intermediate level. Distinguishing between intermediate and expert may require assessment of more complex tasks such as intracorporeal suturing and tying. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: II.

The frequency and effects of distractions in operating theatres.

BACKGROUND: Operating theatres (OTs) are complex environments where team members complete difficult tasks under stress. Distractions in these environments can lead to errors that compromise patient safety. A range of potential distractions exist in OTs and previous research suggests they are common. This study assesses the nature, frequency and impact of distracting events in the OT at a tertiary New Zealand hospital. METHODS: Prospective observational study of the frequency, type and impact of OT distractions during a 3-month period. Two observational methods - the frequency of door openings and a validated tool - were used to categorize OT distractions for a range of acute and elective, paediatric and adult surgical procedures according to their cause and effect. RESULTS: There were 57 procedures (2037 intraoperative minutes) observed. During this time, 721 door openings and 1152 other distracting events were recorded. On average, either a door opening or other distracting event was recorded 56 times per hour of intraoperative time. The frequency of distractions did not vary in relation to acute versus elective or paediatric versus adult procedures but were more common in the morning. Communication unrelated to the case was the most common distracting event: these and equipment issues had the greatest effect on the entire surgical team, usually by causing some interruption to operative flow. CONCLUSION: Distractions in OTs were common, occurring nearly every minute. Most were trivial, but some had the potential to disrupt the operative procedure and result in patient harm. Reducing distractions in surgery could reduce patient harm and improve resource use.

Out of tragedy can emerge the finest human qualities.

In March 2019 the Pacific Association of Pediatric Surgeons held its annual conference in Christchurch, New Zealand, a normally peaceful city that was in the process of rebuilding following the devastating earthquakes of 2010 and 2011. Then the day after the conference concluded a horrendous atrocity was committed in two nearby mosques which presented the hospital with 25 years of major gunshot injuries in just one hour. The remarkable response of the hospital and its staff, the victims and the broader community are outlined. Although the surgical response was impressive, lessons could still be learnt. These related to the consequences of the lack of warning as the ED was flooded with casualties, the effects of scoop and run when a disaster occurs near a hospital, limitations around record keeping, the rapid arrival of expert support into ED, pre-empting pressure points, designation of two key destinations and avoiding patient return to ED after imaging, the importance of flexibility and collaboration between services, the consequences on normal hospital activity in the weeks following the incident and the behaviour of victims. The response of PAPS to the event was no less impressive: consistent with its longstanding commitment to the care and welfare of children around the globe, our organisation, donated over $40,000 through the Christchurch Foundation towards scholarships for the children of the victims to support their higher education. Out of tragedy can emerge the finest human qualities.

Academic paediatric surgery in Australia and New Zealand: Its governance, drivers, successes and challenges.

Traditionally, academic surgeons have been expected to excel in research, administration, teaching and clinical work. For many, to be strong in all of these areas is aspirational rather than a reality - and it may not always be a desirable expectation. It is more likely that future academic surgeons will have exceptional ability in several of these domains, but probably not all. Clinical expertise (even if it is within a narrow field) is critical to gaining credibility with non-academic surgical colleagues; and research leadership and substantial ongoing academic output is critical to maintaining credibility among academic surgical colleagues - and facilitates funding success. The Board of Paediatric Surgery is the specialty training board of the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons (RACS) that is responsible for the training program in paediatric surgery for both Australia and New Zealand. "Scholarship and teaching" is designated as being one of the nine competencies RACS expects of all surgeons. Expertise in the domain of scholarship (and research) occurs at two levels: (1) A working knowledge of scientific method, having a critical and curious mind matched with an ability to formulate a research question and contribute to research studies, and an ability to analyse research data and to use it to inform clinical practice. This is expected of all surgeons; and (2) A career academic surgeon with a formal commitment to research which becomes a major component of their work, with the requisite expertise in scientific method to be able to design, set up and complete research studies. The RACS provides support for academia in surgery to flourish in multiple ways and at various stages in the surgeons' career, as described in this chapter. Increasingly, the academic surgeon has to forge links and to collaborate with other research groups. At least in Australia and New Zealand, departments should work to ensure that their academic surgeons are not excessively burdened with departmental leadership and governance roles that do not require specific academic expertise. Arguably, future academic paediatric surgeons will expect to have a better balance in their lives than some of their predecessors!

