Structure-based secondary structure-independent approach to design protein ligands: Application to the design of Kv1.2 potassium channel blockers.

We have developed a structure-based approach to the design of protein ligands. This approach is based on the transfer of a functional binding motif of amino acids, often referred as to the "hot spot", on a host protein able to reproduce the functional topology of these residues. The scaffolds were identified by a systematic in silico search in the Protein Data Bank for proteins possessing a group of residues in a topology similar to that adopted by the functional motif in a reference ligand of known 3D structure. In contrast to previously reported studies, this search is independent of the particular secondary structure supporting the functional motif. To take into account the global properties of the host protein, two additional criteria were taken into account in the selection process: (1) Only those scaffolds sterically compatible with the positioning of the functional motif as observed in a reference complex model were retained. (2) Host proteins displaying electrostatic potentials, in the region of the transferred functional motif, similar to that of the reference ligand were selected. This approach was applied to the development of protein ligands of the Kv1.2 channel using BgK, a small protein isolated from the sea anemone Bunodosoma granulifera, as the reference ligand. Four proteins obtained by this approach were produced for experimental evaluation. The X-ray structure of one of these proteins was determined to check for similarity of the transferred functional motif with the structure it adopts in the reference ligand. Three of these protein ligands bind the Kv1.2 channel with inhibition constants of 0.5, 1.5, and 1.6 microM. Several mutants of these designed protein ligands gave binding results consistent with the presumed binding mode. These results show that protein ligands can be designed by transferring a binding motif on a protein host selected to reproduce the functional topology of this motif, irrespective to the secondary structure supporting the functional motif, if the host protein possesses steric and electrostatic properties compatible with the binding to the target. This result opens the way to the design of protein ligands by taking advantage of the considerable structural repertoire of the Protein Data Bank.

Toxicity-based selection of Escherichia coli mutants for functional recombinant protein production: application to an antibody fragment.

We propose a novel approach to the selection of Escherichia coli bacterial strains improved for the production of recombinant functional proteins. This approach is based on aggregation-induced toxicity of recombinant proteins. We show that selection of clones displaying a reduced toxicity is an efficient means of isolating bacteria producing recombinant protein with reduced aggregation in favour of correct folding. For an efficient selection, we found that time of toxicity induction must be precisely determined and recombinant protein must be expressed as a fusion with a protein whose activity is easily detectable on plates, thus allowing elimination of non-productive mutants. Choosing the expression to the periplasmic space of an scFv fragment fused to the N-terminus of alkaline phosphatase as a model, we selected chromosomal mutations that reduce aggregation-induced toxicity and showed that they concomitantly improve production of a functional recombinant hybrid. The effects of the mutations isolated could then be cumulated with those of other strategies used for recombinant scFv production. Thus, we could ensure a 6- to 16-fold increase in production of a functional scFv-PhoA hybrid. This is the first report demonstrating the possibility of directly selecting on agar plates E.coli strains improved for functional recombinant protein production from a large bacterial mutant library.

Artificial evolution of an enzyme active site: structural studies of three highly active mutants of Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase.

The crystal structure of three mutants of Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase with catalytic activity (k(cat)) enhancement as compare to the wild-type enzyme is described in different states. The biological aspects of this study have been reported elsewhere. The structure of the first mutant, D330N, which is threefold more active than the wild-type enzyme, was determined with phosphate in the active site, or with aluminium fluoride, which mimics the transition state. These structures reveal, in particular, that this first mutation does not alter the active site. The second mutant, D153H-D330N, is 17-fold more active than the wild-type enzyme and activated by magnesium, but its activity drops after few days. The structure of this mutant was solved under four different conditions. The phosphate-free enzyme was studied in an inactivated form with zinc at site M3, or after activation by magnesium. The comparison of these two forms free of phosphate illustrates the mechanism of the magnesium activation of the catalytic serine residue. In the presence of magnesium, the structure was determined with phosphate, or aluminium fluoride. The drop in activity of the mutant D153H-D330N could be explained by the instability of the metal ion at M3. The analysis of this mutant helped in the design of the third mutant, D153G-D330N. This mutant is up to 40-fold more active than the wild-type enzyme, with a restored robustness of the enzyme stability. The structure is presented here with covalently bound phosphate in the active site, representing the first phosphoseryl intermediate of a highly active alkaline phosphatase. This study shows how structural analysis may help to progress in the improvement of an enzyme catalytic activity (k(cat)), and explains the structural events associated with this artificial evolution.

