Structure-Activity Relationship of Flavin Analogues That Target the Flavin Mononucleotide Riboswitch.

The flavin mononucleotide (FMN) riboswitch is an emerging target for the development of novel RNA-targeting antibiotics. We previously discovered an FMN derivative, 5FDQD, that protects mice against diarrhea-causing Clostridium difficile bacteria. Here, we present the structure-based drug design strategy that led to the discovery of this fluoro-phenyl derivative with antibacterial properties. This approach involved the following stages: (1) structural analysis of all available free and bound FMN riboswitch structures; (2) design, synthesis, and purification of derivatives; (3) in vitro testing for productive binding using two chemical probing methods; (4) in vitro transcription termination assays; and (5) resolution of the crystal structures of the FMN riboswitch in complex with the most mature candidates. In the process, we delineated principles for productive binding to this riboswitch, thereby demonstrating the effectiveness of a coordinated structure-guided approach to designing drugs against RNA.

Novel riboswitch-binding flavin analog that protects mice against Clostridium difficile infection without inhibiting cecal flora.

Novel mechanisms of action and new chemical scaffolds are needed to rejuvenate antibacterial drug discovery, and riboswitch regulators of bacterial gene expression are a promising class of targets for the discovery of new leads. Herein, we report the characterization of 5-(3-(4-fluorophenyl)butyl)-7,8-dimethylpyrido[3,4-b]quinoxaline-1,3(2H,5H)-dione (5FDQD)-an analog of riboflavin that was designed to bind riboswitches that naturally recognize the essential coenzyme flavin mononucleotide (FMN) and regulate FMN and riboflavin homeostasis. In vitro, 5FDQD and FMN bind to and trigger the function of an FMN riboswitch with equipotent activity. MIC and time-kill studies demonstrated that 5FDQD has potent and rapidly bactericidal activity against Clostridium difficile. In C57BL/6 mice, 5FDQD completely prevented the onset of lethal antibiotic-induced C. difficile infection (CDI). Against a panel of bacteria representative of healthy bowel flora, the antibacterial selectivity of 5FDQD was superior to currently marketed CDI therapeutics, with very little activity against representative strains from the Bacteroides, Lactobacillus, Bifidobacterium, Actinomyces, and Prevotella genera. Accordingly, a single oral dose of 5FDQD caused less alteration of culturable cecal flora in mice than the comparators. Collectively, these data suggest that 5FDQD or closely related analogs could potentially provide a high rate of CDI cure with a low likelihood of infection recurrence. Future studies will seek to assess the role of FMN riboswitch binding to the mechanism of 5FDQD antibacterial action. In aggregate, our results indicate that riboswitch-binding antibacterial compounds can be discovered and optimized to exhibit activity profiles that merit preclinical and clinical development as potential antibacterial therapeutic agents.

Small molecule fluoride toxicity agonists.

Fluoride is a ubiquitous anion that inhibits a wide variety of metabolic processes. Here, we report the identification of a series of compounds that enhance fluoride toxicity in Escherichia coli and Streptococcus mutans. These molecules were isolated by using a high-throughput screen (HTS) for compounds that increase intracellular fluoride levels as determined via a fluoride riboswitch reporter fusion construct. A series of derivatives were synthesized to examine structure-activity relationships, leading to the identification of compounds with improved activity. Thus, we demonstrate that small molecule fluoride toxicity agonists can be identified by HTS from existing chemical libraries by exploiting a natural fluoride riboswitch. In addition, our findings suggest that some molecules might be further optimized to function as binary antibacterial agents when combined with fluoride.

Design and antimicrobial action of purine analogues that bind Guanine riboswitches.

Riboswitches are structured RNA domains that can bind directly to specific ligands and regulate gene expression. These RNA elements are located most commonly within the noncoding regions of bacterial mRNAs, although representatives of one riboswitch class have been discovered in organisms from all three domains of life. In several Gram-positive species of bacteria, riboswitches that selectively recognize guanine regulate the expression of genes involved in purine biosynthesis and transport. Because these genes are involved in fundamental metabolic pathways in certain bacterial pathogens, guanine-binding riboswitches may be targets for the development of novel antibacterial compounds. To explore this possibility, the atomic-resolution structure of a guanine riboswitch aptamer from Bacillus subtilis was used to guide the design of several riboswitch-compatible guanine analogues. The ability of these compounds to be bound by the riboswitch and repress bacterial growth was examined. Many of these rationally designed compounds are bound by a guanine riboswitch aptamer in vitro with affinities comparable to that of the natural ligand, and several also inhibit bacterial growth. We found that one of these antimicrobial guanine analogues (6-N-hydroxylaminopurine, or G7) represses expression of a reporter gene controlled by a guanine riboswitch in B. subtilis, suggesting it may inhibit bacterial growth by triggering guanine riboswitch action. These studies demonstrate the utility of a three-dimensional structure model of a natural aptamer to design ligand analogues that target riboswitches. This approach also could be implemented to design antibacterial compounds that specifically target other riboswitch classes.