Master and Apprentice or a Slave to Technology? A Randomized Controlled Trial of Minimal Access Surgery Simulation-Based Training Techniques.

Introduction: This study set out to assess the efficacy of three different approaches to simulation-based minimal access surgery (MAS) training using a three-dimensional printed neonatal thoracoscopic simulator and a virtual simulator. Materials and Methods: Randomized controlled trial of medical students (N = 32), as novices to MAS. The participants performed two construct validated tasks on a thoracoscopic simulator and were then randomly allocated into four intervention groups: (1) three consultant-led sessions on a thoracoscopic simulator; (2) three self-directed learning sessions on the same simulator; (3) self-directed "virtual training" on the "SimuSurg" application; and (4) control. Postintervention participants repeated both tasks. Videos of all task attempts were de-identified and marked by a blinded consultant pediatric surgeon. Results: There were no statistically significant differences in baseline objective structured assessment of technical skills (OSATS) scores or demographics in any group. For the "ring transfer" task, Groups 1 and 2 showed significant improvement after intervention, with no significant change in Groups 3 or 4. There was no significant difference between Groups 1 or 2 in postintervention scores. For the "needle pass" task, no group demonstrated a statistically significant improvement after intervention. Conclusion: Practice on a physical simulator either consultant-led or self-directed led to improved scores for MAS novices compared with a virtual simulator or no intervention for a simple "ring transfer" task. This suggests that time on the physical simulator was the most important factor and implies that trainees could usefully practice simple tasks at their convenience rather than require consultant supervision. This improvement is not seen in more challenging tasks such as the "needle pass."

Contemporary management of Hirschsprung disease in New Zealand.

BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to report the contemporary management of Hirschsprung disease (HD) in New Zealand. METHODS: We undertook a national multi-centre retrospective review of all newly diagnosed cases of HD during a 16-year period (2000-2015). Demographics, genetic and syndromic associations, family history, radiology and histology results and surgical interventions were analysed. RESULTS: A total of 246 cases (males:females 4:1) were identified, an incidence of 1:3870 live births. Short-segment disease was present in 81.7%, long-segment disease in 8.5%, total colonic aganglionosis in 6.5% and unknown in 3.3%. HD was diagnosed by 4 weeks' corrected gestational age in 67%. Thirty cases (12%) also had Trisomy 21. Fifty-three (21.5%) patients required a repeat rectal biopsy for definitive diagnosis. A contrast enema was performed in 55% and identified the transition zone with 69% accuracy. Primary pull-through surgery was undertaken in 59% (65% of short-segment cases) at a median age of 27 days; others were initially managed by a defunctioning stoma. The commonest definitive procedure was a Soave-Boley endorectal pull-through (79%) (or similar variant). During a median follow-up of 7.4 years, six (2.5%) survivors underwent a redo pull-through, 13 (5.5%) an appendicostomy, 16 (6.8%) a defunctioning stoma and 10 never had a definitive procedure. Total colonic aganglionosis was significantly more likely to be fatal (12.5% versus 0.5%, P < 0.0005) or associated with a permanent end stoma (27.5% versus 4.5%, P < 0.0005). CONCLUSIONS: Most New Zealand born infants with short-segment HD are currently managed by primary pull-through, usually in the first months of life.

End-User Input into the Design and Validation of a Synthetic Thoracoscopic Esophageal Atresia/Tracheo-Esophageal Fistula Simulator.

