ABSTRACT
Operando characterization can reveal degradation processes in battery materials and are essential for the development of battery chemistries. This study reports the first use of quasi-simultaneous operando pair distribution function (PDF) and X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) of a battery cell, providing a detailed, atomic-level understanding of the cycling mechanism of Bi2MoO6 as an anode material for Na-ion batteries. This material cycles via a combined conversion-alloying reaction, where electrochemically active, nanocrystalline Na x Bi particles embedded in an amorphous Na-Mo-O matrix are formed during the first sodiation. The combination of operando PDF and XAS revealed that Bi obtains a positive oxidation state at the end of desodiation, due to formation of Bi-O bonds at the interface between the Bi particles and the Na-Mo-O matrix. In addition, XAS confirmed that Mo has an average oxidation state of +6 throughout the (de)sodiation process and, thus, does not contribute to the capacity. However, the local environment of Mo6+ changes from tetrahedral coordination in the desodiated state to distorted octahedral in the sodiated state. These structural changes are linked to the poor cycling stability of Bi2MoO6, as flexibility of this matrix allows movement and coalescence of the Na x Bi particles, which is detrimental to the electrochemical stability.
ABSTRACT
Development of new anode materials for Na-ion batteries strongly depends on a detailed understanding of their cycling mechanism. Due to instrumental limitations, the majority of mechanistic studies focus on operando materials' characterization at low cycling rates. In this work, we evaluate and compare the (de)sodiation mechanisms of BiFeO3 in Na-ion batteries at different current densities using operando X-ray diffraction (XRD) and ex situ X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS). BiFeO3 is a conversion-alloying anode material with a high initial sodiation capacity of â¼600 mAh g-1, when cycled at 0.1 A g-1. It does not change its performance or cycling mechanism, except for minor losses in capacity, when the current density is increased to 1 A g-1. In addition, operando XRD characterization carried out over multiple cycles shows that the Bi â NaBi (de)alloying reaction and the oxidation of Bi at the interface with the Na-Fe-O matrix are detrimental for cycling stability. The isolated NaBi â Na3Bi reaction is less damaging to the cycling stability of the material.
ABSTRACT
Based on the same rocking-chair principle as rechargeable Li-ion batteries, Na-ion batteries are promising solutions for energy storage benefiting from low-cost materials comprised of abundant elements. However, despite the mechanistic similarities, Na-ion batteries require a different set of active materials than Li-ion batteries. Bismuth molybdate (Bi2MoO6) is a promising NIB anode material operating through a combined conversion/alloying mechanism. We report anoperandox-ray diffraction (XRD) investigation of Bi2MoO6-based anodes over 34 (de)sodiation cycles revealing both basic operating mechanisms and potential pathways for capacity degradation. Irreversible conversion of Bi2MoO6to Bi nanoparticles occurs through the first sodiation, allowing Bi to reversibly alloy with Na forming the cubic Na3Bi phase. Preliminary electrochemical evaluation in half-cellsversusNa metal demonstrated specific capacities for Bi2MoO6to be close to 300 mAh g-1during the initial 10 cycles, followed by a rapid capacity decay.OperandoXRD characterisation revealed that the increased irreversibility of the sodiation reactions and the formation of hexagonal Na3Bi are the main causes of the capacity loss. This is initiated by an increase in crystallite sizes of the Bi particles accompanied by structural changes in the electronically insulating Na-Mo-O matrix leading to poor conductivity in the electrode. The poor electronic conductivity of the matrix deactivates the NaxBi particles and prevents the formation of the solid electrolyte interface layer as shown by post-mortem scanning electron microscopy studies.