Roseoflavin is a natural antibacterial compound that binds to FMN riboswitches and regulates gene expression.

Riboswitches in messenger RNAs carry receptor domains called aptamers that can bind to metabolites and control expression of associated genes. The Gram-positive bacterium Bacillus subtilis has two representatives of a class of riboswitches that bind flavin mononucleotide (FMN). These riboswitches control genes responsible for the biosynthesis and transport of riboflavin, a precursor of FMN. We found that roseoflavin, a chemical analog of FMN and riboflavin that has antimicrobial activity, can directly bind to FMN riboswitch aptamers and downregulate the expression of an FMN riboswitch-lacZ reporter gene in B. subtilis. A role for the riboswitch in the antimicrobial mechanism of roseoflavin is supported by our observation that some previously identified roseoflavin-resistant bacteria have mutations within an FMN aptamer. Riboswitch mutations in these resistant bacteria disrupt ligand binding and derepress reporter gene expression in the presence of either riboflavin or roseoflavin. If FMN riboswitches are a major target for roseoflavin antimicrobial action, then future efforts to develop compounds that trigger FMN riboswitch function could lead to the identification of new antimicrobial drugs.

Antibacterial lysine analogs that target lysine riboswitches.

Lysine riboswitches are bacterial RNA structures that sense the concentration of lysine and regulate the expression of lysine biosynthesis and transport genes. Members of this riboswitch class are found in the 5' untranslated region of messenger RNAs, where they form highly selective receptors for lysine. Lysine binding to the receptor stabilizes an mRNA tertiary structure that, in most cases, causes transcription termination before the adjacent open reading frame can be expressed. A lysine riboswitch conceivably could be targeted for antibacterial therapy by designing new compounds that bind the riboswitch and suppress lysine biosynthesis and transport genes. As a test of this strategy, we have identified several lysine analogs that bind to riboswitches in vitro and inhibit Bacillus subtilis growth, probably through a mechanism of riboswitch-mediated repression of lysine biosynthesis. These results indicate that riboswitches could serve as new classes of antibacterial drug targets.

Riboswitches as antibacterial drug targets.

New validated cellular targets are needed to reinvigorate antibacterial drug discovery. This need could potentially be filled by riboswitches-messenger RNA (mRNA) structures that regulate gene expression in bacteria. Riboswitches are unique among RNAs that serve as drug targets in that they have evolved to form structured and highly selective receptors for small drug-like metabolites. In most cases, metabolite binding to the receptor represses the expression of the gene(s) encoded by the mRNA. If a new metabolite analog were designed that binds to the receptor, the gene(s) regulated by that riboswitch could be repressed, with a potentially lethal effect to the bacteria. Recent work suggests that certain antibacterial compounds discovered decades ago function at least in part by targeting riboswitches. Herein we will summarize the experiments validating riboswitches as drug targets, describe the existing technology for riboswitch drug discovery and discuss the challenges that may face riboswitch drug discoverers.

A tale of two targets: differential RNA selectivity of nucleobase-aminoglycoside conjugates.

Aminoglycoside antibiotics are RNA-binding polyamines that can bind with similar affinities to structurally diverse RNA targets. To design new semisynthetic aminoglycosides with improved target selectivity, it is important to understand the energetic and structural basis by which diverse RNA targets recognize similar ligands. It is also imperative to discover how novel aminoglycosides could be rationally designed to have enhanced selectivity for a given target. Two RNA drug targets, the prokaryotic ribosomal A-site and the HIV-1 TAR, provide an excellent model system in which to dissect the issue of target selectivity, in that they each have distinctive interactions with aminoglycosides. We report herein the design, synthesis, and binding activity of novel nucleobase-aminoglycoside conjugates that were engineered to be more selective for the A-site binding pocket. Contrary to the structural design, the conjugates bind the A-site more weakly than does the parent compound and bind the TAR more tightly than the parent compound. This result implies that the two RNA targets differ in their ability to adapt to structurally diverse ligands and thus have inherently different selectivities. This work emphasizes the importance of considering the inherent selectivity traits of the RNA target when engineering new ligands.

Conformational constraint as a means for understanding RNA-aminoglycoside specificity.

