Hydrophobic core malleability of a de novo designed three-helix bundle protein.

De novo protein design provides a tool for testing the principles that stabilize the structures of proteins. Recently, we described the design and structure determination of alpha(3)D, a three-helix bundle protein with a well-packed hydrophobic core. Here, we test the malleability and adaptability of this protein's structure by mutating a small, Ala residue (A60) in its core to larger, hydrophobic side-chains, Leu and Ile. Such changes introduce strain into the structures of natural proteins, and therefore generally destabilize the native state. By contrast, these mutations were slightly stabilizing ( approximately 1.5 kcal mol(-1)) to the tertiary structure of alpha(3)D. The value of DeltaC(p) for unfolding of these mutants was not greatly affected relative to wild-type, indicating that the change in solvent accessibility for unfolding was similar. However, two-dimensional heteronuclear single quantum coherence spectra indicate that the protein adjusts to the introduction of steric bulk in different ways. A60L-alpha(3)D showed serious erosion in the dispersion of both the amide backbone as well as the side-chain methyl chemical shifts. By contrast, A60I-alpha(3)D showed excellent dispersion of the backbone resonances, and selective changes in dispersion of the aliphatic side-chains proximal to the site of mutation. Together, these data suggest that alpha(3)D, although folded into a unique three-dimensional structure, is nevertheless more malleable and flexible than most natural, native proteins.

NMR studies of the anti-apoptotic protein Bcl-xL in micelles.

The Bcl-2 family of proteins play a pivotal role in the regulation of programmed cell death. One of the postulated mechanisms for the function of these proteins involves the formation of ion channels in membranes. As a first step to structurally characterize these proteins in a membrane environment, we investigated the structure of a Bcl-x(L) mutant protein when incorporated into small detergent micelles. This form of Bcl-x(L) lacks the loop (residues 49-88) between helix 1 and helix 2 and the putative C-terminal transmembrane helix (residues 214-237). Below the critical micelle concentration (CMC), Bcl-x(L) binds detergents in the hydrophobic groove that binds to pro-apoptotic proteins. However, above the CMC, Bcl-x(L) undergoes a dramatic conformational change. Using NMR methods, we characterized the secondary structure of Bcl-x(L) in the micelle-bound form. Like Bcl-x(L) in aqueous solution, the structure of the protein when dissolved in dodecylphosphocholine (DPC) micelles consists of several alpha-helices separated by loops. However, the length and position of the individual helices of Bcl-x(L) in micelles differ from those in aqueous solution. The location of Bcl-x(L) within the micelle was examined from the analysis of protein-detergent NOEs and limited proteolysis. In addition, the mobility of the micelle-bound form of Bcl-x(L) was investigated from NMR relaxation measurements. On the basis of these studies, a model is proposed for the structure, dynamics, and location of Bcl-x(L) in micelles. In this model, Bcl-x(L) has a loosely packed, dynamic structure in micelles, with helices 1 and 6 and possibly helix 5 partially buried in the hydrophobic interior of the micelle. Other parts of the protein are located near the surface or on the outside of the micelle.

Structural basis for binding of Smac/DIABLO to the XIAP BIR3 domain.

The inhibitor-of-apoptosis proteins (IAPs) regulate programmed cell death by inhibiting members of the caspase family of enzymes. Recently, a mammalian protein called Smac (also named DIABLO) was identified that binds to the IAPs and promotes caspase activation. Although undefined in the X-ray structure, the amino-terminal residues of Smac are critical for its function. To understand the structural basis for molecular recognition between Smac and the IAPs, we determined the solution structure of the BIR3 domain of X-linked IAP (XIAP) complexed with a functionally active nine-residue peptide derived from the N terminus of Smac. The peptide binds across the third beta-strand of the BIR3 domain in an extended conformation with only the first four residues contacting the protein. The complex is stabilized by four intermolecular hydrogen bonds, an electrostatic interaction involving the N terminus of the peptide, and several hydrophobic interactions. This structural information, along with the binding data from BIR3 and Smac peptide mutants reported here, should aid in the design of small molecules that may be used for the treatment of cancers that overexpress IAPs.