Improving Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase efficacy by additional mutations inside and outside the catalytic pocket.

We describe a strategy that allowed us to confer on a bacterial (E. coli) alkaline phosphatase (AP) the high catalytic activity of the mammalian enzyme while maintaining its high thermostability. First, we identified mutations, at positions other than those occupied by essential catalytic residues, which inactivate the bacterial enzyme without destroying its overall conformation. We transferred concomitantly into the bacterial enzyme four residues of the mammalian enzyme, two being in the catalytic pocket and two being outside. Second, the gene encoding the inactive mutant was submitted to random mutagenesis. Enzyme activity was restored upon the single mutation D330N, at a position that is 12 A away from the center of the catalytic pocket. Third, this mutation was combined with other mutations previously reported to increase AP activity slightly in the presence of magnesium. As a result, at pH 10.0 the phosphatase activity of both mutants D330N/D153H and D330N/D153G was 17-fold higher than that of the wild-type AP. Strikingly, although the two individual mutations D153H and D153G destabilize the enzyme, the double mutant D330N/D153G remained highly stable (T(m)=87 degrees C). Moreover, when combining the phosphatase and transferase activities, the catalytic activity of the mutant D330N/D153G increased 40-fold (k(cat)=3200 s-1) relative to that of the wild-type enzyme (k(cat)=80 s-1). Due to the simultaneous increase in K(m), the resulting k(cat)/K(m) value was only increased by a factor of two. Therefore, a single mutation occurring outside a catalytic pocket can dramatically control not only the activity of an enzyme, but also its thermostability. Preliminary crystallographic data of a covalent D330N/D153G enzyme-phosphate complex show that the phosphate group has significantly moved away from the catalytic pocket, relative to its position in the structure of another mutant previously reported.

Do structural deviations between toxins adopting the same fold reflect functional differences?

Three-finger proteins form a structurally related family of compounds that exhibit a great variety of biological properties. To address the question of the prediction of functional areas on their surfaces, we tentatively conferred the acetylcholinesterase inhibitory activity of fasciculins on a short-chain curaremimetic toxin. For this purpose, we assimilated the three-dimensional structure of fasciculin 2 with the one of toxin alpha. This comparison revealed that the tips of the first and second loops, together with the C terminus residue, deviated most. A first recombinant fasciculin/toxin alpha chimera was designed by transferring loop 1 in its entirety together with the tip of loop 2 of fasciculin 2 into the toxin alpha scaffold. A second chimera (rChII) was obtained by adding the point Asn-61 --> Tyr substitution. Comparison of functional and structural properties of both chimeras show that rChII can accommodate the imposed modifications and displays nearly all the acetylcholinesterase-blocking activities of fasciculins. The three-dimensional structure of rChII demonstrates that rChII adopts a typical three-fingered fold with structural features of both parent toxins. Taken together, these results emphasize the great structural flexibility and functional adaptability of that fold and confirm that structural deviations between fasciculins and short-chain neurotoxins do indeed reflect functional diversity.

Molecular and structural basis of the specificity of a neutralizing acetylcholine receptor-mimicking antibody, using combined mutational and molecular modeling analyses.