The lack of high RNA target selectivity displayed by aminoglycoside antibiotics results from both their electrostatically driven binding mode and their conformational adaptability. The inherent flexibility around their glycosidic bonds allows them to easily assume a variety of conformations, permitting them to structurally adapt to diverse RNA targets. This structural promiscuity results in the formation of aminoglycoside complexes with diverse RNA targets in which the antibiotics assume distinct conformations. Such differences suggest that covalently linking individual rings in an aminoglycoside could reduce its available conformations, thereby altering target selectivity. To explore this possibility, conformationally constrained neomycin and paromomycin analogues designed to mimic the A-site bound aminoglycoside structure have been synthesized and their affinities to the TAR and A-site, two therapeutically relevant RNA targets, have been evaluated. As per design, this constraint has minimal deleterious effect on binding to the A-site. Surprisingly, however, preorganizing these neomycin-class antibiotics into a TAR-disfavored structure has no deleterious effect on binding to this HIV-1 RNA sequence. We rationalize these observations by suggesting that the A-site and HIV TAR possess inherently different selectivities toward aminoglycosides. The inherent plasticity of the TAR RNA, coupled to the remaining flexibility within the conformationally constrained analogues, makes this RNA site an accommodating target for such polycationic ligands. In contrast, the deeply encapsulating A-site is a more discriminating RNA target. These observations suggest that future design of novel target selective RNA-based therapeutics will have to consider the inherent "structural" selectivity of the RNA target and not only the selectivity patterns displayed by the low molecular weight ligands.

The structure-function dilemma of the hammerhead ribozyme.

A powerful approach to understanding protein enzyme catalysis is to examine the structural context of essential amino acid side chains whose deletion or modification negatively impacts catalysis. In principle, this approach can be even more powerful for RNA enzymes, given the wide variety and subtlety of functionally modified nucleotides now available. Numerous recent success stories confirm the utility of this approach to understanding ribozyme function. An anomaly, however, is the hammerhead ribozyme, for which the structural and functional data do not agree well, preventing a unifying view of its catalytic mechanism from emerging. To delineate the hammerhead structure-function comparison, we have evaluated and distilled the large body of biochemical data into a consensus set of functional groups unambiguously required for hammerhead catalysis. By examining the context of these functional groups within available structures, we have established a concise set of disagreements between the structural and functional data. The number and relative distribution of these inconsistencies throughout the hammerhead reaffirms that an extensive conformational rearrangement from the fold observed in the crystal structure must be necessary for cleavage to occur. The nature and energetic driving force of this conformational isomerization are discussed.

Using pyrene-labeled HIV-1 TAR to measure RNA-small molecule binding.

To quantitatively understand the binding affinity and target selectivity of small-molecule RNA interactions, it is useful to have a rapid, highly reproducible binding assay that can be readily generalized to different RNA targets. To that end, an assay has been developed and validated for measuring the binding of low-molecular weight ligands to RNA by monitoring the fluorescence of a covalently incorporated fluorophore. As a test system, the fluorescence of a pyrene-derivatized HIV-1 TAR (transactivating response element) RNA was measured upon titration with aminoglycoside antibiotics. The binding isotherms thus obtained fit well with a model for a 1:1 interaction and yield an accurate measure of the equilibrium dissociation constant. Among a series of natural aminoglycosides, the binding affinity correlates with the number of amines, supporting an electrostatic compensation model for binding. Furthermore, the ionic strength dependence confirms that much of the binding energy is electrostatic. Finally, by measuring the binding affinity in the presence of nucleic acid competitors, we confirm that although aminoglycosides show high RNA to DNA selectivity, their selectivity among different RNA targets is sub- optimal. We conclude that this newly developed assay can be generalized to measure the binding affinities and selectivities of a variety of small molecules to a specific RNA target.

Steric interference modification of the hammerhead ribozyme.

Although the structure of the hammerhead ribozyme is well characterized, many questions remain about its catalytic mechanism. Extensive evidence suggests the necessity of a conformational change en route to the transition state. We report a steric interference modification approach for investigating this change. By placing large 2' modifications at residues insensitive to structurally conservative 2'-deoxy modifications, we hoped to discover structural effects distal to the site of modification. Of twenty residues tested, six were identified where the addition of 2' bulk inhibits cleavage, even though these bulky modifications could be accommodated in the crystal structure without steric clash. It is proposed that these 2'-modifications inhibit cleavage by preventing formation of the alternate, active conformation. Since these 2' effects are present in both domain I and domain II of the hammerhead, the entire catalytic core must undergo conformational changes during catalysis.

Internal equilibrium of the hammerhead ribozyme is altered by the length of certain covalent cross-links.

A method was developed that permits covalent cross-links of different linker lengths to be introduced into RNA at defined positions. The previous observation that a cross-link between stems I and II of the hammerhead ribozyme was confirmed and further explored. By examining the catalytic consequences of varying the position and length of this cross-link, we conclude that the previously proposed conformational dampening model cannot sufficiently explain the increase in ligation rate induced by the cross-link. Rather, the cross-link constrains the cleaved hammerhead into a structure that more closely resembles the transition state, thereby increasing the reverse ligation rate relative to a non-cross-linked control.