Solution structure of the cytohesin-1 (B2-1) Sec7 domain and its interaction with the GTPase ADP ribosylation factor 1.

Cytohesin-1 (B2-1) is a guanine nucleotide exchange factor for human ADP ribosylation factor (Arf) GTPases, which are important for vesicular protein trafficking and coatamer assembly in the cell. Cytohesin-1 also has been reported to promote cellular adhesion via binding to the beta2 integrin cytoplasmic domain. The solution structure of the Sec7 domain of cytohesin-1, which is responsible for both the protein's guanine nucleotide exchange factor function and beta2 integrin binding, was determined by NMR spectroscopy. The structure consists of 10 alpha-helices that form a unique tertiary fold. The binding between the Sec7 domain and a soluble, truncated version of human Arf-1 was investigated by examining 1H-15N and 1H-13C chemical shift changes between the native protein and the Sec7/Arf-1 complex. We show that the binding to Arf-1 occurs through a large surface on the C-terminal subdomain that is composed of both hydrophobic and polar residues. Structure-based mutational analysis of the cytohesin-1 Sec7 domain has been used to identify residues important for binding to Arf and for mediating nucleotide exchange. Investigations into the interaction between the Sec7 domain and the beta2 integrin cytoplasmic domain suggest that the two proteins do not interact in the solution phase.

De novo design of native proteins: characterization of proteins intended to fold into antiparallel, rop-like, four-helix bundles.

The de novo design and characterization of a series of 51-residue helix-turn-helix peptides intended to dimerize into antiparallel four-stranded coiled coils is described. The sequence is based on a coiled coil heptad repeat Ncap-(Aa Zb Zc Ld Ze Zf Zg)3-turn- (Xa Zb Zc Ld Ze Zf Zg)3-Ccap-CONH2, where X is either Val or Ala. The overall topology was intended to be similar to that found in the Escherichia coli protein ROP. The design strategy included consideration of geometric complementarity of the packing of side chains within the hydrophobic core as well as the use of specific interfacial interactions, both of which were intended to favor the desired ROP-like topology. Additionally, the sequence was designed to destabilize potential alternative structures that might compete with the desired topology. The peptides (RLP-1, RLP-2, and RLP-3) assemble into stable alpha-helical dimers and exhibit the hallmarks of a native protein as judged by its spectroscopic properties, and the lack of binding to hydrophobic dyes. Also, the enthalpy and heat capacity changes upon denaturation were determined by measuring the temperature dependence of the CD spectra and confirmed by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). The values determined by the two methods are in excellent agreement and are in the range of those of naturally occurring proteins of this size. These results suggest that it is now possible to design native-like helical proteins that should serve as templates for the further design of functional proteins.

Expression of de novo designed alpha-helical bundles.

The successful design of proteins requires careful consideration of the multiplicity of forces that stabilize their three-dimensional structures including hydrophobic interactions, hydrogen-bonding, electrostatics and weakly polar interactions. Early attempts to design proteins relied too heavily on hydrophobic interactions to provide stability, resulting in structures with dynamic properties. Addition of more specific interactions to these initial designs gives rise to proteins with more native-like properties. This manuscript describes the design of native-like three- and four-helix bundles, and their cloning and expression of these proteins.

Unusual effects of an engineered disulfide on global and local protein stability.

The global and local stabilities of a eukaryotic ferricytochrome c variant with an engineered disulfide are examined. The disulfide connects position 20, which is usually a valine, to position 102, which is usually a threonine. The cross-linked variant is approximately 1.2 kcal mol-1 less stable than the wild-type protein at 298 K, pH 4.6, in H2O and D2O. Circular dichroism studies show that the decreased stability results from structure-induced stabilization of the denatured state [Betz, S. F., & Pielak, G. J. (1992) Biochemistry 31, 12337-12344]. Here, we use proton chemical shift, paramagnetic shift, and amide proton exchange data to obtain atomic level structural and energetic information. Chemical and paramagnetic shift data indicate only minor native state structural changes. Local stability is obtained from amide proton-deuterium exchange data, using model peptide intrinsic exchange rates. As expected, the exchange data indicate that cross-link incorporation decreases the majority of local stabilities. Near the cross-link, however, local stability seems to increase despite the overall global stability decrease. Furthermore, local stability changes for hydrophobic core residues seem to be greater than the global stability change. We interpret these observations as cross-link-induced changes in exchange competent states and relate them to changes in the denatured state.

