Enhancing nursing documentation in Kazakhstan: assessing utilization and standardization for improving patient care.

Background and aim: This article stresses the importance of comprehensive nursing documentation in scientific medicine and discusses the adoption of standardized terminologies in Europe. The study also presents findings from a cross-sectional study conducted in Kazakhstan, assessing the utilization of standard operating procedures and nursing documentation in various clinical scenarios. The aim was evaluate the level of use of the form of nursing documentation and Standard Operating Procedure within the framework of reforming the Republic of Kazakhstan. Materials and methods: During the period from December 2021 to February 2022, a cross-sectional study was conducted in Kazakhstan, involving a randomly selected sample of nurses with technical and vocational education as well as those with applied/academic baccalaureate degrees in nursing. Results: In this cross-sectional study of 2,263 female nurses, 75.3% were nurse practitioners, and 44% held the highest qualification category. Awareness levels varied, with around 64.7% aware of the pilot program for care services, 65.8% aware of the deputy head position, and 73.8% familiar with the "extended practice nurse" role. Only 55.2% knew about the International Clinical Nursing Classification, and 54.5% observed changes in their nursing approach due to education. The limb edema measurement checklist was not used by the majority (88.4%) of respondents, and 68% did not utilize the antibiotic susceptibility testing checklist. Various other checklists and algorithms had limited utilization, with percentages ranging from 9.1 to 69.3%, indicating varying levels of adoption among participants. For assisting children with cerebral palsy, the "Assessment of hand use capacity according to the MACS classification system" was utilized by 9.1%, while 90.9% did not employ it. In the context of communication, 30.7% of the respondents utilized the "Algorithm of actions of a medical registrar when communicating with a patient," while 69.3% did not use it. These findings highlight variable adoption rates among participants for these medical procedures and protocols. Conclusion: In Kazakhstan, nursing documentation forms and Standard Operating Procedures face challenges and limited utilization, but their implementation has shown positive impacts on patient care and healthcare outcomes. Overcoming resistance to change, increasing awareness, and addressing resource constraints are essential for further improvement.

Cost-Effectiveness of Cardioverter-Defibrillator Implantation in Kazakhstan.

Abstract: Cardiovascular disease is the leading cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide. The implementation of effective technologies such as Implantable cardioverter-defibrillator (ICD) for patients at risk of sudden cardiac death requires additional health system resources. Objective: To assess the economic effectiveness of ICD in comparison with conservative tactics for preventing life-threatening rhythm disturbances in Kazakhstan. Methods: A Markov model was built with a time horizon of 35 years. Mortality and utility data were obtained from the available literature. The economic parameters of the model are based on the approved tariffs for medical services in Kazakhstan and clinical protocols. Following WHO recommendations, a willingness to pay threshold of three times gross domestic product per capita was used to assess cost-effectiveness. A discount rate of 3.5% was applied to both costs and benefits. To deal with parameter uncertainties and to provide robust analysis, a probabilistic sensitivity analysis was performed, randomly varying all inputs subject to uncertainty assuming a statistical distribution. Results: The total costs in the primary prevention (PP) group by ICD implantation and in the control group were 8,903,786 tenges and 3,194,414 tenges, respectively. The discounted total quality-adjusted life-years saved (QALYs) in the ICD and control groups were 6.48 and 4.98, respectively. The indicator of incremental cost-effectiveness ratio amounted to3791604 tenge, which is below the willingness to pay threshold and indicates the cost-effectiveness of using ICD as a PP strategy in patients with sudden cardiac death risk factors in the health care of Kazakhstan. Conclusion: The ICD for the primary prevention of the development of life-threatening rhythm disturbances and sudden cardiac death is a cost-effective health technology from the position of a payer in the health care system of Kazakhstan.

The diagnostic accuracy of spirometry versus peak expiratory flow test for follow-up of adult asthma patients at primary care level.

Background: The asthma burden is growing worldwide, and this is predisposed by environmental and occupational exposures as well as individual risk factors. This study was aimed at a comparison of diagnostic accuracy of spirometry and peak expiratory flow rate (PEFR) in asthma screening of adult patients with lung function abnormalities that present at the level of primary care. Methods: This study was conducted in Shymkent city, South Kazakhstan, the third most populous city of the country with developed industries and high rates of pulmonary diseases. Four hundred and ninety-five adult patients with lung function abnormalities were enrolled in the study and underwent two screening tests (spirometry and PEFR). The diagnosis of asthma was verified by a qualified pulmonologist after performance of screening tests and was based on symptoms, medical history, and laboratory and lung function tests. Results: The sensitivity of spirometry was 0.97 and that of PEFR was 0.95 (p = 0.721), whereas the specificity of spirometry was 0.37 and that of PEFR was 0.28 (p = 0.227). Both tests yielded the same results for the positive predictive value (0.98). The negative predictive value was significantly higher for spirometry versus PEFR (0.23 versus 0.08; p = 0.006). The positive and negative likelihood ratios of the two tests also differed significantly (p = 0.001 and p = 0.006, respectively), whereas the overall accuracy was comparable between the two tests (0.96 for spirometry and 0.94 for PEFR; p = 0.748). Conclusion: Ambulatory PEFR monitoring is non-inferior to the monitoring of the forced expiratory volume in 1 second and could be used for screening purposes on equal grounds with spirometry.

Implantation of Implantable Cardioverter Defibrillators in Kazakhstan.

Background and Objectives: Implantation of implantable cardioverter-defibrillators (ICD) has increased significantly over the past decade. However, limited data exist regarding practices and policies of ICD implantations in Kazakhstan. We aimed to provide an overview of the current use of ICD in Kazakhstan. Methods: Using the Unified Healthcare Information System database of the entire Kazakh adult population, statistical and cost data of ICD implantations in 2017-2019 were evaluated. Cardiologists and electrophysiologists working in cardio surgery centers and departments were asked to go through an online survey focused on subcutaneous-ICD (S-ICD) experience. Results: Implantation of traditional transvenous cardioverter-defibrillators for residents of Kazakhstan is fully reimbursed. A total of 2,263 ICD interventions (2,252 new implantations and 11 reimplantations) were performed across the country during the study period. According to the tariffs approved by the Ministry of Health, the reimbursement cost for one ICD case is about 14,061.80 US dollars. The survey showed that only two hospitals have implanted S-ICDs. Among the main reasons why S-ICD is not widely used in the country the following were named: lack of trained staff (61.1% of respondents); the cost of device and lack of reimbursement (38.7%); and lack of pacing function (27.8%). Conclusion: The number of ICD implantation in Kazakhstan is steadily continuing to grow, although, compared to developed countries, the implantation rate especially for S-ICD remains low. There is a need in deliberate strategies to remove policy barriers for implementation the most innovative cardiac implantable electronic devices implantations such as S-ICD in the country.