Chondral defects in animal models: effects of selected repair procedures in canines.

The defect made to the level of the tidemark in a canine model has been used in several prior investigations of various articular cartilage repair procedures. Direct comparison of the repair method, 15 weeks postoperatively, showed a significant correlation between the degree to which the calcified cartilage layer and subchondral bone were disrupted and the amount of tissue filling. Moreover, when it forms, hyaline cartilage most frequently occurs superficial to intact calcified cartilage. Many of the chondrocytic cells and fibroblasts expressed the gene for a contractile muscle actin, alpha-smooth muscle actin. However, the role of this actin isoform is yet in question. These findings may inform future strategies for cartilage repair.

Autologous chondrocyte implantation in a canine model: change in composition of reparative tissue with time.

The objective of the study was to evaluate the tissue types filling 4-mm diameter defects in the canine trochlear groove 1.5, 3, and 6 months after autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI). Untreated defects served as controls. Periosteum alone controls were also included at the 1.5-month time period. The results were compared with previously published findings obtained 12 and 18 months postoperative. After 3 months the ACI-treated defects contained significantly more reparative tissue than found in the untreated control group, including twice the amount of hyaline cartilage (HC). These findings, however, were the only significant effects of the ACI treatment when compared to the periosteum alone or empty control groups. The benefits of ACI found at 3 months did not persist to longer time periods. An evaluation of the inter-observer error associated with the histomorphometric method indicated that it was generally less than the inter-animal variation in the results.

Healing of canine articular cartilage defects treated with microfracture, a type-II collagen matrix, or cultured autologous chondrocytes.

The effects of three different treatments on the healing of articular cartilage defects were compared with use of a previously developed canine model. In the articular surface of the trochlear grooves of 12 adult mongrel dogs, two 4-mm-diameter defects were made to the depth of the tidemark. Four dogs were assigned to each treatment group: (a) microfracture treatment, (b) microfracture with a type-II collagen matrix placed in the defect, and (c) type-II matrix seeded with cultured autologous chondrocytes. After 15 weeks, the defects were studied histologically. Data quantified on histological cross sections included areal or linear percentages of specific tissue types filling the defect, integration of reparative tissue with the calcified and the adjacent cartilage, and integrity of the subchondral plate. Total defect filling (i.e., the percentage of the cross-sectional area of the original defect filled with any type of reparative tissue) averaged 56-86%, with the greatest amount found in the dogs in the microfracture group implanted with a type-II collagen matrix. The profiles of tissue types for the dogs in each treatment group were similar: the tissue filling the defect was predominantly fibrocartilage, with the balance being fibrous tissue. There were no significant differences in the percentages of the various tissue types among dogs in the three groups.

Articular cartilage chondrocytes in type I and type II collagen-GAG matrices exhibit contractile behavior in vitro.

Natural healing of articular cartilage defects generally does not occur, and untreated lesions may predispose the joint to osteoarthritis. To promote healing of cartilage defects, many researchers are turning toward a tissue engineering approach involving cultured cells and/or porous, resorbable matrices. This study investigated the contractile behavior of cultured canine chondrocytes seeded in a porous collagen-glycosaminoglycan (GAG) scaffold. Chondrocytes isolated from the knee joints of adult canines and expanded in monolayer culture were seeded into porous collagen-GAG scaffolds. Scaffolds were of two different compositions, with the predominant collagen being either type I or type II collagen, and of varying pore diameters. Over the 4-week culture period, the seeded cells contracted all of the type I and type II collagen-based matrices, despite a wide range of stiffness (145 +/- 23 Pa, for the type I scaffold, to 732 +/- 35 Pa, for the type II material). Pore diameter (25-85 microm, type I; and 53-257 microm, type II) did not affect cell-mediated contraction. Immunohistochemical staining revealed the presence of alpha-smooth muscle actin, an isoform responsible for contraction of smooth muscle cells and myofibroblasts, in the cytoplasm of the seeded cells and in chondrocytes in normal adult canine articular cartilage.

Healing of defects in canine articular cartilage: distribution of nonvascular alpha-smooth muscle actin-containing cells.

