HDV ribozymes.

The self-cleaving RNA sequences, or ribozymes, in the genomic and antigenomic strands of hepatitis delta virus (HDV) RNA fold into structures that are similar to each other but distinct from those of small ribozymes associated with the RNA replicons that infect plants. HDV ribozymes have provided a tractable system for studying the mechanism of catalytic RNA, and results of biochemical and structural studies on the HDV ribozymes, from a number of labs, have enhanced our understanding and expanded our thinking about the potential for catalytic roles of RNA side chains. The results of these studies are consistent with models suggesting that both an active-site cytosine and a divalent metal ion have catalytic roles in facilitating the cleavage reaction in the HDV ribozymes. Despite recent advances, details about the catalytic mechanism of the HDV ribozyme continue to be debated, and these ribozymes should serve as a good system for further study.

Ribozyme activity in the genomic and antigenomic RNA strands of hepatitis delta virus.

In the hepatitis delta virus, ribozymes are encoded in both the genomic strand RNA and its complement, the antigenomic strand. The two ribozymes are similar in sequence and structure, are most active in the presence of divalent cation and catalyze RNA cleavage reactions which generate a 5'-hydroxyl group and a 2',3'-cyclic phosphate group. Recent progress has been made in understanding the catalytic mechanism. One key was a crystal structure of the genomic ribozyme that revealed a specific cytosine positioned to act as a general acid-base catalyst. The folding of the ribozyme in the context of the longer viral RNA is another area of interest. The biology requires that each ribozyme act only once, and mechanisms proposed for regulation of ribozyme activity sometimes invoke alternative RNA structures. Likewise, interference of ribozyme function by polyadenylation of the antigenomic RNA strand could be controlled through alternative structures, and a model for such control is proposed.

Energetic contribution of non-essential 5' sequence to catalysis in a hepatitis delta virus ribozyme.

Hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozymes employ multiple catalytic strategies to achieve overall rate enhancement of RNA cleavage. These strategies include general acid-base catalysis by a cytosine side chain and involvement of divalent metal ions. Here we used a trans-acting form of the antigenomic ribozyme to examine the contribution of the 5' sequence in the substrate to HDV ribozyme catalysis. The cleavage rate constants increased for substrates with 5' sequence alterations that reduced ground-state binding to the ribozyme. Quantitatively, a plot of activation free energy of chemical conversion versus Gibb's free energy of substrate binding revealed a linear relationship with a slope of -1. This relationship is consistent with a model in which components of the substrate immediately 5' to the cleavage site in the HDV ribozyme-substrate complex destabilize ground-state binding. The intrinsic binding energy derived from the ground-state destabilization could contribute up to 2 kcal/mol toward the total 8.5 kcal/mol reduction in activation free energy for RNA cleavage catalyzed by the HDV ribozyme.

Involvement of a cytosine side chain in proton transfer in the rate-determining step of ribozyme self-cleavage.

Ribozymes of hepatitis delta virus have been proposed to use an active-site cytosine as an acid-base catalyst in the self-cleavage reaction. In this study, we have examined the role of cytosine in more detail with the antigenomic ribozyme. Evidence that proton transfer in the rate-determining step involved cytosine 76 (C76) was obtained from examining cleavage activity of the wild-type and imidazole buffer-rescued C76-deleted (C76 Delta) ribozymes in D(2)O and H(2)O. In both reactions, a similar kinetic isotope effect and shift in the apparent pKa indicate that the buffer is functionally substituting for the side chain in proton transfer. Proton inventory of the wild-type reaction supported a mechanism of a single proton transfer at the transition state. This proton transfer step was further characterized by exogenous base rescue of a C76 Delta mutant with cytosine and imidazole analogues. For the imidazole analogues that rescued activity, the apparent pKa of the rescue reaction, measured under k(cat)/K(M) conditions, correlated with the pKa of the base. From these data a Brønsted coefficient (beta) of 0.51 was determined for the base-rescued reaction of C76 Delta. This value is consistent with that expected for proton transfer in the transition state. Together, these data provide strong support for a mechanism where an RNA side chain participates directly in general acid or general base catalysis of the wild-type ribozyme to facilitate RNA cleavage.

