Two year comparison of sevelamer and calcium carbonate effects on cardiovascular calcification and bone density.

BACKGROUND: Calcium-based phosphate binders may induce tissue calcification, and little is known about their effects on bone density. We compared the effects of a calcium with a non-calcium phosphate binder on both arterial calcification and bone density measured by computed tomography. METHODS: Seventy-two adult haemodialysis patients were randomized to treatment with calcium carbonate (CC) or sevelamer (SEV) for 2 years. Electron beam CT scans were performed at baseline and at 6, 12 and 24 months. Serum phosphorus, calcium, calcium x phosphorus product and intact parathyroid hormone (iPTH) were measured and other routine laboratory tests were also carried out. RESULTS: The average calcium x phosphorus product was similar in the two treatment groups. However, patients receiving CC had significantly lower average iPTH (P<0.01), were more likely to have hypercalcaemic episodes (P = 0.03) and had significantly greater increases in coronary artery (CC median 484, P<0.0001, SEV median 37, P = 0.3118, between-group P = 0.0178) and aortic (CC median 610, P = 0.0003, SEV median 0, P = 0.5966, between-group P = 0.0039) calcification scores. The CC group also had a significant decrease in trabecular bone density (CC median -6%, P = 0.0049, SEV median +3%, P = 0.0296, between-group P = 0.0025). However, there was no significant difference in cortical bone density between the two groups. CONCLUSIONS: This 2 year study shows that calcium carbonate use is continuously associated with progressive arterial calcification in haemodialysis patients. In addition, it suggests that it is also associated with decreased trabecular bone density. However, this latter finding requires confirmation by a study specifically devoted to this issue.

Decrease in thoracic vertebral bone attenuation with calcium-based phosphate binders in hemodialysis.

UNLABELLED: We performed a post hoc analysis of a 52-week randomized trial conducted in adult hemodialysis patients that compared the effects of calcium-based phosphate binders and sevelamer, a nonabsorbable polymer, on parameters of mineral metabolism and vascular calcification by electron beam tomography. In this analysis, we evaluated the relative effects of calcium and sevelamer on thoracic vertebral attenuation by CT and markers of bone turnover. Subjects randomized to calcium salts experienced a significant reduction in trabecular bone attenuation and a trend toward reduction in cortical bone attenuation, in association with higher concentrations of serum calcium, lower concentrations of PTH, and reduced total and bone-specific alkaline phosphatase. INTRODUCTION: In patients with chronic kidney disease, hyperphosphatemia is associated with osteodystrophy, vascular and soft tissue calcification, and mortality. Calcium-based phosphate binders are commonly prescribed to reduce intestinal phosphate absorption and to attenuate secondary hyperparathyroidism. Clinicians and investigators have presumed that, in hemodialysis patients, calcium exerts beneficial effects on bone. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We performed a post hoc analysis of a 52-week randomized trial conducted in adult hemodialysis patients that compared the effects of calcium-based phosphate binders and sevelamer, a nonabsorbable polymer, on parameters of mineral metabolism and vascular calcification by electron beam tomography. In this analysis, we evaluated the relative effects of calcium and sevelamer on thoracic vertebral attenuation by CT and markers of bone turnover. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: The average serum phosphorus and calcium x phosphorus products were similar for both groups, although the average serum calcium concentration was significantly higher in the calcium-treated group. Compared with sevelamer-treated subjects, calcium-treated subjects showed a decrease in thoracic vertebral trabecular bone attenuation (p = 0.01) and a trend toward decreased cortical bone attenuation. More than 30% of calcium-treated subjects experienced a 10% or more decrease in trabecular and cortical bone attenuation. On study, sevelamer-treated subjects had higher concentrations of total and bone-specific alkaline phosphatase, osteocalcin, and PTH (p < 0.001). When used to correct hyperphosphatemia, calcium salts lead to a reduction in thoracic trabecular and cortical bone attenuation. Calcium salts may paradoxically decrease BMD in hemodialysis patients.