Why is it so difficult to derive pluripotent stem cells in domestic ungulates?

Pluripotent stem cells are the focus of an extremely active field of investigation that is bringing new light on our understanding of the mechanisms that control pluripotency and differentiation. Rodent and primates are the only species where true, or bona fide, pluripotent stem cells have been derived. The attempts to derive pluripotent stem cells from domestic ungulates have been going on for more than 20 years with little progress. Cell lines from these species present a series of limitations that have precluded their use for both basic and clinically oriented studies. However, in the last 3 years, some substantial progress have been made making the currently available ungulate pluripotent stem cells closest than ever before to their human and mouse counterpart. This result has been achieved through both conceptual and technical progress that will be illustrated and discussed in this review.

Pluripotency network in porcine embryos and derived cell lines.

Huge amounts of work have been dedicated to the establishment of embryonic stem cell lines from farm animal species since the successful isolation of embryonic stem cells from the mouse and from the human. However, no conclusive results have been obtained so far, and validated lines have yet to be established in domestic animals. Many limiting factors have been suggested and need to be studied further to isolate truly pluripotent cell lines from livestock. In this review, we will discuss the difficulties in deriving and maintaining embryonic stem cell lines from farm animal embryos and how can this lack of success be explained. We will summarize results obtained in our laboratory regarding derivation of pluripotent cells in the pigs. Problems related to the identification of standard methods for derivation, maintenance and characterization of cell lines will also be examined. We will focus our attention on the need for appropriate stemness-related marker molecules that can be used to reliably investigate pluripotency in domestic species. Finally, we will review data presently available on functional key pluripotency-maintaining pathways in farm animals.