Introduction: Thoracoscopic repair of esophageal atresia and tracheo-esophageal fistula (EA/TEF) is challenging. We addressed this by designing a fully synthetic simulator of the procedure and described the design process and how its content validity was assessed. Methods: An iterative design and assessment of content validity was undertaken in three stages. Data were collected from participants who trialed the model and completed a survey of their experience (adapted from Barsness et al.). Results: The model was trialed by participants of varying experience. Each design refinement improved the model's fidelity and validity. For the last iteration of the simulator, the observed averages (out of a maximum of 5) were: value as a training tool 4.8, relevance 4.6, physical attributes 4.5, realism of material 4.25, realism experience 4.17, and ability to perform tasks 3.77. Conclusion: An iterative design process based on end-user feedback has led to a synthetic simulator that has achieved a high level of content validity. This model has advantages over other EA/TEF simulators in that it is relatively inexpensive and does not use animal tissue, thus removing ethical and procurement issues. It was rated highly for its value and relevance to training.

Development of an instrumented thoracoscopic surgical trainer for objective evaluation of esophageal atresia/tracheoesophageal fistula repair.

Operative repair of complex conditions such as esophageal atresia and tracheoesophageal fistula (EA/TEF) is technically demanding, but few training opportunities exist outside the operating theater for surgeons to attain these skills. Learning them during surgery on actual neonates where the stakes are high, margins for error narrow, and where outcomes are influenced by technical expertise, is problematic. There is an increasing demand for high-fidelity simulation that can objectively measure performance. We developed such a simulator to measure force and motion reliably, allowing quantitative feedback of technical skill. A 3D-printed simulator for thoracoscopic repair of EA/TEF was instrumented with motion and force tracking components. A 3D mouse, inertial measurement unit (IMU), and optical sensor that captured force and motion data in four degrees of freedom (DOF) were calibrated and verified for accuracy. The 3D mouse had low average relative errors of 2.81%, 3.15%, and 6.15% for 0 mm, 10 mm offset in Y, and 10 mm offset in X, respectively. This increased to - 23.5% at an offset of 42 mm. The optical sensors and IMU displayed high precision and accuracy with low SDs and average relative errors, respectively. These parameters can be a useful measurement of performance for thoracoscopic EA/TEF simulation prior to surgery. Graphical abstract Inclusion of sensors into a high-fidelity simulator design can produce quantitative feedback which can be used to objectively asses performance of a technically difficult procedure. As a result, more surgical training can be done prior to operating on actual patients in the operating theater.

Critical design and validation considerations for the development of neonatal minimally invasive surgery simulators.

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE: Pediatric surgical trainees have limited exposure to advanced minimally invasive surgery (MIS) during their clinical training, particularly for cases such as esophageal atresia/tracheoesophageal fistula (EA/TEF). Simulation on validated neonatal models offers an alternative means of training that may augment traditional forms of training; but to be useful, they must fulfill certain criteria. METHODOLOGY: Review of the currently available MIS, thoracoscopic and laparoscopic, simulators for pediatric surgery, and identification of those factors that contribute to their fidelity and validity as a training tool that must be incorporated in the design of future simulation models. RESULTS: There are few neonatal laparoscopic and thoracoscopic models currently available, or in the research stage. To our knowledge, there is no commercially available, synthetic, high fidelity and low cost thoracoscopic model in existence. Use of animal tissue has disadvantages of ethical dilemmas, cost, and logistic and procurement issues. Newer synthetic models need to be validated for fidelity, to replicate those components of the operation that pose the greatest technical challenge, and incorporate means of measuring acquisition of technical expertise. CONCLUSION: This review describes the principles that need to be considered to develop low cost, validated high-fidelity MIS simulator that can be used for training, and that is capable of measuring the acquisition of the technical skills that can be applied to the repair of complex procedures such as esophageal atresia. Level of evidence III.

Ethnic variations in the childhood prevalence of Hirschsprung disease in New Zealand.