Controlling topology and native-like behavior of de novo-designed peptides: design and characterization of antiparallel four-stranded coiled coils.

The de novo design of peptides and proteins has emerged as an attractive approach for investigating protein structure and function. Here, the design, synthesis, and characterization of a new series of alpha-helical peptides intended to form antiparallel four-stranded coiled coils is described. Computer models were generated without the use of extant protein structures and were used to refine the sequence. The peptides are of the general formula Ncap-(XaZbZcLdZeZfZg)3-Ccap, where X is either Ala, Val, Thr, or Leu, and Ncap and Ccap are sequences designed to satisfy the helices unpaired amide nitrogens and carbonyl oxygens, respectively. The hydrophobic residues (at positions a and d) were chosen so that geometric packing of large and small hydrophobes would favor an antiparallel arrangement. Special attention was also given to residues at the helix--helix interfaces. These residues were chosen to balance potential attractive and repulsive electrostatic forces so that the desired topology was favored while other possible folds were destabilized. Two of the four peptides associate under neutral conditions into the desired tetramers. One of the complexes (a = Val) behaves like a native-like protein as judged by NMR, thermodynamics, and apolar dye (ANS) binding. The other tetrameric complex (a = Leu) exhibits broader NMR resonances, diminished values of delta H and delta Cp, and tight binding of the hydrophobic dye ANS, similar to early designed proteins. These results reinforce the importance of optimizing van der Waals packing interactions in protein design but demonstrate that hydrophobic packing must be balanced with hydrogen-bonding and electrostatic interactions to produce novel native-like proteins.

Crystallization of a designed peptide from a molten globule ensemble.

BACKGROUND: The design of amino acid sequences that adopt a desired three-dimensional fold has been of keen interest over the past decade. However, the design of proteins that adopt unique conformations is still a considerable problem. Until very recently, all of the designed proteins that have been extensively characterized possess the hallmarks of the molten globular state. Molten globular intermediates have been observed in both equilibrium and kinetic protein folding/stability studies, and understanding the forces that determine compact non-native states is critical for a comprehensive understanding of proteins. This paper describes the solution and early solid state characterization of peptides that form molten globular ensembles. RESULTS & CONCLUSIONS: Crystals diffracting to 3.5 A resolution have been grown of a 16-residue peptide (alpha 1A) designed to form a tetramer of alpha-helices. In addition, a closely related peptide, alpha 1, has previously been shown to yield crystals that diffract to 1.2 A resolution. The solution properties of these two peptides were examined to determine whether their well defined crystalline conformations were retained in solution. On the basis of an examination of their NMR spectra, sedimentation equilibria, thermal unfolding, and ANS binding, it is concluded that the peptides form alpha-helical aggregates with properties similar to those of the molten globule state. Thus, for these peptides, the process of crystallization bears many similarities to models of protein folding. Upon dissolution, the peptides rapidly assume compact molten globular states similar to the molten globule like intermediates that are formed at short times after refolding is initiated. Following a rate-determining nucleation step, the peptides crystallize into a single or a small number of conformations in a process that mimics the formation of native structure in proteins.

Protein design: a hierarchic approach.

The de novo design of peptides and proteins has recently emerged as an approach for investigating protein structure and function. Designed, helical peptides provide model systems for dissecting and quantifying the multiple interactions that stabilize secondary structure formation. De novo design is also useful for exploring the features that specify the stoichiometry and stability of alpha-helical coiled coils and for defining the requirements for folding into structures that resemble native, functional proteins. The design process often occurs in a series of discrete steps. Such steps reflect the hierarchy of forces required for stabilizing tertiary structures, beginning with hydrophobic forces and adding more specific interactions as required to achieve a unique, functional protein.

Native-like and structurally characterized designed alpha-helical bundles.