The objective of this study was to evaluate the types of tissue resulting from spontaneous healing of surgically created defects in adult canine articular cartilage up to 29 weeks postoperatively, with specific attention directed toward the presence and distribution of cells containing the contractile actin isoform, alpha-smooth muscle actin. Two 4-mm diameter defects were made in the trochlear groove to the depth of the tidemark in 20 adult mongrel dogs. The areal percentage of specific tissue types in the reparative material was determined histomorphometrically. Immunohistochemistry was employed to evaluate the percentage of alpha-smooth muscle actin-containing cells. The results showed that approximately 50% of the chondrocytes in the superficial zone of the uninvolved articular cartilage expressed alpha-smooth muscle actin. A significantly lower percentage of alpha-smooth muscle actin-positive chondrocytes appeared in the uninvolved deep zone. Notably, the deep zone adjacent to the defect contained a greater percentage of such cells than in the uninvolved deep zone. Also of interest was that a greater percentage of nonvascular cells in the hyaline cartilage and fibrocartilage of the reparative tissue contained alpha-smooth muscle actin-positive cells, compared to the fibrous tissue in the defects. The findings of this study revealed that canine articular cartilage has some potential for spontaneous regeneration, including integration with the calcified cartilage zone. By 29 weeks, up to 40% of an areal cross section of an untreated full-thickness chondral defect was found to fill with hyaline cartilage, with up to 19% judged histologically similar to articular cartilage. The results warrant further consideration of the role of alpha-smooth muscle actin in chondrocytes in normal articular cartilage and in reparative tissue.

alpha-smooth muscle actin and contractile behavior of bovine meniscus cells seeded in type I and type II collagen-GAG matrices.

Many types of injuries to the meniscus of the knee joint result in defects that do not heal, leading to pain and dysfunction. Several ongoing investigations are developing porous absorbable matrices to be used alone or seeded with cultured cells to facilitate regeneration of this tissue. The objective of this study was to evaluate in vitro the contractile behavior of meniscal cells seeded in type I and type II collagen matrices. In many connective tissues, fibroblasts that have assumed a contractile phenotype (myofibroblasts) have been found to play an important role in healing and in pathological conditions. This phenotype, if expressed by meniscal cells, could affect their behavior in cell-seeded matrices developed for tissue engineering. In this study, the presence of a contractile actin isoform, alpha-smooth muscle (alpha-SM) actin, was assessed by immunohistochemistry in normal calf meniscal tissue and in meniscal cells in 2- and 3-dimensional culture. Calf meniscus cells were seeded in type I and type II collagen-glycosaminoglycan (GAG) matrices. The diameter of the matrices was measured every 2-3 days. Immunohistochemical staining of the 2-dimensional cultures for alpha-SM actin was performed after 1, 3, and 7 days and the staining of the seeded matrices was at 1, 7, 14, and 21 days. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) was performed on selected samples. After 3 weeks the seeded type I matrices displayed a significant shrinkage of almost 50% whereas the type II matrix and both types of unseeded controls showed almost no contraction over the same time period. Positive staining for the alpha-SM actin phenotype was seen in 10% of the cells of the normal tissue but was present in all cells seeded in monolayer and in both types of matrices. TEM of representative cell-seeded matrices showed microfilaments approximately 7 nm thick, consistent with the myofibroblast phenotype. This is the first report of alpha-SM actin containing cells in the knee meniscus. The finding that, under certain conditions, meniscal cells can express the myofibroblast phenotype warrants study of their role in meniscal healing and the tissue response to implants to facilitate tissue regeneration.

Meniscus cells seeded in type I and type II collagen-GAG matrices in vitro.