A pH-sensitive RNA tertiary interaction affects self-cleavage activity of the HDV ribozymes in the absence of added divalent metal ion.

Self-cleavage of the genomic and antigenomic ribozymes from hepatitis delta virus (HDV) requires divalent cation for optimal activity. Recently, the HDV genomic ribozyme has been shown to be active in NaCl in the absence of added divalent metal ion at low pH (apparent pKa 5.7). However, we find that the antigenomic ribozyme is 100 to 1000-fold less active under similar conditions. With deletion of a three-nucleotide sequence (C41-A42-A43) unique to the genomic ribozyme, the rate constant for cleavage decreased substantially, while activity of the antigenomic ribozyme was enhanced by introducing a CAA sequence. From the crystal structure, it has been proposed that C41 in this sequence is protonated. To investigate a possible connection between activity at low pH and protonation of C41, mutations were made that were predicted to either eliminate protonation or alter the nature of the tertiary interaction upon protonation. In the absence of added Mg2+, these mutations reduced activity and eliminated the observed pH-rate dependence. Thermal denaturation studies revealed a pH-sensitive structural feature in the genomic ribozyme, while unfolding of the mutant ribozymes was pH-independent. We propose that, in the absence of added Mg2+, protonation of C41 contributes to enhanced activity of the HDV genomic ribozyme at low pH.

Kinetic scheme for intermolecular RNA cleavage by a ribozyme derived from hepatitis delta virus RNA.

A minimal kinetic mechanism for a trans-acting ribozyme derived from the HDV antigenomic RNA self-cleaving element was established from steady-state, pre-steady-state, single-turnover, and binding kinetics. Rate constants for individual steps, including substrate binding and dissociation, cleavage, and product release and binding, were measured at 37 degrees C at pH 8.0 in 10 mM Mg(2+) using oligonucleotides as either substrates, noncleavable analogues or 3' product mimics. A substrate containing a normal 3',5'-linkage was cleaved with a first-order rate constant (k(2)) of 0.91 min(-)(1). The association rate constant for the substrate to the ribozyme (2.1 x 10(7) M(-)(1) min(-)(1)) was at the lower range of the expected value for RNA duplex formation, and the substrate dissociated with a rate constant (1.4 min(-)(1)) slightly faster than that for cleavage. Thus the binary complex was not at equilibrium with free enzyme and substrate prior to the cleavage step. Following cleavage, product release was kinetically ordered in that the 5' product was released rapidly (>12 min(-)(1)) relative to the 3' product (6.0 x 10(-)(3) min(-)(1)). Rapid 5' product release and lack of a demonstrable binding site for the 5' product could contribute to the difficulty in establishing the ribozyme-catalyzed reverse reaction (ligation). Slow release of the 3' product was consistent with the extremely low turnover under steady-state conditions as 3' product dissociation was rate-limiting. The equilibrium dissociation constant for the substrate was 24-fold higher than that of the 3' cleavage product. A substrate with a 2',5'-linkage at the cleavage site was cleaved with a rate constant (k(2)) of 1.1 x 10(-)(2) min(-)(1). Thus, whereas cleavage of a 3',5'-linkage followed a Briggs-Haldane mechanism, 2', 5' cleavage followed a Michaelis-Menten mechanism.

Imidazole rescue of a cytosine mutation in a self-cleaving ribozyme.

Ribozymes use a number of the same catalytic strategies as protein enzymes. However, general base catalysis by a ribozyme has not been demonstrated. In the hepatitis delta virus antigenomic ribozyme, imidazole buffer rescued activity of a mutant with a cytosine-76 (C76) to uracil substitution. In addition, a C76 to adenine substitution reduced the apparent pKa (where Ka is the acid constant) of the self-cleavage reaction by an amount consistent with differences in the pKa values of these two side chains. These results suggest that, in the wild-type ribozyme, C76 acts as a general base. This finding has implications for potential catalytic functions of conserved cytosines and adenines in other ribozymes and in ribonuclear proteins with enzymatic activity.