The antagonist activity of short-chain toxins from snake venoms toward the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) is neutralized upon binding to a toxin-specific monoclonal antibody called Malpha2-3 (1). To establish the molecular basis of this specificity, we predicted from both mutational analyses and docking procedures the structure of the Malpha2-3-toxin complex. From knowledge of the functional paratope and epitope, and using a double-mutation cycle procedure, we gathered evidence that Asp(31) in complementarity determining region 1H is close to, and perhaps interacts with, Arg(33) in the antigen. The use of this pair of proximate residues during the selection procedure yielded three models based on docking calculations. The selected models predicted the proximity of Tyr(49) and/or Tyr(50) in the antibody to Lys(47) in the toxin. This was experimentally confirmed using another round of double-mutation cycles. The two models finally selected were submitted to energy minimization in a CHARMM22 force field, and were characterized by a root mean square deviation of 7.0 +/- 2.9 A. Both models display most features of antibody-antigen structures. Since Malpha2-3 also partially mimics some binding properties of nAChR, these structural features not only explain its fine specificity of recognition, but may also further clarify how toxins bind to nAChR.

Regional and accelerated molecular evolution in group I snake venom gland phospholipase A2 isozymes.

In accordance with detection of a few phospholipase A2 (PLA2) isozyme genes by Southern blot analysis, only two cDNAs, named NnkPLA-I , and NnkPLA-II, encoding group I PLA2s, NnkPLA-I and NnkPLA-II, respectively, were isolated from the venom gland cDNA library of Elapinae Naja naja kaouthia of Malaysia. NnkPLA-I and NnkPLA-II showed four amino acid substitutions, all of which were brought about by single nucleotide substitution. No existence of clones encoding CM-II and CM-III, PLA2 isozymes which had been isolated from the venom of N. naja kaouthia of Thailand, in Malaysian N. naja kaouthia venom gland cDNA library was verified by dot blot hybridization analysis with particular probes. NnkPLA-I and NnkPLA-II differed from CM-II and CM-III with four and two amino acid substitutions, respectively, suggesting that their molecular evolution is regional. The comparison of NnkPLA-I, NnkPLA-II and cDNAs encoding other group I snake venom gland PLA2s indicated that the 5'- and 3'-untranslated regions are more conserved than the mature protein-coding region and that the number of nucleotide substitutions per nonsynonymous site is almost equal to that per synonymous site in the protein-coding region, suggesting that accelerated evolution has occurred in group I venom gland PLA2s possibly to acquire new physiological functions.

Stability of a structural scaffold upon activity transfer: X-ray structure of a three fingers chimeric protein.

Fasciculin 2 and toxin alpha proteins belong to the same structural family of three-fingered snake toxins. They act on different targets, but in each case the binding region involves residues from loops I and II. The superimposition of the two structures suggests that these functional regions correspond to structurally distinct zones. Loop I, half of loop II and the C-terminal residue of fasciculin 2 were therefore transferred into the toxin alpha. The inhibition constant of the resulting chimera is only 15-fold lower than that of fasciculin 2, and as expected the potency of binding to the toxin alpha target has been lost. In order to understand the structure-function relationship between the chimera and its "parent" molecules, we solved its structure by X-ray crystallography. The protein crystallized in space group P3(1)21 with a=b=58.5 A, and c=62.3 A. The crystal structure was solved by molecular replacement and refined to 2.1 A resolution. The structure belongs to the three-fingered snake toxin family with a core of four disulphide bridges from which emerge the three loops I, II and III. Superimposition of the chimera on fasciculin 2 or toxin alpha revealed an overall fold intermediate between those of the two parent molecules. The regions corresponding to toxin alpha and to fasciculin 2 retained their respective geometries. In addition, the chimera protein displayed a structural behaviour similar to that of fasciculin 2, i.e. dimerization in the crystal structure of fasciculin 2, and the geometry of the region that binds to acetylcholinesterase. In conclusion, this structure shows that the chimera retains the general structural characteristics of three-fingered toxins, and the structural specificity of the transferred function.

Recombinant single-chain Fv antibody fragment-alkaline phosphatase conjugate for one-step immunodetection in molecular hybridization.