A number of coiled coils and alpha-helical bundles have recently been designed, and many have now been structurally characterized by X-ray crystallography. Others have not been as well characterized structurally but exhibit native-like properties in aqueous solution. Both areas of investigation have contributed greatly to our understanding of the nature of specificity in this class of molecules.

Protein thermal denaturation, side-chain models, and evolution: amino acid substitutions at a conserved helix-helix interface.

Random mutant libraries with substitutions at the interface between the N- and C-terminal helices of Saccharomyces cerevisiae iso-1-cytochrome c were screened. All residue combinations that have been identified in naturally occurring cytochrome c sequences are found in the libraries. Mutants with these combinations are biologically functional. Enthalpies, heat capacities, and midpoint temperatures of denaturation are used to determine the entropy and Gibbs free energy of denaturation (delta GD) for the ferri form of the wild-type protein and 13 interface variants. Changes in delta GD cannot be allocated solely to enthalpic or entropic effects, but there is no evidence of enthalpy-entropy compensation. The lack of additivity of delta GD values for single versus multiple amino acid substitutions indicates that the helices interact thermodynamically. Changes in delta GD are not in accord with helix propensities, indicating that interactions between the helices and the rest of the protein outweigh helix propensity. Comparison of delta GD values for the interface variants and nearly 90 non-cytochrome c variants to side-chain model data leads to several conclusions. First, hydrocarbon side chains react to burial-like transfer from water to cyclohexane, but even weakly polar side chains respond differently. Second, despite octanol being a poor model for protein interiors, octanol-to-water transfer free energies are useful stability predictors for changing large hydrocarbon side chains to smaller ones. Third, unlike cyclohexane and octanol, the Dayhoff mutation matrix predicts stability changes for a variety of substitutions, even at interacting sites.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Probing weakly polar interactions in cytochrome c.

Theoretical, statistical, and model studies suggest that proteins are stabilized by weakly polar attractions between sulfur atoms and properly oriented aromatic rings. The two sulfur-containing amino acids, methionine and cysteine, occur frequently among functional alleles in random mutant libraries of Saccharomyces cerevisiae iso-1-cytochrome c genes at positions that form a weakly polar aromatic-aromatic interaction, the wild-type protein. To determine if a weakly polar sulfur-aromatic interaction replaced the aromatic-aromatic interaction, the structure and stability of two variants were examined. Phenylalanine 10, which interacts with tyrosine 97, was replaced by methionine and cysteine. The cysteine was modified to form the methionine and cysteine analog, S-methyl cysteine (CysSMe). Proton NMR studies indicate that changing Phe 10 to Met or CysSMe affects only local structure and that the structures of sulfur-containing variants are nearly identical. Analysis of chemical shifts and nuclear Overhauser effect data indicates that both sulfur-containing side chains are in position to form a weakly polar interaction with Tyr 97. The F10M and F10CSMe variants are 2-3 kcal mol-1 less stable than iso-1-cytochrome c at 300 K. Comparison of the stabilities of the F10M and F10CSMe variants allows evaluation of the potential weakly polar interaction between the additional sulfur atom of F10CSMe and the aromatic moiety of Tyr 97. The F10CSMe;C102T variant is 0.7 +/- 0.3 kcal mol-1 more stable than the F10M;C102T protein. The increased stability is explained by the difference in hydrophobicity of the sulfur-containing side chains. We conclude that any weakly polar interaction between the additional sulfur and the aromatic ring is too weak to detect or is masked by destabilizing contributions to the free energy of denaturation.

Amide proton exchange rates of oxidized and reduced Saccharomyces cerevisiae iso-1-cytochrome c.

Proton NMR spectroscopy was used to determine the rate constant, kobs, for exchange of labile protons in both oxidized (Fe(III)) and reduced (Fe(II)) iso-1-cytochrome c. We find that slowly exchanging backbone amide protons tend to lack solvent-accessible surface area, possess backbone hydrogen bonds, and are present in regions of regular secondary structure as well as in omega-loops. Furthermore, there is no correlation between kobs and the distance from a backbone amide nitrogen to the nearest solvent-accessible atom. These observations are consistent with the local unfolding model. Comparisons of the free energy change for denaturation, delta Gd, at 298 K to the free energy change for local unfolding, delta Gop, at 298 K for the oxidized protein suggest that certain conformations possessing higher free energy than the denatured state are detected at equilibrium. Reduction of the protein results in a general increase in delta Gop. Comparisons of delta Gd to delta Gop for the reduced protein show that the most open states of the reduced protein possess more structure than its chemically denatured form. This persistent structure in high-energy conformations of the reduced form appears to involve the axially coordinated heme.