Ribozyme cleavage of a 2,5-phosphodiester linkage: mechanism and a restricted divalent metal-ion requirement.

The natural substrate cleaved by the hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozyme contains a 3',5'-phosphodiester linkage at the cleavage site; however, a 2',5'-linked ribose-phosphate backbone can also be cleaved by both trans-acting and self-cleaving forms of the HDV ribozyme. With substrates containing either linkage, the HDV ribozyme generated 2',3'-cyclic phosphate and 5'-hydroxyl groups suggesting that the mechanisms of cleavage in both cases were by a nucleophilic attack on the phosphorus center by the adjacent hydroxyl group. Divalent metal ion was required for cleavage of either linkage. However, although the 3',5'-linkage was cleaved slightly faster in Ca2+ than in Mg2+, the 2',5'-linkage was cleaved in Mg2+ (or Mn2+) but not Ca2+. This dramatic difference in metal-ion specificity is strongly suggestive of a crucial metal-ion interaction at the active site. In contrast to the HDV ribozymes, cleavage at a 2',5'-phosphodiester bond was not efficiently catalyzed by the hammerhead ribozyme. The relaxed linkage specificity of the HDV ribozymes may be due in part to lack of a rigid binding site for sequences 5' to the cleavage site.

A nested double pseudoknot is required for self-cleavage activity of both the genomic and antigenomic hepatitis delta virus ribozymes.

The crystal structure of a genomic hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozyme 3' cleavage product predicts the existence of a 2 bp duplex, P1.1, that had not been previously identified in the HDV ribozymes. P1.1 consists of two canonical C-G base pairs stacked beneath the G.U wobble pair at the cleavage site and would appear to pull together critical structural elements of the ribozyme. P1.1 is the second stem of a second pseudoknot in the ribozyme, making the overall fold of the ribozyme a nested double pseudoknot. Sequence comparison suggests the potential for P1.1 and a similar fold in the antigenomic ribozyme. In this study, the base pairing requirements of P1.1 for cleavage activity were tested in both the genomic and antigenomic HDV ribozymes by mutagenesis. In both sequences, cleavage activity was severely reduced when mismatches were introduced into P1.1, but restored when alternative base pairing combinations were incorporated. Thus, P1.1 is an essential structural element required for cleavage of both the genomic and antigenomic HDV ribozymes and the model for the antigenomic ribozyme secondary structure should also be modified to include P1.1.

A conserved bulged adenosine in a peripheral duplex of the antigenomic HDV self-cleaving RNA reduceskinetic trapping of inactive conformations.

In the ribozyme of hepatitis delta virus antigenomic RNA, two short duplexes, P2 and P2a, stabilize the active self-cleaving structure. However, P2a also promotes kinetic trapping of non-native structures. A bulged adenosine (A14) separates P2a and P2; this bulged A is conserved in clinical isolates of HDV but is unlikely to be physically close to the cleavage site phosphate in the ribozyme structure. Removing the bulge did not significantly slow the rate of cleavage but slowed the conversion of inactive to active conformations. In the absence of the bulged A, inactive conformations required higher urea concentrations or higher temperatures to be activated. Thus, the bulged-nucleotide in the P2-P2a duplex did not provide an essential kink or hinge between P2 and P2a that was required for cleavage activity but, rather, increased the rate of refolding from an inactive to an active ribozyme structure. These data also suggest a model in which P2 and P2a form a coaxial stacked helix of 9 bp, the most likely arrangement being one in which P2-P2a is roughly parallel to P1.

A toggle duplex in hepatitis delta virus self-cleaving RNA that stabilizes an inactive and a salt-dependent pro-active ribozyme conformation.