Using phage-display technology, a recombinant single-chain Fv antibody fragment (scFv) was rapidly generated from the K16-16 hybridoma secreting mouse monoclonal antibody (MAb) that binds to acetylaminofluorene-labeled DNA (AAF-DNA). The selected A4 phage-scFv specifically bound to AAF-DNA. The anti-AAF scFv gene was then recloned into a fusion vector for the production of a hybrid protein comprising the antibody fragment fused to a potent bacterial alkaline phosphatase variant (PhoAv). The anti-AAF scFv-PhoAv hybrid protein was bifunctional and possessed both antigen binding capacity and PhoA activity. The recombinant conjugate was directly used, without further purification, for one-step immunodetection in dot-blot hybridization. The detection limit was identical and the test was quicker than the conventional two-step procedure with the purified anti-AAF MAb revealed with a secondary enzyme-labeled antibody. To assess the value of this new reagent for the immunodetection of genomic nucleic acids, genomic DNAs of Campylobacter jejuni and Campylobacter coli were then one-step immunodetected with non-purified recombinant scFv-PhoAv conjugate in a Southern-blot hybridization experiment. The present study shows that the genetic fusion with PhoAv provides a new tool for immunodetection which presents easier and quicker production and use with the same sensitivity and specificity as classical reagents. The recombinant anti-AAF scFv-PhoAv conjugate is a promising alternative reagent for applications involving the immunodetection of specific DNA or RNA sequences, such as the detection and characterization of microorganisms.

Increasing immunogenicity of antigens fused to Ig-binding proteins by cell surface targeting.

Fusion of antigenic proteins to Ig-binding proteins such as protein A from Staphylococcus aureus and its derived ZZ fragment is known to increase immunogenicity of the fused Ag in vivo. To shed light on the origin of this effect, we used snake toxins as Ags and observed that 1) fusion of toxins to ZZ enhanced their presentation to a toxin-specific T cell hybridoma (T1B2), using A20 B lymphoma cells, splenocytes, or peritoneal exudate cells as APCs; 2) this enhancement further increased when the number of fused Ig-binding domains varied from two with ZZ to five with protein A; and 3) the phenomenon vanished when the fusion protein was preincubated with an excess of free ZZ or when P388D1 monocytes cells were used as APCs. Therefore, ZZ-fused toxins are likely to be targeted to surface Igs of APCs by their ZZ moiety. Furthermore, ZZ-alpha and toxin alpha stimulated similar profiles of toxin-specific T cells in BALB/c mice, suggesting a comparable processing and presentation in vivo for both toxin forms. To improve the targeting efficiency, ZZ-alpha was noncovalently complexed to various Igs directed to different cell surface components of APCs. The resulting complexes were up to 10(3)-fold more potent than the free toxin at stimulating T1B2. Also, they elicited both a T cell and an Ab response in BALB/c mice, without the need of any adjuvant. This simple approach may find practical applications by increasing the immunogenicity of recombinant proteins without the use of adjuvant.

Molecular evolution of snake toxins: is the functional diversity of snake toxins associated with a mechanism of accelerated evolution?

Recent studies revealed that animal toxins with unrelated biological functions often possess a similar architecture. To tentatively understand the evolutionary mechanisms that may govern this principle of functional prodigality associated with a structural economy, two complementary approaches were considered. One of them consisted of investigating the rates of mutations that occur in cDNAs and/or genes that encode a variety of toxins with the same fold. This approach was largely adopted with phospholipases A2 from Viperidae and to a lesser extent with three-fingered toxins from Elapidae and Hydrophiidae. Another approach consisted of investigating how a given fold can accommodate distinct functional topographies. Thus, a number of topologies by which three-fingered toxins exert distinct functions were investigated either by making chemical modifications and/or mutational analyses or by studying the three-dimensional structure of toxin-target complexes. This review shows that, although the two approaches are different, they commonly indicate that most if not all the surface of a snake toxin fold undergoes natural engineering, which may be associated with an accelerated rate of evolution. The biochemical process by which this phenomenon occurs remains unknown.

The functional architecture of an acetylcholine receptor-mimicking antibody.

