ABSTRACT
Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) is the most comprehensive means of medically treating obesity, but only few data have so far been published concerning its long-term effectiveness. We here report our experience of 1068 consecutive patients (868 females) treated with CBT at a university-based obesity centre. The patients were enrolled into three different programmes: a 14-week LEARN programme (672 patients), a 16-week MOB programme for the morbidly obese (259 patients), or a 20-week BINGE programme for subjects affected by binge eating (137 patients). Eighty-five percent of the subjects completed the weekly programmes. The percentage of patients attending the scheduled control visits during the 1-year follow-up gradually decreased, being very low in the BINGE group (10%). The percentage weight loss was an average of 6% during the weekly courses, being higher in the MOB programme; by the end of the weekly sessions, it exceeded 10% of initial body weight in 22% of cases and increased to 36% during the follow-up. The cumulative probability of follow-up was higher among the patients undergoing the MOB and LEARN programmes than among the BINGE patients (p < 0.0001), and decreased with the increasing severity of obesity. Female gender and a weight loss of > 10% i.b.w. increased compliance to follow-up. The study further demonstrates the difficulty of achieving compliance to chronic management of obesity and the critical role of binge eating disorder in the medium-term treatment of obesity. Strategies are needed to improve adherence to a follow-up protocol.
Subject(s)
Bulimia/therapy , Cognitive Behavioral Therapy/methods , Obesity, Morbid/therapy , Obesity/therapy , Adaptation, Psychological , Adult , Analysis of Variance , Body Mass Index , Bulimia/psychology , Cognitive Behavioral Therapy/standards , Female , Follow-Up Studies , Humans , Male , Middle Aged , Motivation , Obesity/psychology , Obesity, Morbid/psychology , Patient Care Team , Patient Compliance/psychology , Patient Education as Topic , Problem Solving , Program Evaluation , Proportional Hazards Models , Severity of Illness Index , Treatment Outcome , Weight LossABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: To measure the effects of cognitive-behavioural therapy on health-related quality of life (HRQL) in obese patients, in relation to binge eating disorder. DESIGN: Longitudinal, clinical intervention study consisting of structured sessions of cognitive-behavioural therapy, preceded by sessions chaired by a psychologist in subjects with binge eating. SUBJECTS: Two groups of obese patients (92 treated by cognitive-behavioural therapy (77 females); 76 untreated controls (67 female), selected from the waiting list (control group)). Of 92 treated patients, 46 had a binge eating disorder at psychometric testing and structured clinical interview. MEASUREMENTS: Health-related quality of life by means of Short-Form 36 questionnaire at baseline and after 3-5 months. RESULTS: Cognitive-behavioural treatment produced an average weight loss of 9.4+/-7.5 kg, corresponding to a BMI reduction of 3.48+/-2.70 kg/m(2). No changes were observed in the control group. All scales of HRQL improved in treated subjects (by 5-19%). In obese subjects with binge eating weight loss was lower in comparison to non-bingers (7.7+/-8.1 vs 11.1+/-6.6; P=0.034). However, the improvement in HRQL was on average larger, and significantly so for Role Limitation-Physical (P=0.006), Role Limitation-Emotional (P=0.002), Vitality (P=0.003), Mental Health (P=0.032) and Social Functioning (P=0.034). Bodily Pain was the sole scale whose changes paralleled changes in body weight. CONCLUSIONS: The positive effects of cognitive-behavioural therapy, mainly in subjects with binge eating, largely outweigh the effects on body weight, resulting in a significant change in self-perceived health status.
Subject(s)
Bulimia/psychology , Cognitive Behavioral Therapy/statistics & numerical data , Health , Obesity/psychology , Quality of Life/psychology , Adolescent , Adult , Aged , Analysis of Variance , Cohort Studies , Female , Humans , Longitudinal Studies , Male , Middle Aged , Prospective Studies , Surveys and QuestionnairesABSTRACT
We evaluated the effect of a 500-ml intragastric balloon (Ballobes) on some aspects of eating-related behaviour and weight loss on nine massively obese patients. An 800-kcal mixed meal test was performed some days before, 2-3 days and 2 months after the implant of the balloon. A hypocaloric program was started after the second meal test. At hourly intervals, before and after the meal, patients were asked to rate the desire to eat, hunger, satiety and prospective consumption of food. After 2 months, weight loss was 12.0 +/- 5.1 kg. A significant decrease in the balloon diameters was observed, but none completely deflated. During the meal test performed 2-3 days after the implant, subjects rated themselves as significantly less hungry, fuller and desiring to eat less food. These patterns, however, returned to the baseline levels at the meal test performed after 2 months. No relationship was found between weight loss and reduction in the balloon diameters, nor between the latter and the changes in temporal profiles of eating ratings. The effect of a 500-ml balloon on meal-related hunger and satiety therefore seems to disappear with time.