The antigenomic RNA of hepatitis delta virus (HDV) can form a short duplex, P2a, in which a four-nucleotide sequence within the self-cleaving domain pairs with a sequence just outside the previously defined 3'-boundary of the ribozyme. Both sequences that would participate in forming P2a were previously determined to be non-essential for self-cleavage activity. Ribozymes able to form P2a were less active than those lacking the 3' P2a sequence when preincubated under the standard low-Na+ conditions. Chemical probing of the RNA correlated base-pairing in P2a with this inhibition. Furthermore, mutagenesis and 3' truncation experiments mapped the inhibitory sequence to P2a. However, raising the NaCl concentration in the preincubation prior to adding Mg2+ reversed the inhibitory effect. Moreover, with NaCl preincubation, the P2a-containing ribozyme was more active than an otherwise identical ribozyme lacking the 3' P2a sequence. Non-denaturing gels provided evidence for alternative conformations of the P2a-containing precursor with only the faster-migrating species correlating with the active form. A difference in the temperature-dependence for the rate of cleavage of the P2a-containing ribozyme with and without NaCl, together with a difference in the melting behavior of the RNA in NaCl with and without P2a, suggested that P2a favors the native structure in NaCl. Many derivatives of the HDV ribozymes form inactive conformers; however, this study reveals details of a specific structure that stabilizes both inactive and active conformations of the HDV ribozyme.

Core-associated non-duplex sequences distinguishing the genomic and antigenomic self-cleaving RNAs of hepatitis delta virus.

The two ribozymes found in hepatitis delta virus RNA form related but non-identical secondary structures and display similar cleavage properties in vitro. Three of the non-duplex elements hypothesized to contribute nucleotides to the catalytic core vary slightly in length between the two ribozymes and the differences are conserved in clinical isolates. Possible functional relationships of the core sequence elements were tested by systematically exchanging sequences between the two ribozymes. It was found that switching two of the elements (L3 and J4/2) from one ribozyme to the other reduced cleavage activity in both. On the other hand, exchanging the third region (J1/4) resulted in enhanced activity for one ribozyme and a smaller increase in activity for the other. Combining exchanges did not reveal any compensatory interactions involving these particular elements nor did a pattern emerge that would suggest an optimal combination of core sequences for a generalized HDV ribozyme. Non-compensatory behavior reinforces the idea that the non-duplex sequences may form sequence-specific contacts with duplex portions of the ribozyme, but, in addition, these data suggest that there may be selective pressures on the ribozyme sequences in the virus that are not reflected in the in vitro self-cleavage assays.

Self-cleaving ribozymes of hepatitis delta virus RNA.

Hepatitis delta virus (HDV) is a small single-stranded RNA satellite of hepatitis B virus. Although it is a human pathogen, it shares a number of features with a subset of the small plant satellite RNA viruses, including self-cleaving sequences in the genomic and antigenomic sequences of the viral RNA. The self-cleaving sequence is critical to viral replication and is thought to function as a ribozyme in vivo to process the products of rolling-circle replication to unit-length molecules. A divalent cation is required for cleavage and while a structural role is implicated for metal ions, a more direct role for a metal ion in catalysis has not yet been proven. A minimal natural ribozyme sequence with proficient in vitro self-cleavage activity is about 85 nucleotides long and adopts a secondary structure with four paired regions (P1-P4). The two pairings that define the 5' and 3' boundaries of the ribozyme, P1 and P2, form an atypical pseudoknot arrangement. This secondary structure places a number of constraints on the possible tertiary folding of the sequence, which together with chemical probing, photo-cross-linking, mutagenesis and computer-assisted modeling provides clues to the three-dimensional structure. The data are consistent with a model in which the cleavage site, located at the 5' end of P1, is in close proximity to three single-stranded regions, consisting of a hairpin loop at the end of P3 and two sequences joining P1 to P4 and P4 to P2. While the natural forms of the HDV ribozymes appear to be prone to misfolding, biochemical and mutagenesis studies from a number of laboratories has allowed the production of trans-acting ribozymes and smaller more active cis-acting ribozymes, both of which will aid in further mechanistic and structural studies of this RNA.

Circular ribozymes generated in Escherichia coli using group I self-splicing permuted intron-exon sequences.