Malpha2-3 is a monoclonal antibody that partially mimics the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR). Its three-dimensional structure has been previously predicted by molecular modeling, suggesting that 29 complementarity determining region (CDR) residues and 2 framework residues are exposed to solvent. To identify the antibody residues that bind to the antigen, i.e. snake toxin that binds specifically to AChR, we (i) produced the scFv form of Malpha2-3 fused to alkaline phosphatase, in the periplasmic space of Escherichia coli; (ii) submitted approximately 75% of exposed residues of the fused scFv to individual or combined mutations, and (iii) identified the residues whose mutations affect scFv binding to the toxin, using a sensitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. 11 critical residues were identified, including 8 heavy chain residues, 2 framework residues, and 1 light chain residue. They cover a surface of approximately 800 A2, with a subset of most critical residues (VHD31, VHY32, and VHG101) and several aromatic residues. This functional architecture not only constitutes a plausible complementary binding surface for the snake toxin but also offers a structural basis to ultimately understand the capacity of the antibody to partially mimic AChR.

High-level production and isotope labeling of snake neurotoxins, disulfide-rich proteins.

The aim of this work was to produce and to label snake neurotoxins, disulfide-rich proteins. A mutant of a snake toxin, erabutoxin a, was used as a model. Its N-terminal part was fused to ZZ, a synthetic IgG-binding domain of protein A (B. Nilsson et al., 1987, Protein Eng. 1, 107-113), thus preventing degradation in the bacterial cytoplasm and providing a simple affinity-purification method on IgG Sepharose. A soluble fusion protein was obtained with a yield of 60 mg/L, corresponding to 20 mg/L toxin. The toxin moiety was folded on the column while the hybrid was still bound. The oxidoreducing conditions for the refolding were optimized and were found to be oxidative but with a need for reducing molecules. The concentration of the hybrid bound to the column could be increased up to 3.3 mg/ml without significantly altering the folding process. CNBr cleavage of the fusion protein followed by a purification step yielded about 2 mg of biologically active toxin mutant per gram of dry cell weight. This procedure was applied to produce 55 mg of a toxin uniformly labeled with 15N.

Complete amino-acid sequence of the beta-subunit of VTX from venom of the stonefish (Synanceia verrucosa) as identified from cDNA cloning experiments.

A cDNA encoding a subunit of the verrucotoxin (VTX) has been identified from a cDNA library derived from stonefish venom glands. It encodes a polypeptide of 708 amino-acid residues, followed by a 3'-untranslated region of 895 bp long. The ORF contains the complete mature sequence of the beta-subunit of the VTX, as inferred from both the presence of an identical N-terminus sequence and 96% homology among the 506 amino terminus residues found in the partial sequence of the beta-subunit of the stonustoxin from Synanceia horrida (Ghadessy, F.J., Jeyaseelan, K., Chung, M.C.M., Khoo, H.E., and Yuen, R. (1994) Toxicon 32, 1684-1688). Upstream the mature sequence, we noticed the presence of an incomplete peptide of a 13 amino acids, whose unusual primary structure supports the idea of the existence of a propeptide and/or of a new secretion signal.

Transformation of a non-enzymatic toxin into a toxoid by genetic engineering.

Curaremimetic toxins are typical non-enzymatic toxins that bind to their target [the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR)] through multiple residues. Nevertheless, we show that the concomitant substitutions of only three of the ten functionally important residues of such a toxin sufficed to cause an affinity decrease of the toxin for AChR that is higher than four orders of magnitude. Despite these triple mutations, the overall conformation of the mutated protein remains similar to that of a related recombinant toxin, as judged from both circular dichroism analysis and investigation of antigenicity, using monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies. Furthermore, we show that the detoxified toxin is capable of eliciting antibodies that neutralize the binding of a wild-type toxin to AChR. Therefore, transformation of a non-enzymatic toxin into a toxoid can be achieved, like in the case of enzymatic toxins, by introducing a small number of mutations at positions identified to be critical for expression of toxicity.

Mimicry between receptors and antibodies. Identification of snake toxin determinants recognized by the acetylcholine receptor and an acetylcholine receptor-mimicking monoclonal antibody.