BACKGROUND: Epidemiological studies have suggested that there may be ethnic variations in the prevalence of Hirschsprung disease (HD) but no study has systematically investigated this issue or potential ethnic variations in the extent of aganglionosis in HD. This study aimed to investigate this in a childhood population in New Zealand. METHODS: A multicentre national retrospective review was undertaken of all newly diagnosed cases of HD at each of the four paediatric surgical centres in New Zealand over a 16-year period (January 2000 to December 2015). Original histological, radiological and operative reports were obtained and analysed. Self-identified ethnicity was recorded from admission documents. Birth statistics were obtained from Statistics New Zealand. RESULTS: A total of 246 cases of HD were identified. The prevalence of HD was 1:3790 live births for European, 1:6610 among Maori, 1:1834 among Pacific Peoples, 1:3847 among Asian and 1:5694 among Middle Eastern. The prevalence of HD was statistically significantly greater in Pacific Peoples (P < 0.0005). The proportion of children with long-segment HD was also significantly greater in Pacific and Asian populations than others (P = 0.04). These findings were not due to differences in the proportion of familial cases of HD among the different populations. CONCLUSIONS: The prevalence and phenotype of HD varies significantly between different ethnic groups within New Zealand. This may well be related to variations in the frequencies of HD-associated gene mutations within these populations.

Paradox of meritocracy in surgical selection, and of variation in the attractiveness of individual specialties: to what extent are women still disadvantaged?

BACKGROUND: Evidence from outside surgery suggests that meritocracy-based processes around selection tend to reduce, rather than increase, diversity. In recent years, the surgical training boards have gone to considerable effort to achieve greater transparency and fairness in their selection processes, and to identify those attributes that are believed to best predict future success as a surgeon. This is consistent with the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons Diversity and Inclusion Plan, which places emphasis on gender equity and has goals that include increasing the attractiveness of surgery as a vocation for women, removing impediments to them applying to the surgical training programmes and removing any biases that might disadvantage them during the selection process. METHODS: This study uses the Female Opportunity Index and rate ratio metrics to measure the level of female disadvantage in surgical selection, whether it be by the perception of its attractiveness to women which influences their application rates, or by the likelihood of successful selection for those who have applied, compared with their male counterparts. RESULTS: There are marked differences between the nine surgical specialties and 13 specialty training boards in both the proportion of women who apply, and the proportion who are successful in gaining entry onto the Surgical Education and Training programmes. The Female Opportunity Index ranged from 0.21 to 0.87, which represents a wide variation between surgical specialties. CONCLUSION: These data raise the question as to whether unconscious bias is occurring in an apparently meritocracy-based selection process in some specialties. The data also suggest that some specialties are relatively unattractive to women, for which the reasons are likely to be complex.

Umbilicus and its extensive clinical repertoire.

The umbilicus is involved in a wide range of abnormalities in infants and children. The most severe are evident at birth and include exomphalos (omphalocele) and gastroschisis, both of which can be life-threatening but are easy to diagnose. Exomphalos is often associated with other congenital abnormalities, whereas the associated problems in gastroschisis are largely confined to the gut. Infection of the umbilicus in the neonate presents as omphalitis. The causes of a moist umbilicus following separation of the umbilical stump are multiple, from the relatively minor umbilical granuloma or ectopic bowel mucosa to the more significant patent urachus that leaks urine. Patency of the entire vitello-intestinal (omphalomesenteric) tract allows air and faecal fluid to drain through the umbilicus. The clinical manifestations of persistence of the vitello-intestinal tract vary markedly according to which part remains: clinical presentations include melaena and anaemia, closed-loop bowel obstruction and Meckel diverticulitis. An umbilical hernia occurs when the umbilical cicatrix fails to close. On the other hand, the umbilicus has its uses, which range from being a route for intravenous access in the neonate to being a convenient point of access in laparoscopic surgery.