A circularly permuted self-splicing group I intron from Anabaena was used to generate covalently closed circular trans-acting ribozymes in Escherichia coli. The RNA component of Bacillus subtilis RNaseP and an artificial trans-acting hepatitis delta virus ribozyme were expressed as the exon portion of the permuted intron. RNA isolated from these cells contained circular forms of the ribozymes, indicating that circles were generated from precursors expressed in these cells. Total RNA isolated from cells producing the circular RNA contained ribozyme activity. In contrast, a linear form of the delta virus ribozyme expressed as part of an unprocessed transcript yielded no detectable activity. These data extend previous in vitro and in vivo studies on splicing-mediated RNA circularization by demonstrating the intracellular production of circular ribozymes. These results have implications for the development of systems expressing therapeutic forms of small RNAs such as ribozymes and decoy-type competitors. Circular RNAs generated by splicing are devoid of flanking sequences that could potentially interfere with function. Also, because circular RNAs are not primary substrates for exonucleases, they may have increased in vivo half-lives relative to linear molecules with similar sequences.

A small circular TAR RNA decoy specifically inhibits Tat-activated HIV-1 transcription.

Linear TAR RNA has previously been used as a decoy to inhibit HIV-1 transcription in vitro and HIV-1 replication in vivo. A 48 nucleotide circular RNA containing the stem, bulge and loop of the HIV-1 TAR element was synthesized using the self-splicing activity of a group I permuted intron-exon and was tested for its ability to function as a TAR decoy in vitro. This small circular TAR molecule was exceptionally stable in HeLa nuclear extracts, whereas a similar linear TAR molecule was rapidly degraded. The TAR circle bound specifically to Tfr38, a peptide containing the TAR-binding region of Tat. The ability of Tat to trans-activate transcription from the HIV-1 promoter in vitro was efficiently inhibited by circular TAR RNA but not by TAR circles that contained either bulge or loop mutations. TAR circles did not inhibit transactivation exclusively by binding to Tat since this inhibition was not reversed by adding excess Tat to the transcription reaction. Together, these data suggest that TAR circles act as decoys that inhibit transactivation by binding to Tat and at least one cellular factor. These data also demonstrate the utility of small circular RNA molecules as tools for biochemical studies.

Hepatitis delta virus ribozymes fold to generate a solvent-inaccessible core with essential nucleotides near the cleavage site phosphate.

Self-cleaving sequences or ribozymes from the hepatitis delta virus (HDV) genomic RNA and its complement form similar secondary structures that suggest a core region and potential active site composed of "single-stranded" sequences. However, there is little data on tertiary interactions in these ribozymes, therefore structural features were investigated using cross-linking and hydroxyl radical cleavage. Cross-links in cis and trans forms of the antigenomic RNA were generated using the photoactivatable azidophenacyl group tethered to the cleavage site phosphate. Specific cross-links formed to J4/2, and to the 3' sides of P3 and L3. Different sites were cross-linked in low salt or monovalent cations versus divalent cations, suggesting a metal ion-dependent conformational change near the cleavage site. The solvent-inaccessible regions of both the genomic and antigenomic ribozymes were revealed by cleavage in Fe(II)-EDTA. In Mg2+, backbone segments most strongly protected from solvent-based hydroxyl radicals were mapped to J4/2 and parts of L3. Similar patterns of protection were seen in trans-acting ribozymes bound to a product oligonucleotide. These data provide evidence for a common tertiary structure for the HDV ribozymes. They would be consistent with a model in which the end of P1, including the cleavage site phosphate and the nucleotide 5' to the cleavage site, is positioned in an active site pocket or cleft formed by the three single-stranded regions, L3, J4/2, and J1/4.

Exon circularization in mammalian nuclear extracts.

Correct ligation of exons in pre-mRNA splicing requires splice site juxtaposition (splice site pairing), usually involving a 5' splice site and a downstream 3' splice site. Splicing of a 5' splice site to an upstream 3' splice site, however, is predicted to result in a circular RNA. This mode of splice site pairing across the axon has been hypothesized to account for rare RNAs containing scrambled exons (Nigro JM et al., 1991, Celt 64:607-613; Cocquerelle C et al., 1992, EMBO J 11:1 095-1098). Additionally, this mode of splice site pairing has been postulated to explain the formation of SRY circular transcripts in mouse testis (Capel B et al., 1993, Celt 73:1019- 1030). Here we show that splice site pairing across the exon can result in exon circularization in vitro. These results indicate that spliceosome-mediated axon circularization indeed can account for the formation of scrambled exons and circular RNAs. Exon circularization efficiency decreased dramatically as the length of the exon was increased from 95 nt to 274 nt. Circularization of this longer exon was restored, however, when intronic complementary sequences were included in the RNA substrate. These complementary sequences could form a stem that served to bring the splice sites into proximity and thereby promote splice site pairing. Therefore, the splicing of this structured RNA recapitulated SRY-like exon circularization in vitro.