The objective of this study was to determine the proliferative and biosynthetic activity of calf meniscus cells seeded in type I and type II collagen-glycosaminoglycan (GAG) copolymers with the overall goal to develop a cell-seeded implant for future investigations to improve the regeneration of the knee meniscus. The cell-seeded matrices were digested in protease and analyzed for GAG by a modification of the dimethyl-methylene blue method and assayed for DNA content. Other specimens were evaluated histologically after 1, 7, 14 and 21 days. Contraction of the same types of matrices, seeded with adult canine meniscus cells, was measured at the same time points. After three weeks, cells were observed throughout the type II matrix, whereas the type I matrix was densely populated at the margins. The cell morphology and the cell density after three weeks in both matrices was consistent with the normal meniscus. DNA assay for the type I matrix showed a 40% decrease over the first week and a final amount of DNA that was not significantly different from the initial value, whereas the type II matrix doubled its DNA content over the same time period. The cells continued their biosynthesis of GAG and type I collagen. GAG content of the type II matrix increased by 50% more than the type I matrix after three weeks. Over the same time period, the type I matrix displayed a significant shrinkage to approximately 50% of its initial value whereas in contrast, the type II matrix and the unseeded controls showed no significant shrinkage. The number of cells and the higher GAG synthesis in the type II matrix, and its resistance to cell-mediated contracture, commend it for future investigation of the regeneration of meniscus in vivo.

Chondrocyte-seeded collagen matrices implanted in a chondral defect in a canine model.

The objective of our study was to evaluate reparative tissues formed in chondral defects in an adult canine model implanted with cultured autologous articular chondrocytes seeded in type I and II collagen GAG matrices. Two defects were produced in the trochlea grooves of the knees of 21 dogs, with cartilage removed down to the tidemark. This study includes the evaluation of 36 defects distributed among five treatment groups: Group A, type II collagen matrix seeded with autologous chondrocytes under a sutured type II collagen flap; Group B, type I collagen matrices seeded with chondrocytes under a sutured fascia flap; Group C, unseeded type I collagen matrix implanted under a sutured fascia flap; Group D, fascia lata flap alone; and Group E, untreated defects. All animals were killed 15 weeks after implantation. Six other defects were created at the time of death and evaluated immediately after production as 'acute defect controls'. In three additional defects, unseeded matrices were sutured to the defect and the knee closed and reopened after 30 min to determine if early displacement of the graft was occurring; these defects served as 'acute implant controls'. The areal percentages of four tissue types in the chondral zone of the original defect were determined histomorphometrically: fibrous tissue (FT); hyaline cartilage (HC); transitional tissue (TT, including fibrocartilage); and articular cartilage (AC). New tissue formed in the remodeling subchondral bone underlying certain defects was also assessed. Bonding of the repair tissue to the subchondral plate and adjacent cartilage, and degradation of the adjacent tissues were evaluated. There were no significant differences in the tissues filling the original defect area of the sites treated with chondrocyte-seeded type I and type II matrices. Most of the tissue in the area of the original defect in all of the groups was FT and TT. The areal percentage of HC plus AC was highest in group E, with little such tissue in the cell-seeded groups, and none in groups C and D. The greatest total amount of reparative tissue, however, was found in the cell-seeded type II matrix group. Moreover, examination of the reparative tissue formed in the subchondral region of defects treated with the chondrocyte-seeded collagen matrices (Groups A and B) demonstrated that the majority of the tissue was positive for type II collagen and stained with safranin O. These results indicate an influence of the exogenous chondrocytes on the process of chondrogenesis in this site. In all groups with implants (A-D), 30(50% of the FT and TT was bonded to the adjacent cartilage. Little of this tissue (6-22%) was attached to the subchondral plate, which was only about 50% intact. Remarkable suture damage was found in sections from each group in which sutures were used. Harvest sites showed no regeneration of normal articular cartilage, 18 weeks after the biopsy procedure. Future studies need to investigate other matrix characteristics, and the effects of cell density and incubation of the seeded sponges prior to implantation on the regenerative response.

Effect of cultured autologous chondrocytes on repair of chondral defects in a canine model.

