ABSTRACT
In this experimental study, the initial phase involved preparing composite structures with various mix ratios using the Ti-6Al-4V alloy, widely used in clinical applications, in conjunction with ZrO2 and hydroxyapatite (HA) synthesized via the precipitation method, employing powder metallurgy techniques. Subsequently, the microstructures of the resultant hybrid composite materials were imaged, and x-ray diffraction (XRD) phase analyses were conducted. In the final phase of the experimental work, tests were performed to determine the biocompatibility properties of the hybrid composites. For this purpose, cytotoxicity and genotoxicity assays were carried out. The tests and examinations revealed that structures compatible both morphologically and elementally were obtained with no phase transformations that could disrupt the structure. The incorporation of ZrO2 into the Ti-6Al-4V alloy was observed to enhance cell viability values. The value of 98.25 ± 0.42 obtained by adding 20% ZrO2 gave the highest cell viability result. The addition of HA into the hybrid structures further increased the cell viability values by approximately 10%. All viability values for both HA-added and HA-free groups were obtained above the 70% viability level defined in the standard. According to the genotoxicity test results, the highest cytokinesis-block proliferation index values were obtained as 1.666 and 0.620 in structures containing 20% ZrO2 and 10% ZrO2 + 10% HA, respectively. Remarkably, all fabricated composite and hybrid composite materials surpassed established biocompatibility standards and exhibited nontoxic and nongenotoxic properties. This comprehensive study contributes vital insights for future biomechanical and other in vitro and in vivo experiments, as it meticulously addresses fundamental characterization parameters crucial for medical device development. RESEARCH HIGHLIGHTS: Support of optimum doping rates ions on hybrid composites and concentrations. Development of uniform surface appearance and distributions/orientations of microcrystals on ceramic compounds Improvement of cell viability and desired increase in biocompatibility with the doping of HA.
ABSTRACT
This multidisciplinary study examined sensitively the change in the dynamics of main mechanical performance, stability of crystal structure, crystallinity quality, strength, corrosion resistance, biocompatibility, resistance to structural degradation/separations and mechanical durability features of hydroxyapatite (HAp) biomedical materials based on the fluorine addition and degradation process to guide future medical and dental treatment studies. In the study, the fluorine ions were used to be the dental coating, filling and supporting material for biologically or synthetically produced bone minerals. The general characteristic properties were investigated by means of standard spectroscopic, structural and mechanical analysis methods including RAMAN, SEM-EDS, TEM, Vickers micro-indentation hardness and density measurements. A time dependent release test was performed to evaluate possible fluorine ion release after the degradation process. It was found that the fundamental characteristic properties of HAp biomedical materials are noted to improve with the increase in the fluoride level up to 2% due much more stabilization of HAp crystal system. The combination of RAMAN spectra and powder XRD analyzes indicates that 2% addition level affects positively the formation velocity of characteristic HAP phase. Besides, fluorine doped HAp materials all exhibited the main characteristic peaks after degradation process. This is attributed to the fact that the fluorine ions enabled the hydroxyapatite to enhance the structural quality and stability towards the corrosion environment. However, in case of excess dopant level of 3% the degradation rates were obtained to increase due to higher contribution rate and especially electrostatic interactions. As for the surface morphology examinations, 2% fluorine added HAp with the highest density of 3.0879 g/cm3 was determined to present the superior crystallinity quality (smallest grain size, best smooth surface, honeycomb pattern, regular shaped particles and densest particle distributions through the specimen surface). Conversely, the excess fluorine triggered to increase seriously degree of micro/macro porosity in the surface morphology and microscopic structural problems in the crystal system. Thus, the HAp doped with 3% was the most affected material from the degradation process. Additionally, the fluorine ion values read after the release process were quite far from the value that could cause toxic effects. Lastly, the optimum fluorine addition provides the positive effects on the highest durability, stiffness and mechanical fracture strength properties as a consequence of differentiation in the surface residual compressive stress regions (lattice strain fields), amplification sites and active operable slip systems in the matrix. Hence, the crack propagations prefer to proceed in the transcrystalline regions rather than the intergranular parts. Similarly, it was found that Vickers micro-indentation hardness tests showed that the microhardness parameters increased after the degradation process. All in all, the fluorine addition level of 2% was noted to be good choice to improve the fundamental characteristic properties of hydroxyapatite biomedical materials for heavy-duty musculoskeletal, orthopedic implant, biological and therapeutic applications in medicine and dentistry application fields.