Core sequences and a cleavage site wobble pair required for HDV antigenomic ribozyme self-cleavage.

The secondary structures proposed for the cis-acting hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozymes contain four duplex regions, three sequences joining the duplexes and two hairpin loops. The core and active site of the ribozyme could be formed by portions of the joining sequences, J1/4 and J4/2, together with one of the hairpin loops, L3. To establish the core region and define essential bases within this putative active site 28 single base changes at 15 positions were made and tested for effects on ribozyme cleavage. At 14 of the 15 positions all of the changes resulted in detectable decreased rates of cleavage. At seven of the positions one or more of the changes resulted in a 500-fold or greater decrease in the observed rate constant for cleavage. Mutations that resulted in 10(3)-fold effects were found in all three regions hypothesized to form the core. At the cleavage site substitutions of the cytosine 5' of the site of cleavage did not provide strong support for a sequence-specific interaction involving this nucleotide. In contrast, an A-C combination was the most effective substitution for a potential G-U pair 3' of the cleavage site, suggesting a requirement for a wobble pair at that position.

Circularizing ribozymes and decoy-competitors by autocatalytic splicing in vitro and in vivo.

An Anabaena group I intron was circularly permuted at loop 5, loop 6 and loop 8, and tested for self-splicing activity. Precursor RNAs from these constructs spliced efficiently and produced circular exons in vitro. Using group I permuted-intron-exon sequences, circular forms of the HDV ribozyme, the RNA component of RNaseP from B. subtilis, the HIV TAR and a short HIV Rev-binding element were generated and tested for activity and stability. The activity of circular ribozymes is comparable to the linear counterparts with similar core sequences. Circular forms of the TAR and Rev-binding element showed specific binding to Tfr-38 and Rev(35-50) peptide, respectively. To explore the potential for using this methodology to express circular RNA in vivo, circular forms of the HDV ribozyme and RNaseP RNA were produced in E. coli. Analysis of total RNA indicated that the precursor RNA spliced efficiently and accurately to produce circular ribozymes. The activity of in vivo expressed circular ribozymes could be demonstrated indicating that they fold into active conformation. These results suggest that self-splicing group I PIE sequences could prove useful for expressing small stable circular ribozyme/decoy-competitor or antisense RNAs in cells.

Optimal self-cleavage activity of the hepatitis delta virus RNA is dependent on a homopurine base pair in the ribozyme core.

A non-Watson-Crick G.G interaction within the core region of the hepatitis delta virus (HDV) antigenomic ribozyme is required for optimal rates of self-cleavage activity. Base substitutions for either one or both G's revealed that full activity was obtained only when both G's were replaced with A's. At those positions, substitutions that generate potential Watson-Crick, G.U, heteropurine, or homopyrimidine combinations resulted in dramatically lower cleavage activity. A homopurine symmetric base pair, of the same type identified in the high-affinity binding site of the HIV RRE, is most consistent with this data. Additional features shared between the antigenomic ribozyme and the Rev binding site in the vicinity of the homopurine pairs suggest some structural similarity for this region of the two RNAs and a possible motif associated with this homopurine interaction. Evidence for a homopurine pair at the equivalent position in a modified form of the HDV genomic ribozyme was also found. With the postulated symmetric pairing scheme, large distortions in the nucleotide conformation, the sugar-phosphate backbone, or both would be necessary to accommodate this interaction at the end of a helix; we hypothesize that this distortion is critical to the structure of the active site of the ribozyme and it is stabilized by the homopurine base pair.