Articular cartilage has a limited capacity for repair. In recent clinical and animal experiments, investigators have attempted to elicit the repair of defects of articular cartilage by injecting cultured autologous chondrocytes under a periosteal flap (a layer of periosteum). The objective of the present study was to determine the effect of cultured autologous chondrocytes on healing in an adult canine model with use of histomorphometric methods to assess the degree of repair. A total of forty-four four-millimeter-diameter circular defects were created down to the zone of calcified cartilage in the articular cartilage of the trochlear groove of the distal part of the femur in fourteen dogs. The morphology and characteristics of the original defects were defined in an additional six freshly created defects in three other dogs. Some residual noncalcified articular cartilage, occupying approximately 2 per cent of the total cross-sectional area of the defect, was sometimes left in the defect. The procedure sometimes damaged the calcified cartilage, resulting in occasional microfractures or larger fractures, thinning of the zone of calcified cartilage, or, rarely, small localized penetrations into subchondral bone. The forty-four defects were divided into three treatment groups. In one group, cultured autologous chondrocytes were implanted under a periosteal flap. In the second group, the defect was covered with a periosteal flap but no autologous chondrocytes were implanted. In the third group (the control group), the defects were left empty. The defects were analyzed after twelve or eighteen months of healing. Histomorphometric measurements were made of the percentage of the total area of the defect that became filled with repair tissue, the types of tissue that filled the defect, and the integration of the repair tissue with the adjacent cartilage at the sides of the defects and with the calcified cartilage at the base of the defect. In histological sections made through the center of the defects in the three groups, the area of the defect that filled with new repair tissue ranged from a mean total value of 36 to 76 per cent, with 10 to 23 per cent of the total area consisting of hyaline cartilage. Integration of the repair tissue with the adjacent cartilage at the edges of the defect ranged from 16 to 32 per cent in the three groups. Bonding between the repair tissue and the calcified cartilage at the base of the defect ranged from 41 to 89 per cent. With the numbers available, we could detect no significant difference among the three groups with regard to any of the parameters used to assess the quality of the repair. In the two groups in which a periosteal flap was sutured to the articular cartilage surrounding the defect, the articular cartilage showed degenerative changes that appeared to be related to that suturing.

Canine chondrocytes seeded in type I and type II collagen implants investigated in vitro.

Synthetic and natural absorbable polymers have been used as vehicles for implantation of cells into cartilage defects to promote regeneration of the articular joint surface. Implants should provide a pore structure that allows cell adhesion and growth, and not provoke inflammation or toxicity when implanted in vivo. The scaffold should be absorbable and the degradation should match the rate of tissue regeneration. To facilitate cartilage repair the chemical structure and pore architecture of the matrix should allow the seeded cells to maintain the chondrocytic phenotype, characterized by synthesis of cartilage-specific proteins. We investigated the behavior of canine chondrocytes in two spongelike matrices in vitro: a collagen-glycosaminoglycan (GAG) copolymer produced from bovine hide consisting of type I collagen and a porous scaffold made of type II collagen by extraction of porcine cartilage. Canine chondrocytes were seeded on both types of matrices and cultured for 3 h, 7 days, and 14 days. The histology of chondrocyte-seeded implants showed a significantly higher percentage of cells with spherical morphology, consistent with chondrocytic morphology, in the type II sponge at each time point. Pericellular matrix stained for proteoglycans and for type II collagen after 14 days. Biochemical analysis of the cell seeded sponges for GAG and DNA content showed increases with time. At day 14 there was a significantly higher amount of DNA and GAG in the type II matrix. This is the first study that directly compares the behavior of chondrocytes in type I and type II collagen matrices. The type II matrix may be of value as a vehicle for chondrocyte implantation on the basis of the higher percentage of chondrocytes retaining spherical morphology and greater biosynthetic activity that was reflected in the greater increase of GAG content.

Matrix collagen type and pore size influence behaviour of seeded canine chondrocytes.

This study directly compared the behaviour of chondrocytes in porous matrices comprising different collagen types and different pore diameters. There was a dramatic difference in the morphology of the cells in the type I and type II collagen matrices. The cells in the type II collagen matrix retained their chondrocytic morphology and synthesized glycosaminoglycans, while in the type I matrix the chondrocytes displayed a fibroblastic morphology with less biosynthetic activity than those in the type II. Small pore diameter affected morphology initially in the type I matrices and showed a higher increase of DNA content, but with time the cells lost the chondrocytic morphology. Our results demonstrate the marked influence of collagen type and pore characteristics on the phenotypic expression of seeded chondrocytes.