In several instances, a monoclonal antibody raised against a receptor ligand has been claimed to mimic the ligand receptor. Thus, a specific monoclonal antibody (Malpha2-3) raised against a short-chain toxin from snake was proposed to mimic the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) (). Further confirming this mimicry, we show that (i) like AChR, Malpha2-3 elicits anti-AChR antibodies, which in turn elicit anti-toxin antibodies; and (ii) the region 106-122 of the alpha-chain of AChR shares 66% primary structure identity with complementarity-determining regions of Malpha2-3. Also, a mutational analysis of erabutoxin a reveals that the epitope recognized by Malpha2-3 consists of 10 residues, distributed within the three toxin loops. Eight of these residues also belong to the 10-residue epitope recognized by AChR, a result that offers an explanation as to the functional similarities between the receptor and the antibody. Strikingly, however, most of the residues common to the two epitopes contribute differentially to the energetic formation of the antibody-toxin and the receptor-toxin complexes. Together, the data suggest that the mimicry between AChR and Malpha2-3 is partial only.

Engineering of a recombinant colorimetric fusion protein for immunodiagnosis of insulin.

A synthetic DNA encoding human proinsulin was inserted in frame in the bacterial alkaline phosphatase gene. A homogeneous recombinant human proinsulin-alkaline phosphatase conjugate was obtained directly from the periplasm of Escherichia coli transformed with a plasmid carrying the hybrid gene. The recombinant conjugate was stable and could be produced in the bacteria. The immunological properties of the recombinant conjugate and those of the human insulin and human proinsulin were compared using a panel of six different human insulin-specific monoclonal antibodies. Three immunological groups were thus distinguished and one of them indiscriminately recognized all of the insulin-like molecules. One monoclonal antibody from this group was used in combination with the recombinant conjugate to develop successfully a competitive immunoenzymatic assay for detecting insulin.

A recombinant insect-specific alpha-toxin of Buthus occitanus tunetanus scorpion confers protection against homologous mammal toxins.

We have constructed a cDNA library from venom glands of the scorpion Buthus occitanus tunetanus and cloned a DNA sequence that encodes an alpha-toxin. This clone was efficiently expressed in Escherichia coli as a fusion protein with two Ig-binding (Z) domains of protein A from Staphylococcus aureus. After CNBr treatment of the fusion protein and HPLC purification, we obtained approximately 1 mg recombinant apha-toxin/l bacterial culture. The toxin, called Bot XIV, displays no toxicity towards mammals but is active towards insects as shown by its paralytic activity against Blatella germanica cockroach and by electrophysiological studies on Periplaneta americana cockroaches. The Bot XIV protein fused to two Z domains is highly immunogenic in mice and induces production of antisera that specifically recognize and neutralize highly toxic components that had been injected into mice. This fusion protein could be very useful for development of potent protective antisera against scorpion venoms.

Genetic engineering of snake toxins. The functional site of Erabutoxin a, as delineated by site-directed mutagenesis, includes variant residues.

Using site-directed mutagenesis, we previously identified some residues that probably belong to the site by which Erabutoxin a (Ea), a sea snake toxin, recognizes the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AcChoR) (Pillet, L., Trémeau, O., Ducancel, F. Drevet, P., Zinn-Justin, S., Pinkasfeld, S., Boulain, J.-C., and Ménez, A. (1993) J. Biol. Chem. 268, 909-916). We have now studied the effect of mutating 26 new positions on the affinity of Ea for AcChoR. The mutations are F4A, N5V, H6A, Q7L, S9G, Q10A, P11N, Q12A, T13V, T14A, K15A, T16A, delta S18, E21A, Y25F, Q28A, S30A, T35A, I36R, P44V, T45A, V46A, K47A, P48Q, I50Q, and S53A. Binding affinity decreases upon mutation at Gln-7, Gln-10 and to a lesser extent at His-6, Ser-9 and Tyr-25 whereas it increases upon mutation at Ile-36. Other mutations have no effect on Ea affinity. In addition, new mutations of the previously explored Ser-8, Asp-31, Arg-33, and Glu-38 better explain the functional role of these residues in Ea. The previous and present mutational analysis suggest that the "functional" site of Ea covers a homogeneous surface of at least 680 A2, encompassing the three toxin loops, and includes both conserved and variant residues. The variable residues might contribute to the selectivity of Ea for some AcChoRs, including those from fish, the prey of sea snakes.