Disulfide bonds and the stability of globular proteins.

An understanding of the forces that contribute to stability is pivotal in solving the protein-folding problem. Classical theory suggests that disulfide bonds stabilize proteins by reducing the entropy of the denatured state. More recent theories have attempted to expand this idea, suggesting that in addition to configurational entropic effects, enthalpic and native-state effects occur and cannot be neglected. Experimental thermodynamic evidence is examined from two sources: (1) the disruption of naturally occurring disulfides, and (2) the insertion of novel disulfides. The data confirm that enthalpic and native-state effects are often significant. The experimental changes in free energy are compared to those predicted by different theories. The differences between theory and experiment are large near 300 K and do not lend support to any of the current theories regarding the stabilization of proteins by disulfide bonds. This observation is a result of not only deficiencies in the theoretical models but also from difficulties in determining the effects of disulfide bonds on protein stability against the backdrop of numerous subtle stabilizing factors (in both the native and denatured states), which they may also affect.

Changes in global stability and local structure of cytochrome c upon substituting phenylalanine-82 with tyrosine.

We have examined the F82Y;C102T variant of Saccharomyces cerevisiae iso-1-cytochrome c using high-resolution proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, chemical denaturation, and differential scanning calorimetry. Comparison of proton chemical shifts, paramagnetic shifts, and nuclear Overhauser effects indicates structural changes are localized to the vicinity of position 82. One alteration involves the rearrangement of the side chain of leucine-85. Using many more proton assignments than were available in the initial report [G. J. Pielak, R. A. Atkinson, J. Boyd, and R. J. P. Williams, Eur. J. Biochem. 177, 179-185 (1988)], a second alteration involving an interaction between arginine-13 and tyrosine-82 is observed. The interaction appears to involve a hydrogen bond with the eta-protons of arginine's guanido group acting as donor and tyrosine's phenolic eta-oxygen as acceptor. In spite of this potentially-stabilizing interaction, the free energy of denaturation decreases by approximately 2.4 kcal mol-1. Results are discussed with respect to alterations in the native and denatured states.

Introduction of a disulfide bond into cytochrome c stabilizes a compact denatured state.

We introduced a novel disulfide bond, modeled on that of bullfrog cytochrome c, into yeast iso-1-cytochrome c. The disulfide spontaneously forms upon purification. A variety of techniques were used to examine the denaturation of this variant and several non-cross-linked controls. Denaturation is reversible and, with the exception of the protein in which the two cysteines are blocked, consistent with a two-state process. Comparison of the calorimetric and van't Hoff enthalpy changes indicates that denaturation is two-state at pH 4.6. Calorimetric and fluorescence-monitored guanidine hydrochloride (GdnHCl) denaturation data indicate that the free energy of denaturation for the cross-linked protein (delta Gd at 300 K) is decreased relative to non-cross-linked controls. The dependence of delta Gd on GdnHCl concentration, the GdnHCl concentration that denatures half the protein, as well as the enthalpy, entropy, and heat capacity changes (mGdnHCl, Cm, delta Hd, delta Sd, and delta Cp, respectively), all decrease in magnitude upon introduction of the cross-link. The decrease in delta Hd and delta Sd were confirmed by monitoring absorbance at several wavelengths as a function of temperature. The cross-link also decreases the pH dependence of these observables. Circular dichroism studies indicate the denatured state of the cross-linked protein possesses more structure than non-cross-linked proteins, and this structure is refractory to increases in temperature and chemical denaturant. We conclude that the diminished values of delta Gd, delta Hd, delta Sd, delta Cp, and mGdnHCl result from the denatured state of the cross-linked variant being more compact and possessing more structure than non-cross-linked controls.